Rusty Buffalo Sports Pub & Grill

270 Center Rd, West Seneca
(716) 608-6621

Recent Reviews

D And B B.

If you are local they are friendly to you. If you stop in while in town for a drink, literally the most unfriendly establishment. They clearly don't need anyone's business.

Tyne Taylor

Love Love The wings, the Cheers atmosphere where everyone knows each other, the staff is amazing and I can’t wait to come back and visit Julie!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Katrina Burgasser

Best Chivettas wings, great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings

Ana Rodriguez

I absolutely loved it here! First time there with my mom to watch the bills game. The atmosphere is amazing. The people working and just the crowd were so great to be around! Definitely going to be one of my favorites! Highly highly recommend.Parking: It’s in a plaza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings

RuleFat

supper nice place to find great food.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, House Salad, Pulled Pork Sandwich

Robert Lucas

If you like good food, pool, darts and sports this is your place to go! we were there on 10/7/23 and there was no one there since the bills played the following moring at 9:30 but this is such a good spot to go. The food was amazing, you gotta try the bang bang shrimp. Nothing but good things to say and it was fair pricing. Absolutely go there over Anchor

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jim McCarthy

Good wings, cold beer ? what else can I say ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Susan S

Attended a celebration of life for a friend.. Very nice...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Brancato

Cool place. Outside patio is chill. Drinks were

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

April (clouddancer46)

Can always count on great service, fun, and friends. So many great memories. Available for parties, great for Bills games, dart tournaments, billiards and creating all around good times.

Anthony dapruzzo

I had such an inceptional time with the owner and bartender :-) The atmosphere is amazing and they have more TVs than your brain can comprehend. Four dart tables! And all sorts of memorabilia :-) I would highly recommend this establishment and they have the best custom made wind sauce I've tasted a buffalo, I've been to a lot of bars in Buffalo but they're sauce is the boss.

Rob W

Very nice!.....just stopped in for a beer....will def go back to try their bar food

Kim Chatwood

Great atmosphere had a lot of fun meeting up with some friends and playing darts.

Andrew F.

One of my favorite places back home in Massachusetts is a little place called the Black Sheep Tavern (I know, I'm reviewing the Rusty Buffalo, bear with me). Great pizza, good wings, fun atmosphere--you know the kind of place I'm talking about, and if you don't and you're near the Rusty Buffalo, go on in and you'll see what I mean. Anyway, I was traveling with my family through the Buffalo area and we figured since we're here, we really ought to have wings for dinner, right? After reading a ton of Yelp reviews, we settled on the Rusty Buffalo. I reached out on Facebook (they were closed at that time) to ask how much lead time they needed for an order of wings, and they got right back to me. 30 minutes, so plan ahead! I phoned in the order so that it would be ready for us to pick up as soon as we got into town--they were really nice on the phone and even called me back when we got disconnected. I ordered four chicken finger dinners and 40 wings--I was about to order extra fries, but the lady on the phone stopped me and told me the dinners each came with easily enough fries for two people. Not many places will undersell a customer like that, and I really appreciated it, since traveling long distance with leftovers can be a pain. I walked in to pick up the order, and it was like I was back home again. Great atmosphere, friendly people, good music, and the food smelled amazing. We got it back to our hotel, checked in, unloaded, and sat down to eat. Everything was still piping hot. I strongly recommend the Honey Sriracha--it's addictive. It was my first time trying Chiavetta's sauce, too, and it was also excellent. Their house Buffalo sauce was some of the best I've had anywhere. However, the Cajun dry rub was everyone's favorite, hands down. Their wings were all crispy and delicious, even the ones that had been sauced heavily. I wouldn't hesitate to go there again anytime I'm passing through.

518lauriek

My husband had been here many years ago and we drove by the other day and decided to try it one night..........well tonight was the night. Today is Thursday and we didn't want to cook so we went for wings and fries. Our server/bartender was Amber and she was great very attentive and on top of things right on the ball, as she was serving the whole place We both ordered wings me the medium crispy and my husband got the dry cajun rub with hot sauce on the side. They were great very crispy and meaty they were delicious. It has been hard to find a good wing around lately since the pandemic started. The fries were nice and brown and not at all greasy we really enjoyed the food. The inside is quite big 4 dart boards and a pool table plus they have several tv's so can play many sports all at once it was an overall great experience we will for sure be back !!!

Load More

Rusty Buffalo Sports Pub & Grill

270 Center Rd, West Seneca, NY 14224
(716) 608-6621