Haskell's Seafood Market and Cafe

77 Main St, Westhampton Beach
(631) 288-7287

Recent Reviews

Dana Mortell

We took some lunch to-go to eat by the beach, and the food was incredible! We ordered the fish and chips, a lobster role, and the NE clam chowder. All were extremely fresh, and still hot when we consumed 20min later. Very well packaged, and great ingredients!

Azadeh Nematzadeh

We love this place, great food, they support local seafood and amazing people are workingthere

Gary Castle

The best fish in Westhampton either to eat in or take out. Peter and Melissa are a pleasure to deal with.

Gary L.

Amazing royal red shrimp! The owner Peter is super kind and attentive. Really an incredible dining experience out back behind the storefront. The food is so fresh. Perfect for a quiet evening out.

mjr 1

excellent in every aspect

Lissett I.

Speechless...Best service, ambiance and food in Westhampton beach. When in town stop in, you won't regret it. Dogs allowed in outside seating area and it's BYOB.

Regina Z.

I was visiting my friend with my boyfriend and wanted to try something in west Hamptons. We discovered this hidden gem. This place is like a restaurant with patios in the back and a market where you can buy things on the go. It's a friendly local place so there aren't too much seating. We sat in the back and were very comfortable. We ordered a bunch of food and I think the prices are reasonable. We ordered lobster salad roll (hot), Lobster and shrimp combo roll (cold), Crab dip and melted cheddar over sourdough, New England chowder, Fish n chips, and fried calamari. The portions of the rolls are incredible! They packed a lot of seafood into the roll (very generous). However, I think the rolls could have a bit more butter. The appetizers were good. The fried calamari wasn't as crispy as I thought it would be but it's fresh. The crab dip was really good. The chowder and fish n chips were alright. I like how the chowder had so many clams in it and they added truffle oil into it. However, I like the chowder thicker and it was a bit runny for me. Fish n chip was fresh but I would like a little more seasoning. Overall, we really enjoyed the food and the service was amazing. They made sure we all were comfortable and kept checking up on us. The best part of this place is that they catch everything fresh by themselves. We are planning to go back again!

Lynda DiBenedetto

Best Kept Secret in Westhampton Beach!Stopped in July 3rd and had the best seafood meal-Calamari-lobster roll-fish and chips and stuffed bass. We really enjoyed sitting in the back patio and the service was excellent thanks to our gracious waitress Melissa. BYOB

Sofyan S.

Food (5/5): Ordered the hot lobster roll, shrimp and lobster combo roll, crab dip, and calamari. We then added new England clam chowder and fish and chips. All of the dishes were amazing and delicious. I particularly liked the lobster and shrimp rolls. The shrimp roll was packed with meat and tasted so fresh and delicious.Service (5/5): Very friendly and helpful service. The server came up and had a friendly conversation with us. They got us water quickly and the food came out pretty fast. Additionally they checked up on us frequently and had a super positive without being overbearing attitude. Really top notch service.Ambiance (5/5): Chill ambiance where you can order from the desk and then sit outside in the patio. Very chill and relaxed ambiance. Only downside is there are mosquitoes because we were outside so perhaps if you're prone to that, bug spray would be helpful.

Hannah K.

Best lobster roll I've had. Better than anything in New England! Lobster was fresh, succulent, and delicious. Will definitely be back again.

Scott Wellington

Great food to stay or take with you. Catering is spot on and the service is helpful and kind.

Kate N.

Delicious! Everything was fresh and locally sourced. We really appreciated our server, Melissa, who took the time to explain the types of fish, taste and the pride they take in only locally sourcing their seafood. We will be back!

Philip Algieri

Fantastic market selling only local seafood. Prepared items are far better than any restaurant in the area. The recently renovated patio area in the back is very cozy and a great place to enjoy lunch or dinner in the warmer months.

chessia kelley

Local fresh catch at B a fair price. Amazing diy sushi section s as well with specialty grocery items.

Emelye Ender

So good and fresh

Load More

Haskell's Seafood Market and Cafe

77 Main St, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978
(631) 288-7287