Yummies Ice Cream

12 Center St, Warsaw
(585) 786-0430

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Marian Bauer

Great ice cream. Wonderful place to stop. Cheerful.

mel marie

Amazing in both hard and soft serve.
This ice cream is straight up amazing
It also comes in a huge array of interesting flavors.
If you don't believe me when it comes to how good this is, you need only visit or on a sunny day..
The line sometimes goes out of the parking lot.
The only sad part is it closes in the winter, so get there before mid October or you'll have to wait for spring...

Colleen Michalczak

Always friendly. Well organized. When busy they get your order while you're waiting inline with your car. So when you pull up the wait is not long. I am going to try all flavors this season.

Madelaine Martin

I’ve had some amazing ice cream and this isn’t tops for me. It’s fine. Got the mint fudge hard ice cream and the mint flavor was very mild, and it was a tad watery/icy. Like it didn’t have enough fat in it, or it had too much air? Hard to explain but it didn’t have that dense mouth feel. When I get a hard ice cream cone, I should be able to bite into it! This was too soft to do so, and there was no delay in me trying it. She scooped it, handed it to me, and I started in on it. Maybe they’re trying to save money and stretch ingredients, but there was so many of these weird fudge bites in it, those must cost a decent amount? It said the mix ins were an assortment of chocolate things, but all I could taste were fudge bites, and they barely tasted like chocolate. I think the quality, despite being homemade, is just not there. Maybe I got a bad batch, but this tasted like supermarket ice cream to me. If I’m getting a cone, I really want that rich mouthfeel. Bummer!

Rebecca Harvey

The best homemade ice-cream with tons of flavors, lots of choices on size, reasonable prices, really good homemade waffle cones and a great vibe. A very popular place, both with the locals and with tourists and those passing through on Rte 20A. There’s a drive-through and patio seating. Well worth making the stop during their season between March and October!

Nancy Lesswing

Homemade ice cream, great flavors too! Great service
They use real fruit in their milkshakes

Hossein Zolfaghari

Best ice cream ive ever had and we only found it because we took a wrong turn on a roadtrip and got lost. Absolutely huge serving sizes and great flavors. I’ll come back one day…

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

eric whiting

Love the ice cream !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Santosh GS

WARNING!!! GIGANTIC ICE CREAMS AHEAD! We had a large Max Black Peanut Butter Attack which is described as award winning and it was delicious! Should have gone for a medium but hey, YOLO?! Nice place to hang out too. Get the waffle cone!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Waffle, Max Black PB Attack

Sofia Chiarandini

Insane custard, interesting flavor choices. I like you very much. Drive thru especially convenient.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream, Cookie Monster

KATHLEEN HARTMANS

So in on our way thru warsaw and were delighted by the ice cream. The portions and the price!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stacey DeVaney

Fantastic ice cream

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sofía Wyner Chiarandini

Insane custard, interesting flavor choices. I like you very much. Drive thru especially convenient.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream, Cookie Monster

Brittney Starr

Great dietary restriction friendly menu! Dairy free! Gluten free! Nut free! Sugar free! Options for everyone!

Dietary restrictions: Options for everyone!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Melissa Savoy

Portion sizes are enormous! If you think you want a medium, get a small. Trust me.

Loading...