Yummies Ice Cream

12 Center St, Warsaw
(585) 786-0430

Recent Reviews

Mary P

Went here with some friends to get ice cream!! I got the chocolate + strawberry ice cream. You get your own ice cream (you can choose multiple!), with whatever toppings you'd like, and pay by the weight! There are many options of ice creams and toppings for anyone to enjoy :) Mine was about 7 dollars and it filled me up.Dietary restrictions: There are gluten free and lactose free options!Parking: There are some cute shops around!! Easy parking to walk where you'd like to go

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream, Strawberry Sundae

Jodi C.

Friendly, good service. They have vegan/nondairy options too! Get the coffee ice cream if you enjoy coffee.

Harry Rezzemini

Home made and, indeed, YUMMY!

Rich Pembrock

Made it just before the end of season..great flavors nice vibes good service

Shirl N.

The best homemade hard ice cream I've had in the US! Good sized scoops and great service! I will definitely be coming back.

J. C.

Tasty custard swirl and hard-pack cones and cups were had here. Friendly service, too. It's a nice dessert stop; we were here for a few days just before their closing in October and enjoyed their ice cream several nights after dinner.

Sarah Beana

Their icecream is fantastic and if you have any sort of food allergies THIS is the place for you! Allergens are clearly noted, no need to ask, and their accommodations are phenomenal (ask for a GLUTEN FREE waffle cone!)! Portions are LARGE to say the least, so be prepared. Cute and friendly outdoor space to enjoy your treat, and they also have a drive-thru.

Will Emeny

Generous ice cream sizes. Favorite one of my visit was the cantaloupe ice cream.

Crystal Knowles

First time visiting this icecream shop. The icecream is pretty amazing. We got the PB signature Sundae and the PB Sundae both where amazing. Best vanilla icecream I have had yet. Definitely a must try!

Stephan Penke

Maybe the best ice cream I had on all of my worldwide travels..a must go and worth driving a long way

Takumi Otsuka

Tl;dr - Good ice cream, bad experienceGirlfriend and I stopped through on a drive, got a waffle bowl w/ Max Black PB Attack and a waffle cone w/ Cherry. Ice cream was delicious, portion sizes generous, staff friendly.Unfortunately, the bottom of the waffle bowl was accompanied by a very strong and bitter chemical taste, which was hard to wash out and ruined the experience. A follow-up call w/ Yummies points to residual dish soap on the tool used to press the waffle bowls as the likely culprit.We are not local, but we pass through the area annually, and while this was an unfortunate first experience with Yummies, I would still consider stopping by again (the ice cream really is very good). Might skip the waffle bowl next year though...

Perfectly Gorgeous (GorgeouslyCrafted)

First time going there NO ONE got there until we did , the girl was basically trying to rush us to order which is not easy when they offer so many different things , customer service is key and worrying about the customer INFRONT of you should be your main priority NOT the ones behind because when they get their turn they are not going to want to be rushed ESPECIALLY when it's your family's first time somewhere and MIND you we drove 1hour and 20 minutes just to try it.

wilson chong

Im 47 years old and this is the best Ice Cream I've ever had, anywhere, in my life. Stopped here coming home from Niagara. If I ever go back to Niagara I'm stopping here for more hand dipped ice cream. Incredible.

Joe clancy

Cool little joint we stopped at for ice cream on our way up to Toronto on motorcycles.

Brandy Bovee

Great ice cream. Cool little ice cream shack with a drive-through. I had the muddy frog....it was soooo yummy!

Load More