Old Fashioned Ice Cream

The best ice cream on Long Island!

Best ice cream flavor selections, pleasant staff and beautiful delicious custom made ice cream cakes. Best Old Fashion Ice Cream around!

Saw a flavor i never saw b4 and I'm obsessed #STAFFSUPERNICE!!

Drove a long distance because Google showed this place as open, only to arrive and find it closed. Very frustrating and a complete waste of time. Updating business hours online is basic customer service. Disappointed.
Please update your hours to avoid putting others through the same situation.

Fresh delicious homemade ice cream..so many delicious flavors to choose from. Lots of soft serve and hard ice cream

This is the best ice cream ever made. You HAVE to try moms yummy crumb cake 🤤

Parking is the only problem

This place is amazing been going here since I was a kid I'm 50 now wouldn't get ice cream any other place got to check this place out

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The best ice cream on Long Island!!

Calling all vegans or dairy-free folks to try out this spot!! They have some of the best vegan ice cream options on Long Island. They rotate their options, but they usually carry vegan vanilla soft serve and a second option like strawberry or pistachio. These are so creamy and delicious. They have occasionally have dole whip as well. They have vegan chocolate covered bananas. They can also make those mini sundaes or chocolate saucers dairy-free/vegan ahead of time for birthday parties. They have a variety of vegan toppings like sprinkles, nuts, chocolate/strawberry dip, etc. please support this spot if you’re ever in the area.

My family and I travel frequently and frequent various ice cream shops. We don't eat ice cream from regular stores; we prefer to buy it from farm stands or specialty ice cream parlors. This time, I chose this shop. It was Sunday, and the line was crowded; the line even started outside, but it moved quickly. The place is very modest, without much decor; I found it quite uninviting. The service was average. The ice cream selection was decent, and the prices were average. The kids and I chose three different flavors: coconut, mango, and pecan. The pecan and coconut were too sweet for our tastes, and I didn't really like the mango either; it lacked the tartness you usually get with mango. Overall, I recommend visiting.

Great homemade ice cream. Many enjoyable flavors.

The ice cream was delicious. A touch pricey but worth it. The staff was polite, and the store was clean. I would definitely go here again and again.

Open seven days a week &. Amazing ice cream! It has a unique whipped “ consistency like no other !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The best ice cream in the area. So many great flavors and new flavors coming all the time. The only bad thing for me is that sometimes I have such a hard time choosing!