Alfredo's Pizza

134 NY-109, West Babylon
(631) 321-1199

Recent Reviews

The Penis Collection

Even if the English language consisted of 1000000000000 words, there still would not be enough to describe how heinous of an experience i have had with this store. My daughter and my child both Threw Up hard. They Hate you. Don't eat here if you have any respect for yourself or food as a whole.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jonas Felix

A few days ago, I bought a pie from this place. It was soggy and barely had any sauce. Not only that but it looked undercooked. If I had to give this place zero stars I would.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Antonio

Horrible restaurant?????????????????????????????HORRIBLE GROSS

JOLIE FELIX

I'd rather die then eat food from this restaurant.

Larry D.

tasty food and pasta/heros today excellent service friendly service staff plenty of parking. great for take out

Melanie & Rusty Rose

Alfredo’s has delicious food, they’re always friendly & have great deals too. I also saw they’re animal lovers by agreeing to place the Babylon Animal Shelters flier of adoptable dogs on their boxes.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Goobber Boommer

The new owner is a great a guy, hard worker and the pizza is delicious!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ryan Rossano

I order from them on Uber eats and they are unparalleled.10/10 best. Prices are insane, food goes crazy(They have the best lasagna I've ever had and it was BOGO too)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kim tanner

The owners are wonderful, fun just great atmosphere and prices are fair and food is always delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christina C.

If I could give it a zero I would. Worst pie I have EVER had. Ordered a "grandma pie" and it was completely inedible. Absolutely disgusting. Will never go back to this place ever

D Amor

The pizza needs to be crisper more cooked but the seasoning they use is delicious. They are very nice people and good

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Danny M.

I was looking for a place close by for hero specials, A Lot of places have been making the parm heros too soggy and too much sauce ! I was very surprised how good they were, and they even had veal at only a small increase in price! The chicken cutlet was great also, I found my new hero place! Fast delivery also! I was happy, I will be back

Brandon Berkowitz

I ordered here from Uber eats and I asked for an extra cup of sauce on the side very politely then I got charged $2 for it. I called up and asked to cancel it and they said no it’s already changed. So then I asked to get a regular slice of pizza instead of a $2 small cup of tomato sauce and he said the pizza cost $3 and he can’t give me the $1 difference…… in a restaurant business the customer is always right and should be top priority. To charge me $2 for 1 small cup of tomato sauce then not cancel it then not allow me to get something else Instead is crazy!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 1

Tom Thumb

Food was lukewarm, cheese was not melted on the pizza the bread was white on the bottom of the pizza meaning it wasn't cooked enough and the pizza was warm at best.I don't know if this place changed owners because the food used to be good and also hot. Disappointing. I will try them one more time before I look for someone else.

Food: 4

Patrick Zuckerwise

I can't understand some customers that believe that the quote "The Customer is Always Right" when they are complete unaware of the costs for the food they order and the time and effort it takes to make such food, and the standards for selling it. They believe they should get additional add-ons and extra food for free when nothing in this world is given for free. This is norm of equal trade for products you desire from a merchant as a customer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hot Wings

Load More