The new restaurant Prime 36 opened and I was disappointed. For the price one would expect an exceptional meal. Met some friends who just finished and they said their steak was undercooked. We received the same undercooked steak and we asked it for it to be done medium. The surf part of the meal was not Maine Lobster and it was just ok a bit dry. The salad and dessert was very good but if you bill yourself as a steakhouse you should be able to cook a steak according to preference. The bar area is very nicely redone and the place was packed. I would order a chicken dish next time.
Ben McCool
Excellent food, good service. NYC-level pricing was a mild surprise, but the experience justified it. Thanks for the superb birthday meal!
ESB NYC
This was a last minute selection for a Saturday evening dinner. While I thought our entrées were generally pretty tasty, in the end this is basically run-of-the-mill red sauce, Italian at a pretty high price for the area. The calamari appetizer that we shared was most likely frozen, and seemed to be a little well-done. two of us had the chicken Albonetti, which we enjoyed my husband had the short ribs which he enjoyed very much but at $38 it is really fully priced.Also…We were told that the entrées came with potatoes and vegetables, but there were no vegetables served. There was another strange issue when we paid the bill, we were five people and one person was paying for three on his credit card and I was paying for two people on my credit card, but they couldn’t figure out how to handle it. The final insult is that they add a 3.5% surcharge if you pay with a credit card. Obviously in this day and age everybody pays with a credit card so it is pretty shady to add this on top of your final dinner bill. If your restaurant is performing that poorly, raise your prices a little bit to cover the cost of credit cards and don’t insult your customers with a surcharge.Sorry to say, but this place seems like it’s on its last legs.
Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari
Shannon Early
We had a lovely Valentines dinner at The Warwick Inn. I had the veal martini and he had the chicken francaise...both were absolutely delicious. Portion size was perfect. I read some of the poor reviews about the service. We found the service just fine however, there is a more laid back European vibe. I enjoyed not feeling rushed or bothered throughout our meal. Was a perfect dining experience.
James Fitzgerald
I cannot rave enough about the Warwick Inn. Jimmy, Aldo, and his staff are top notch. The food is always delicious, timely, and the staff is wonderful. It has been the favorite place of me and my family for many years.
Ellen Linden
I have been here with my husband very often and decided to come back again with a group of friends for dinner. Staff, service and food are amazing. I work as an advertisement specialist and the only remark I find it weird is the restaurant's social media pages, which look like "European tour guide" where owners expose trips, lakes and waterfalls instead of food. As a specialist on the field I would suggest you to advertise your business not your lifestyle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
556richm
My wife and I drive over an hour to enjoy this charming restaurant whenever possible. The food and service is always outstanding and we love the classic Inn atmosphere. We both enjoyed their fabulous stuffed pork chops and calamari as well a nice wine served by a kind / caring staff . This particular visit was especially important for us since it was my wife MaryAnn’s birthday and they made it special for her . Extra special thanks to Nick the host who made it extra special for us with his kindness ,humor and efficiency. We can’t wait to return.
Michael Shulz
We know Jimmy and his family for many years and he never changes. A humble worker and owner. Everytime we come here we experience a great and warm hospitality.We've been coming here since it was "The Dautaj" and they never ceaze to amaze us. Delicious food and very professional service. Our waiter was well spoken and very patient. Thank you for making our night guys !
Rich Meyer
We had an early dinner yesterday at the Warwick Inn. Our table was next to fireplace, which was lit and perfectly accommodating for my girlfriend after a day at the farm. Aldo took our order, and gave us suggestions and Sabina (hopefully that’s her name), was over the top incredible, attentive and always there when needed. The food was awesome, and the atmosphere of the Inn was splendid with lots of character… We extremely liked the place and the whole experience… Highly recommended
victor sprague
Very good food and excellent service can't wait to go back
My husband and I went there and it was the best meal we have had in a while. The staff was very friendly yet professional. They managed to make us feel welcomed, made us laugh, but still let us have a romantic meal. The food was delicious and the plating itself was quite beautiful. We will definitely be going back.
Phillip Cocoliato
The decor was rustic and comfy, and the waitstaff were very friendly and accommodating. The food however was not the greatest. I was expecting a higher level of cuisine for the price tag. We went on a Sunday evening and we were a bit disappointed based on all the hype. I will have to try again, and I will ammend this review to the upside if the experience changes.
Cheryl Pangaro
Food, service and coctails were great. Sitting on the porch made it extra special. Was a perfect day.
Don Wycoff
The owners are extremely nice. The view in amazing! I love this place!!
Peter M
We come here twice a year. The food is always great. The help can sometimes vary but most often good servers. Great ambience, very elegant house and porch, The Scallop with whipped mashed potatoes is amazing. The Scallops melt in your mouth. MMMMM. If the weather is good sit outside but if you sit outside, do also walk around inside so you can see the interior Victorian architecture.
The new restaurant Prime 36 opened and I was disappointed. For the price one would expect an exceptional meal. Met some friends who just finished and they said their steak was undercooked. We received the same undercooked steak and we asked it for it to be done medium. The surf part of the meal was not Maine Lobster and it was just ok a bit dry. The salad and dessert was very good but if you bill yourself as a steakhouse you should be able to cook a steak according to preference. The bar area is very nicely redone and the place was packed. I would order a chicken dish next time.
Excellent food, good service. NYC-level pricing was a mild surprise, but the experience justified it. Thanks for the superb birthday meal!
This was a last minute selection for a Saturday evening dinner. While I thought our entrées were generally pretty tasty, in the end this is basically run-of-the-mill red sauce, Italian at a pretty high price for the area. The calamari appetizer that we shared was most likely frozen, and seemed to be a little well-done. two of us had the chicken Albonetti, which we enjoyed my husband had the short ribs which he enjoyed very much but at $38 it is really fully priced.Also…We were told that the entrées came with potatoes and vegetables, but there were no vegetables served. There was another strange issue when we paid the bill, we were five people and one person was paying for three on his credit card and I was paying for two people on my credit card, but they couldn’t figure out how to handle it. The final insult is that they add a 3.5% surcharge if you pay with a credit card. Obviously in this day and age everybody pays with a credit card so it is pretty shady to add this on top of your final dinner bill. If your restaurant is performing that poorly, raise your prices a little bit to cover the cost of credit cards and don’t insult your customers with a surcharge.Sorry to say, but this place seems like it’s on its last legs.
Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari
We had a lovely Valentines dinner at The Warwick Inn. I had the veal martini and he had the chicken francaise...both were absolutely delicious. Portion size was perfect. I read some of the poor reviews about the service. We found the service just fine however, there is a more laid back European vibe. I enjoyed not feeling rushed or bothered throughout our meal. Was a perfect dining experience.
I cannot rave enough about the Warwick Inn. Jimmy, Aldo, and his staff are top notch. The food is always delicious, timely, and the staff is wonderful. It has been the favorite place of me and my family for many years.
I have been here with my husband very often and decided to come back again with a group of friends for dinner. Staff, service and food are amazing. I work as an advertisement specialist and the only remark I find it weird is the restaurant's social media pages, which look like "European tour guide" where owners expose trips, lakes and waterfalls instead of food. As a specialist on the field I would suggest you to advertise your business not your lifestyle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
My wife and I drive over an hour to enjoy this charming restaurant whenever possible. The food and service is always outstanding and we love the classic Inn atmosphere. We both enjoyed their fabulous stuffed pork chops and calamari as well a nice wine served by a kind / caring staff . This particular visit was especially important for us since it was my wife MaryAnn’s birthday and they made it special for her . Extra special thanks to Nick the host who made it extra special for us with his kindness ,humor and efficiency. We can’t wait to return.
We know Jimmy and his family for many years and he never changes. A humble worker and owner. Everytime we come here we experience a great and warm hospitality.We've been coming here since it was "The Dautaj" and they never ceaze to amaze us. Delicious food and very professional service. Our waiter was well spoken and very patient. Thank you for making our night guys !
We had an early dinner yesterday at the Warwick Inn. Our table was next to fireplace, which was lit and perfectly accommodating for my girlfriend after a day at the farm. Aldo took our order, and gave us suggestions and Sabina (hopefully that’s her name), was over the top incredible, attentive and always there when needed. The food was awesome, and the atmosphere of the Inn was splendid with lots of character… We extremely liked the place and the whole experience… Highly recommended
Very good food and excellent service can't wait to go back
Restaurantji Recommends
My husband and I went there and it was the best meal we have had in a while. The staff was very friendly yet professional. They managed to make us feel welcomed, made us laugh, but still let us have a romantic meal. The food was delicious and the plating itself was quite beautiful. We will definitely be going back.
The decor was rustic and comfy, and the waitstaff were very friendly and accommodating. The food however was not the greatest. I was expecting a higher level of cuisine for the price tag. We went on a Sunday evening and we were a bit disappointed based on all the hype. I will have to try again, and I will ammend this review to the upside if the experience changes.
Food, service and coctails were great. Sitting on the porch made it extra special. Was a perfect day.
The owners are extremely nice. The view in amazing! I love this place!!
We come here twice a year. The food is always great. The help can sometimes vary but most often good servers. Great ambience, very elegant house and porch, The Scallop with whipped mashed potatoes is amazing. The Scallops melt in your mouth. MMMMM. If the weather is good sit outside but if you sit outside, do also walk around inside so you can see the interior Victorian architecture.
Loading...