Old Fashioned Ice Cream
1025 Straight Path, West Babylon
(631) 669-3020
Customers' Favorites
Pistachio Soft Serve with Wet Walnuts
Chocolate Chocolate Chip Single Scoop
Holy Cannoli w Blueberry Soft Serve
Fudge & Biscotti Ice Cream Pie
Golden Oreo Ice Cream Pie
Ice Cream Filled Donut
Small Ice Cream Cones
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Homemade Ice Cream
Gourmet Ice Cream
Menu
Photos
+49 photos
+48 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Pretty long wait usually during peak ice cream hours. Moves pretty slow but I’m sure it’s because of all the great flavor options for guests to choose from. Well worth the wait and glad they’ve been in business for so long.
I did not have the opportunity to visit this store personally but I received a birthday cake 🎂 from this store and it was perfect. My colleagues who purchased the cake spoke highly about the service offered and how receptive and remarkable the staff was when taking the order. I have a severe food allergies and I will recommend this shop to anyone. Thank you.
Dietary restrictions: Good allergy
Dietary restrictions: Good allergy
The girl who waited on me today was very friendly and helpful! The way she scooped the ice cream was like an art, she got all four flavors perfectly triangles in the container so you dont have to go down laters for different flavors! I ordered a bunch of things, all of them delicious! Looking forward to going back to try more flavors. Highly recommend!
You May Also Like
New Yan Chun Kitchen Inc - 922 Straight Path
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian
Pizza King - 914 Straight Path
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian