Jerri's Cakery & Confections Inc.

The Castle, 59 Montauk Hwy, Westhampton
(631) 223-8986

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Just E!

It just tasted like something you'd buy at Walmart. The cake itself was dry and the topping was a butter cream it was at room temp but it was pretty hard tbh and idk when I bite into a cupcake I expect buttercream to just melt in my mouth. Packaging was cute but for $5 not worth the price.

Maggie-Jean Hanley

Absolutely incredible cake and experience! I ordered a custom cake for an event this past weekend, and it was beyond amazing. Not only was the design exactly what I envisioned (beautifully detailed and picture-perfect) but the flavor was just as impressive. You could taste the quality and care in every bite! The team was also an absolute pleasure to work with: friendly, professional, and accommodating from start to finish. They made the process so easy and were quick to respond to every question. Everyone at the event couldn’t stop raving about how gorgeous (and delicious!) the cake was. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a show-stopping centerpiece that tastes as good as it looks. I’ll definitely be coming back for future celebrations! 🎂✨

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jay Sar

I had high hopes for this place but was let down. I bought a small two layer red velvet cake that cost around $40. I was hoping the high price was worth it, but not so much. Cake was dry with not much flavor and the icing was pretty thick and hard. I only tried this one cake so maybe the others are better but I can't justify trying another one when they cost that much.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Maddi Cheers

Amazing almond croissants and apple turnovers! Great customer service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

T W

The cake, was not very good. I ordered a vanilla birthday cake. It tasted like “milk powder”. Most kids ended up throwing away their cake. Very disappointed. I am not sure this was a one off incident but I would not recommend.

The service and atmosphere were good.

Pathways For Wellness - Debbie

Jerri’s Cakery & Confections has a fun, light and cheerful vibe. The staff is cheerful and helpful. I found the baked goods to be a bit pricey. My husband likes carrot cake that is on the lighter size with more layers of cake, and thin layers of icing. Jerri’s carrot cake was moist and very dense, with thick layers of icing, didn’t taste much of the spices. The Apple turnovers had a decent amount of apple filling. There could have been a bit more chocolate in the croissants. There is a cute display that offers treats for your four legged family members.

sue gavin

I called last minute for a birthday cake and the owner was so accommodating, despite that I did not provide 24 hour notice. The cake was beautiful and absolutely delicious!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vicki Greene

Jerry and Brielle created a gorgeous and incredibly delicious cake which brought our family to tears. So special! Thank you for making our pre-wedding party amazing.!!!

Kathy Twombly

At most weddings, the cake seems to be a great prop for some beautiful photos. Not at our daughter’s wedding.The cake was spectacular and absolutely delicious. People went back for second...even third pieces! Everyone wanted to know who baked the cake!To say the cake was a huge hit is an understatement!From the tasting to the set up, Jerri and her team were professional and always responsive.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lauren Lopez

Jerri created a true masterpiece for our wedding this past week! She went above and beyond to create the wedding cake of our dreams! She is a true expert at what she does! She is kind, easy to work with, reliable, and trustworthy. We couldn’t be happier! And our guests can’t stop talking about the beautiful AND delicious cake!! Thank you, Jerri!

Lauren Retundi

Jerri created a true masterpiece for our wedding this past week! She went above and beyond to create the wedding cake of our dreams! She is a true expert at what she does! She is kind, easy to work with, reliable, and trustworthy. We couldn’t be happier! And our guests can’t stop talking about the beautiful AND delicious cake!! Thank you, Jerri!

michael donnelly

Hello,Sold us a stale cake on 4/26/23 that should have been discarded

cara sultan

Jerri was wonderful! The cake she created for my daughter was gorgeous, tasty and exactly what we wanted. People couldn't believe it was real-it was a work of art! Jerri is talented, kind, accmomodating and very talented. Highly recommend.

Rory Aledort

I recently got married and was leaving the cake for the last minute! I had trouble finding a bakery that was creative, decently priced and out east! When we stumbled upon Jerri's it was a no brainer! She was so sweet, accommodating, collaborative and clearly this is her passion. Our cake was the perfect size, exactly what we envisioned and delicious! I would absolutely recommend Jerri's cakes! - Rory Aledort

Eliza Miszczyk

Jerri made sweets for our garden wedding and everything was so pretty and delicious. She listened carefully to our needs and executed our vision perfectly!

Loading...