Haskell's Seafood Market and Cafe

Best lobster roll ever! The entire roll was so fresh, you can taste the lobster. There is no nonsense sauce, no preservatives, no heavy ingredients. Felt so energized and clean after eating it. The salad the side is fresh too. Highly recommend!

Best Lobster Roll. Fresh and no unnecessary ingredients. Very clean.

The seafood was all locally caught (ie you’ll see no salmon on the menu), and tasted incredibly fresh.

Stopped by for a lobster roll and so happy we did! Fresh and tasty combined with friendly service - perfect combination! See you again

I recently dined at a charming seafood restaurant in Westhampton Beach, Long Island, and it was a delightful experience. The fish sandwich was a standout—crispy and perfectly seasoned, with fresh fish that truly highlighted the quality of their seafood. The restaurant's location is incredibly convenient, just a short walk from the beach, making it a perfect spot for a post-sunmeal. Additionally, the extra seating in the back provides a cozy and relaxed atmosphere, ideal for enjoying a meal with friends or family. Overall, it’s a great find for anyone craving excellent seafood in a laid-back setting.

Family owned and operated local fish monger who has the best product in town. Excellent sandwiches, soups, salads, wraps and delicacies.

Recently purchased 2 pounds of (raw) scallops from Haskell’s. Absolutely fantastic!!!! Tender and sweet, never had better!!!

Owner was very friendly and inviting. Waitress Emily even more so. My family really enjoyed the food as well, lobsters rolls and chowder were great! A gem in town. Keep being amazing! ( Can't wait to try the sushi )

Excellent food! They were super accommodating to dietary needs and were so nice. Manhattan clam chowder and lobster roll were fantastic.

Best fish in hamptons and friendly staff

Haskell is such a wonderful respite from other stuffy and expensive dinners on main street in westhampton.

Walk into the seafood shop to choose your filet of fish and have it cooked however you’d like, or choose from their perfectly sized menu.

Everything is unbelievably fresh, all the fish is caught locally that morning.

Menu standouts are the Red shrimp (both cocktail style and fried), the lobster roll, and the tuna entre. The night of our most recent visit, we had three kinds of fresh tuna to choose from— yellowfin, big eye, and bluefin!

The street seating is great but the back patio is really lovely.

Bonus, the restaurant is BYOB so you can bring whatever you’d like without paying restaurant markups for wine and beer.

Haskell's Seafood in Westhampton offers a variety of fresh fish and shellfish, as well as soups, appetizers, and other prepared meals like fish sticks and baked clams. The friendly and helpful staff provide excellent service. The store has a simple, casual atmosphere, and customers can enjoy outdoor seating on the patio.

We came to town craving seafood after a beach afternoon for a quick bite for lunch. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. The food was reasonably priced, absolutely delicious, and served promptly. We were able to enjoy in the adorable back patio surrounded by hydrangeas. We will definitely return the next time we’re around West Hampton and would highly recommend this family-run establishment!

Not sure why there isn’t a line of people camping to get the first lobster roll of the day. It is the best one in the Hamptons for sure and only 34 bucks.

My wife and I were craving lobster rolls so decided to give this market a try. Wait staff were incredibly attentive, informative and kind. They let you know all about the food being served and where they get it locally. And the food itself was so fresh and delicious. Would highly recommend.