Nickel's Pit BBQ Watkins Glen
207 N Franklin St, Watkins Glen
(607) 210-4646
Customers' Favorites
Carolina Pulled Pork Sandwich
Beef Brisket and Pulled Pork
Brisket Lovers Combo
Pulled Pork Nachos
Loaded Tater Tots
Pulled Pork Combo
Deep Fried Pickles
Brisket Sandwich
Chopped Brisket
Southern Greens
Menu
Photos
+42 photos
+41 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Came here on a whim while on vacation, Incredible. Started the night with the pickle platter. It’s worth every penny if you are a fan of pickled things. The jalapeno pickles were my favorite of the bunch. Went with the burntendwich and it did not disappoint! Incredibly savory. Upgrade to the mac on the sandwich or get the premium mac on the side, it’s incredible. Alli was incredibly hospitable and knew all the good flavor combos. Ask for her if you can. Will be back again!
My husband enjoyed this restaurant so much that we ended up dining here twice during our stay; this is something we rarely do when visiting a new destination. Every dish we tried was exceptionally flavorful, and the house sauce, in particular, was outstanding.
This spot truly stands out and is a must-visit for anyone spending time in Watkins Glen. The quality of the food and overall experience exceeded our expectations. This place is now in our top 5 barbecue...
This spot truly stands out and is a must-visit for anyone spending time in Watkins Glen. The quality of the food and overall experience exceeded our expectations. This place is now in our top 5 barbecue...
Nick and his crew catered our daughter’s wedding at Whitetail Ridge Farm. They showed up early, the food for the happy hour, reception and late nite snack was absolutely delicious and ready on time. We highly recommend Nickle’s catering for any event.
You May Also Like
El Rancho Mexican Restaurant - 212 N Franklin St
![]()
Mexican, Bar, Vegan, Vegetarian
Graft wine + cider bar - 204 N Franklin St
![]()
Wine Bar, American, International, New American
Roosterfish Pub - 223 N Franklin St
![]()
Brewpubs, American, Pizza, Vegan