I do like their subs however don't bother with the deserts. I honestly haven't had a good experience ever. We tried a lemon roll cake. The very next day we went to eat it and it had already started to mold. The cookies and cakes are always dry.
Elaine Spencer
Slow delivery
Order breakfast pizza it not here 1 1/2 hours not here yet
Shannon Ellis
I live in Endwell and come here specifically as there is no one in my area that comes close to their food. The To Go pizzas are great to bring home to freeze or bake.
Theresa Hulslander
Best homemade cannoli and desserts, Cant go wrong with ANY choice, it's perfection.
Kid-friendliness: Small deli but has an area to sit and eat
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cookies, Cup Cakes, Cake, Cheese Pizza
John Farr
Best Italian deli ever.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 4
Greg McNamara
I haven't been here in years since I was a young kid. Does not disappoint. Still as I remember it. Amazing baked goods, amazing breakfast sammich. Still love it
Kid-friendliness: Great for kids, plenty of good stuff
Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp and plenty of open space .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bearz “Bearz” Gray
Review of Soprano’s – Sunday, February 23rd, 2025
I drove to Soprano’s today, hoping to get one of the last remaining Cinnamon Twists that they make on Fridays. Luckily, there were two left, and I bought them. However, the inconsistent quality of their baked goods is particularly disappointing, and the attitude of complete and utter disregard by the male front counter clerks is shocking.
When I asked about various baked goods, they had no idea what they were and showed no desire to actually provide customer service by finding out answers to my questions. If the counter clerks are going to dismiss customer inquiries, then why not create signs for the baked goods so customers can identify muffins, pastries, and other items? As a Chef, I find it appalling that the staff aren’t better prepared to serve customers or represent Soprano’s professionally. If this is the level of service they’re trained to provide, then it reflects poorly on the owner’s priorities and standards.
I generally enjoy most of their pizzas, but the meatballs are overly salty, tasting as if they’ve been marinating in sea water. Why not use a blend of spices and herbs for flavor instead? Reducing the salt or hiring someone who actually knows how to make meatballs would be a significant improvement.
Outside, as I was getting into my vehicle, I spoke with the kitchen manager (who was on a cigarette break) about the meatballs and the coffee machine cartridge being out of coffee (which happens to be Folgers, a poor choice for quality coffee). My feedback seemed to fall on less-than-receptive ears, suggesting that this dismissive attitude might be how the place is managed overall.
Attention, Mr. Owner: You have a great market and a business that needs your attention and care. If you’re unable or unwilling to manage it properly, hire someone who truly understands the food industry and knows how to train staff effectively. Your establishment has potential, but it requires dedication to consistent quality, improved service, and attention to detail.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
James Tsimiklis
Had a gabagool, provolone, and vinegar pepper sandwich.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carl Mosier
I love the cheese steaks, always have fresh soft bread and you can't beat the service
The best place to go for pizza and fresh baked food! I have never been disappointed. Their desserts are divine.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies, Cup Cakes, Cake, Cheese Pizza
Jeremy (Toy-Supra)
This place is amazing, I'm glad I don't live closer to it, otherwise I'd be broke and diabetic. They seem to have everything, and everything I've had there, has been delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Muffins Chocolate Dipped Cannoli Eclair Half Moon Oreo Moons, Cookies, 1⁄4 Sheet Garlic Pizza, Cup Cakes at Soprano's, Cup Cakes, Ruben Sandwich, Chicken Wing Sauce, Cheesesteak Pizza, Cake, Bacon Ham Sausage and Egg Breakfast Pizza, Garlic Pizza with Pepperoni, Peppermint Cupcakes, Caramel Apple Filled Cupcake, Different Kinds of Pizza, Nice Selection of Italian Meats, Coconut Cream Pie, Cheese Pizza, Broc Garlic Pizza, Strawberry Cheesecake
Christopher Walborn
Amazing food love this place whenever I'm going to syare I try to make it a purpose to stop here
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Faith Bogdan
All baked goods are kept in a cooler, so cookies are cold and hard. Be advised they use American cheese on their pizza, even New York style slices. I guess this must be a preference of the locals? Subs are decent, but the burger was more like a burnt fifty-cent piece hidden between two big pieces of bread.
Meghan
Soprano’s was always a staple when it came to take out for our family. However, in the past few months they have really been disappointing. We ordered a cheesesteak pizza, and they put scrambled egg on it? More than once they have gotten our sub orders wrong, forgetting toppings or putting mayo on them when we have a family member with an egg allergy. Tonight, we ordered an Italian sub, turkey sub, and cheeseburger sub. The Italian sub came with meat only, and turkey sub was missing two veggies and oil, I’ll attach a pic of the slip to show what we actually ordered. So sad how this establishment is going downhill because it’s a valley treasure. Hope they’re able to correct things soon.
I do like their subs however don't bother with the deserts. I honestly haven't had a good experience ever. We tried a lemon roll cake. The very next day we went to eat it and it had already started to mold. The cookies and cakes are always dry.
Slow delivery Order breakfast pizza it not here 1 1/2 hours not here yet
I live in Endwell and come here specifically as there is no one in my area that comes close to their food. The To Go pizzas are great to bring home to freeze or bake.
Best homemade cannoli and desserts, Cant go wrong with ANY choice, it's perfection.
Kid-friendliness: Small deli but has an area to sit and eat
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cookies, Cup Cakes, Cake, Cheese Pizza
Best Italian deli ever.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 4
I haven't been here in years since I was a young kid. Does not disappoint. Still as I remember it. Amazing baked goods, amazing breakfast sammich. Still love it
Kid-friendliness: Great for kids, plenty of good stuff
Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp and plenty of open space .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Review of Soprano’s – Sunday, February 23rd, 2025
I drove to Soprano’s today, hoping to get one of the last remaining Cinnamon Twists that they make on Fridays. Luckily, there were two left, and I bought them. However, the inconsistent quality of their baked goods is particularly disappointing, and the attitude of complete and utter disregard by the male front counter clerks is shocking.
When I asked about various baked goods, they had no idea what they were and showed no desire to actually provide customer service by finding out answers to my questions. If the counter clerks are going to dismiss customer inquiries, then why not create signs for the baked goods so customers can identify muffins, pastries, and other items? As a Chef, I find it appalling that the staff aren’t better prepared to serve customers or represent Soprano’s professionally. If this is the level of service they’re trained to provide, then it reflects poorly on the owner’s priorities and standards.
I generally enjoy most of their pizzas, but the meatballs are overly salty, tasting as if they’ve been marinating in sea water. Why not use a blend of spices and herbs for flavor instead? Reducing the salt or hiring someone who actually knows how to make meatballs would be a significant improvement.
Outside, as I was getting into my vehicle, I spoke with the kitchen manager (who was on a cigarette break) about the meatballs and the coffee machine cartridge being out of coffee (which happens to be Folgers, a poor choice for quality coffee). My feedback seemed to fall on less-than-receptive ears, suggesting that this dismissive attitude might be how the place is managed overall.
Attention, Mr. Owner: You have a great market and a business that needs your attention and care. If you’re unable or unwilling to manage it properly, hire someone who truly understands the food industry and knows how to train staff effectively. Your establishment has potential, but it requires dedication to consistent quality, improved service, and attention to detail.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Had a gabagool, provolone, and vinegar pepper sandwich.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love the cheese steaks, always have fresh soft bread and you can't beat the service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Diamond in the rough... love the place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The best place to go for pizza and fresh baked food! I have never been disappointed. Their desserts are divine.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies, Cup Cakes, Cake, Cheese Pizza
This place is amazing, I'm glad I don't live closer to it, otherwise I'd be broke and diabetic. They seem to have everything, and everything I've had there, has been delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Muffins Chocolate Dipped Cannoli Eclair Half Moon Oreo Moons, Cookies, 1⁄4 Sheet Garlic Pizza, Cup Cakes at Soprano's, Cup Cakes, Ruben Sandwich, Chicken Wing Sauce, Cheesesteak Pizza, Cake, Bacon Ham Sausage and Egg Breakfast Pizza, Garlic Pizza with Pepperoni, Peppermint Cupcakes, Caramel Apple Filled Cupcake, Different Kinds of Pizza, Nice Selection of Italian Meats, Coconut Cream Pie, Cheese Pizza, Broc Garlic Pizza, Strawberry Cheesecake
Amazing food love this place whenever I'm going to syare I try to make it a purpose to stop here
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
All baked goods are kept in a cooler, so cookies are cold and hard. Be advised they use American cheese on their pizza, even New York style slices. I guess this must be a preference of the locals? Subs are decent, but the burger was more like a burnt fifty-cent piece hidden between two big pieces of bread.
Soprano’s was always a staple when it came to take out for our family. However, in the past few months they have really been disappointing. We ordered a cheesesteak pizza, and they put scrambled egg on it? More than once they have gotten our sub orders wrong, forgetting toppings or putting mayo on them when we have a family member with an egg allergy. Tonight, we ordered an Italian sub, turkey sub, and cheeseburger sub. The Italian sub came with meat only, and turkey sub was missing two veggies and oil, I’ll attach a pic of the slip to show what we actually ordered. So sad how this establishment is going downhill because it’s a valley treasure. Hope they’re able to correct things soon.
Loading...