Old Fashioned Ice Cream
1025 Straight Path, West Babylon
(631) 669-3020
Customers' Favorites
Pistachio Soft Serve with Wet Walnuts
Chocolate Chocolate Chip Single Scoop
Holy Cannoli w Blueberry Soft Serve
Fudge & Biscotti Ice Cream Pie
Golden Oreo Ice Cream Pie
Ice Cream Filled Donut
Small Ice Cream Cones
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Homemade Ice Cream
Gourmet Ice Cream
Menu
Photos
+52 photos
+51 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Calling all vegans or dairy-free folks to try out this spot!! They have some of the best vegan ice cream options on Long Island. They rotate their options, but they usually carry vegan vanilla soft serve and a second option like strawberry or pistachio. These are so creamy and delicious. They have occasionally have dole whip as well. They have vegan chocolate covered bananas. They can also make those mini sundaes or chocolate saucers dairy-free/vegan ahead of time for birthday...
My family and I travel frequently and frequent various ice cream shops. We don't eat ice cream from regular stores; we prefer to buy it from farm stands or specialty ice cream parlors. This time, I chose this shop. It was Sunday, and the line was crowded; the line even started outside, but it moved quickly. The place is very modest, without much decor; I found it quite uninviting. The service was average. The ice cream selection was decent, and the prices were average. The...
Pretty long wait usually during peak ice cream hours. Moves pretty slow but I’m sure it’s because of all the great flavor options for guests to choose from. Well worth the wait and glad they’ve been in business for so long.
You May Also Like
Paradise Caribbean Restaurant - 987 Straight Path
![]()
Caribbean, Bakery, Haitian
Dooley's Bagel & Deli - 930 Straight Path
![]()
Bagels, Pet Friendly
New Yan Chun Kitchen Inc - 922 Straight Path
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian