The Milk Pail

1346 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill
(631) 537-2565

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Alfred Santos

We were looking for a place to get some apples and jams before heading back home and found this gem.

Kinjal Parikh

All different types and sizes of pumpkin.

Tarun Dangayach

Amazing

Sarah Halsey

I am a regular customer, I go in every weekend for cider and sweeties and apples. It is a bright spot in my life. Everyone is so kind and happy, go the extra mile in taking care of you. Jen and Amy are the best. The other ladies are too. Thank you so much. I recommend highly. 100 points. ❤️❤️❤️

Arielle Hochman

Cute roadside farmstand but staff are not friendly or welcoming. Overpriced but that's to be expected in the area. Would not allow me to throw away a tissue and empty bottle as they "cannot accept outside garbage". Pies were "baked yesterday".

Oscar gonzalez

This is a great shop, especially in the summer. Now on the winter is a bit more limited but still plenty of unique options. If you are in the neighborhood, please stop by. And sometimes they have gallery showings to support local artists. It is a but pricey but worth the quality.

D Hillis

Great assortment of apples and delightful Apple Cider Donuts!!

Danielle Russo

This place is so charming. It has locally produced goodies. The candles smell amazing. Definitely stop in.

Lynda Goldberg

Charged for a bag. Cider and donuts excellent!

Heather Gallagher

Super cute! Nice selection of baked goods and local provisions. The some cider donuts were delicious!

BuscemibTb

Spectacular apple cider donuts and great people. Highly recommend.

reed karen

Great place. Best apples on the East End

Vernette Sylvester

Great visit getting some fun snacks

Tarra Sams

They have a huge selection and they are very helpful and professional

Donaldo Yanez

Exelestly

Loading...