Great pizza. Parking lot not the greatest but the food is worth it
MD “EMRAN” HOSSAIN
No doubt, Best pizza in the town!
Jeffery
Customer service was great. However the pizza was pretty average and not really worth the price. There are better pizzas in Buffalo and better priced.
Greg VanMeter
Some of the best and most original pizza I have had in a long time. Sweet sauce is not too sweet and has great taste. Crust, cheese and pep were fantastic too. Really good job guys. Will definitely be ordering again!
Karl Booth
Amazing pizza.
David Wlodarczyk
Amazing. Trying thin crust next.
Danni Licata
Sweet sauce was good. Dough was perfect. Pepperoni were crisp. Bleu cheese is pretty good as well!
Jordan Barnes
pizza is soooooooo good
wrenands
Someone left a Google review saying how great the vegan pizza is here. I was honestly skeptical, because several pizzerias in Buffalo have claimed to have vegan pizza, which then ultimately proved to be either straight up false claims or genuinely disappointing. One Pie Pizza Co.‘s vegan pizza actually was great though!! I got the 1/4 sheet with banana peppers and onions. My friend and I couldn’t believe we had never heard of it before. We were genuinely impressed! We didn’t even take a picture because it looked so good when we opened it. I’ll get my pizza here from now on. Only thing that could make it better is maybe some vegan pepperoni or sausage, or some dedicated vegan pizzas besides “just cheese.”
James
Simple pepperoni with onions and black olives was perfect. Onions slightly charred. 5 Stars.
The Pizza of the Month (Sweet Chili Pineapple & Bacon) was not a hit and threw most away.
Recently had a pizza that was not up to usual quality but the owner/manager reached out to me to replace it. It was excellent. Sometimes isolated incidents slip by and that is understandable. Thank you for your high quality food and we will remain a loyal customer and urge all else to patronize your fine quality foods you offer. Thank you so very much!!!!! Pizza excellent ? ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Half Sheet Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza
Karol Szymczuk
Fairly generic pizza, sauce is near flavorless, slightly better than Cafeteria pizza, but worse then Little Caesars. There's better places within a mile.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tammy Severn
My favorite place ever! Only place i will order from. Ordering tomorrow. hehe. Keep up the good work guys. Update: the last few weeks not good. Xough is old and pizza made way in advance to where it carmelized. Sorry guys I worked at fontana the original and the pizza here lately is a big no no. U lost my buisness stop being lazy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Half Sheet Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza
Melissa Wood
We ordered One Pie Pizza breakfast pizzas for a catered breakfast event. They were super easy to work with, the delivery was smooth and on time. And the pizza was fantastic! Even their gluten free crust was great. Incredibly pleased with the whole experience.
Food: 5
Service: 5
wendy Priest
As always, One Pie does not disappoint! We had the Allen goat pizza this time and I stuffed one last slice down just to taste it!!!! Great Pizza! Friendly staff on time and perfect.
Great pizza. Parking lot not the greatest but the food is worth it
No doubt, Best pizza in the town!
Customer service was great. However the pizza was pretty average and not really worth the price. There are better pizzas in Buffalo and better priced.
Some of the best and most original pizza I have had in a long time. Sweet sauce is not too sweet and has great taste. Crust, cheese and pep were fantastic too. Really good job guys. Will definitely be ordering again!
Amazing pizza.
Amazing. Trying thin crust next.
Sweet sauce was good. Dough was perfect. Pepperoni were crisp. Bleu cheese is pretty good as well!
pizza is soooooooo good
Someone left a Google review saying how great the vegan pizza is here. I was honestly skeptical, because several pizzerias in Buffalo have claimed to have vegan pizza, which then ultimately proved to be either straight up false claims or genuinely disappointing. One Pie Pizza Co.‘s vegan pizza actually was great though!! I got the 1/4 sheet with banana peppers and onions. My friend and I couldn’t believe we had never heard of it before. We were genuinely impressed! We didn’t even take a picture because it looked so good when we opened it. I’ll get my pizza here from now on. Only thing that could make it better is maybe some vegan pepperoni or sausage, or some dedicated vegan pizzas besides “just cheese.”
Simple pepperoni with onions and black olives was perfect. Onions slightly charred. 5 Stars.
The Pizza of the Month (Sweet Chili Pineapple & Bacon) was not a hit and threw most away.
Stick to a basic pizza and you'll enjoy it.
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Recently had a pizza that was not up to usual quality but the owner/manager reached out to me to replace it. It was excellent. Sometimes isolated incidents slip by and that is understandable. Thank you for your high quality food and we will remain a loyal customer and urge all else to patronize your fine quality foods you offer. Thank you so very much!!!!! Pizza excellent ? ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Half Sheet Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza
Fairly generic pizza, sauce is near flavorless, slightly better than Cafeteria pizza, but worse then Little Caesars. There's better places within a mile.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
My favorite place ever! Only place i will order from. Ordering tomorrow. hehe. Keep up the good work guys. Update: the last few weeks not good. Xough is old and pizza made way in advance to where it carmelized. Sorry guys I worked at fontana the original and the pizza here lately is a big no no. U lost my buisness stop being lazy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Half Sheet Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza
We ordered One Pie Pizza breakfast pizzas for a catered breakfast event. They were super easy to work with, the delivery was smooth and on time. And the pizza was fantastic! Even their gluten free crust was great. Incredibly pleased with the whole experience.
Food: 5
Service: 5
As always, One Pie does not disappoint! We had the Allen goat pizza this time and I stuffed one last slice down just to taste it!!!! Great Pizza! Friendly staff on time and perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...