Guilty Pleasures Cheesecakes

Best Apple pies I've ever had!! If you're in Washingtonville NY do yourself a favor and get a pie you won't be disappointed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheesecake, Italian Cheesecakes with Fresh Mixed Berries, Five Layer Peach Cake, Cannoli Cheesecake, Rainbow Cookies, Brownie Explosion

I came in the day before Thanksgiving for an apple crumb pie and said I hadn't found anything that could compare to what my favorite orchard had in the past. Well you changed that!! It was delicious!!! And I'm so glad I went for the bigger one instead of the small size 🤣. I wish I had a photo to post but there isn't much left

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Guilty Pleasure Cheesecakes deserves all the stars! ⭐️
Patrick was amazing in helping me connect with Justine — and she is truly phenomenal. She created a baklava cheesecake for the first time, and it was an absolute hit. Everyone loved it, and it tasted just as incredible as it looked!

Thank you for helping create such a beautiful memory for my team and me. I will definitely be ordering again!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

You will always find something different at Guilty Pleasure . I just tried the pumpkin cannoli, which was fantastic. Definitely a must try when you visit. The staff was friendly and the atmosphere is just as different as the menu!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I absolutely love everything about Guilty Pleasures!! Justine & Patrick are amazing. Their space is so unique. They have such creativity!! Please go check them out if you haven't already.

A friend and I visited here for the first time together for coffee and a pastry. On recommendation I had a peach blueberry muffin that blew me away. Fruit was fresh and local, crumble on top perfectly finished, and the muffin must have been about half fruit, moist but did not fall apart. Then! I left my bag behind by mistake! And when I went back I just had to buy another muffin, and a cobbler bar to boot. Staff were very attentive, funny, friendly, quick, and helpful. I love the decor, I could stare at the neat vintage ceiling fan forever if it wouldn't hold up the line! Great little outdoor seating area with umbrella, indoor atmosphere is vintage, playful, and mischievous - like you stepped into an old toy chest in the attic, and there's also a delicious bakery inside! Loved it. Kids would love this place for a treat and a little toy!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Everything is so delicious and it keeps changing with more variety
Owners are super nice and friendly
Like walking into an old country store. It’s worth the trip from anywhere!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheesecake, Five Layer Blueberry Creme Cake

Amazing desserts, made by amazing people! Dubai chocolates that are out of this world and sait Mary's pastries, that will blow your mind! Highly recommended visiting Guilty Pleasures!

Cheesecakes awesome must try!! so much more then Cheesecakes need to see!!

Best cheesecake , Italian Rainbow Cookie Latte in existence. Stop in every time I’m in the area for the best cheesecake and playlists are also second to none.

This place is amazing! Wonderful people, always something new to eat, and it’s all homemade goodness 👍

Perfect cheesecake, a big variety, outstanding service. Yes you can order any cheesecake flavor you want. Love the place

They have a great selection of candy from back in the 1980/1990. Prices are a little bit on the high side but it’s still worth it. Definitely worth coming back. The cheesecake selection was minimal.

Delicious cheesecakes , a wonderful birthday pleasure

Has the Best Drinks And Sandwiches ive had in ages