Very good dinner ... amazing affordable prices and good service. Love the old school feel. The large shrimp in the Alfredo were delicious.
William Darrow
You will never find a more family run restaurant than Aiello's restaurant in Whitney Point
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Angel Perry
Wonderful experience! Our server was Incredibly Friendly & she was Super Helpful! She went above & beyond! She even took a photo for us:) She asked at the start of order if we wanted separate bills even…& at the end of lunch she remembered to bring the piece of Bday cake I had called ahead to request & they added a delightful extra touch of decorating the plate with “Happy Birthday”! Our waitress even sang Happy Birthday to my daughter with us:) I didn’t pay the bill so couldn’t see but sure hope the tip reflected such Amazing service!!! The entire staff was very friendly! & the food was Amazingly Delicious! Thanks Again Aiello’s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicholas Longo
I drove five hours from New Jersey to spend Easter weekend with my girlfriends family in Freeville and was recommended to stop by here for a slice of pizza. We came in while they were closing and I was greeted by one of the servers that was very kind and helpful with assisting us. By no means did they have to serve us at all after the kitchen was closed. Thanks to the friendly staff and Jeremy they went out of their way to heat us up 4 slices! Jeremy was really nice and took time to show us around and give us a nice history lesson of the establishment. After paying for our pizza which not to mention was delicious! Before leaving he looked us out with an amazing stromboli on top of jar of sauce! I will 100 percent be coming back for dinner and highly recommend anyone looking for a good meal, friendly atmosphere, and a fun time you need to stop in here. Thanks again to Jeremy and staff!!! 5 star 5 star ?
steven Bolt
Clean, Friendly, and DELICIOUS. One of the top restaurants in the area i will never ever stop recommending this place. Worth any drive!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Eggplant Parm
C Dub, Jr
Fair Italian food. The Sicilian Eggplant Parm is good, steamed oysters with butter and lemon good, Fra Diavolo is good although it was sweet, I expected it to be a little spicy and not so sweet. The macaroni and cheese is delicious! They charge gratuity for any "groups" over 4, I suppose. The first time I went , I was with a group of 10. The waitress said she couldn't do 10 separate checks that she could only do one check or, at most, two checks. Ok, NBD, we just put it on one check one person paid the whole bill and then we CashApp-ed the money to that person, there was a 20% automatic gratuity on the check. I went back in a few days later with a group of 5 and got the same response about one check. Five people is not a big group, that's 2 couples and a child. I think they only do that to ensure that they get a tip. Do people not tip anymore that now it is part of the bill? I wonder if I go in there with only my girl if she will still classify us as "large group". At any rate, it's the fanciest place to eat in Whitney Point, but there are places in Vestal and Binghamton that are just as good or better and I use the word "fancy" loosely. The setting is nice here, it's an old hotel so that's nice. They also do take out, you can get a pizza or anything on the menu to eat here. No dress code required.
Carter
Great food, service, and atmosphere. Friendly crowd, great bartenders.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thomas Aukett
My go to food from here is the manboli it's a meat lovers dream food. Chicken, steak, sausage, peppers and cheese. It's amazing.Parking: When busy it's difficult to get a parking spot.
We were on the way to Ithaca and we did a pit stop at Aiello’s for a quick bite. Such a friendly and lovely place with great food and service. The best on tap Fiddlehead IPA I have ever had. Cheers ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Canoli, Pizzas
Maria Nunu
Waitress was good, atmosphere is nice. Ordered pasta with shrimp, pasta was ok, shrimp a little too charred but the problem was the Alfredo sauce, I don't think it should be made with a roux, didn't like it , tasted like flour with Carnation milk.
Got the boneless wings and they were absolutely awesome definitely homemade!! The bartender was a sweetheart!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Bisque, Chicken Wings
LRLkniVes
Very good service and far more than exceptional food! I'll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Chicken Wings
Marianne A.
Seriously I am a pizza connoisseur. I've been coming to Aiello's for 30 years and the margarita pizza never disappoints! My husband loves the Sicilian Eggplant and the specials are delicious. No matter your preference Aiello's is a favorite. Thank you to the family for keeping it going!
Aaron Weiss
Worst chicken wings ever, no flavor, taste like eating a lump of charcoal
Toyster M
I had the lobster ravioli with white wine sauce and dry tomatoes - it was to die for! The appetizer was Arancini di riso and it was fantastic. Autentico sapore Italiano. Dopo cena un cigaro col boss! ❤️
Very good dinner ... amazing affordable prices and good service. Love the old school feel. The large shrimp in the Alfredo were delicious.
You will never find a more family run restaurant than Aiello's restaurant in Whitney Point
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful experience! Our server was Incredibly Friendly & she was Super Helpful! She went above & beyond! She even took a photo for us:) She asked at the start of order if we wanted separate bills even…& at the end of lunch she remembered to bring the piece of Bday cake I had called ahead to request & they added a delightful extra touch of decorating the plate with “Happy Birthday”! Our waitress even sang Happy Birthday to my daughter with us:) I didn’t pay the bill so couldn’t see but sure hope the tip reflected such Amazing service!!! The entire staff was very friendly! & the food was Amazingly Delicious! Thanks Again Aiello’s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I drove five hours from New Jersey to spend Easter weekend with my girlfriends family in Freeville and was recommended to stop by here for a slice of pizza. We came in while they were closing and I was greeted by one of the servers that was very kind and helpful with assisting us. By no means did they have to serve us at all after the kitchen was closed. Thanks to the friendly staff and Jeremy they went out of their way to heat us up 4 slices! Jeremy was really nice and took time to show us around and give us a nice history lesson of the establishment. After paying for our pizza which not to mention was delicious! Before leaving he looked us out with an amazing stromboli on top of jar of sauce! I will 100 percent be coming back for dinner and highly recommend anyone looking for a good meal, friendly atmosphere, and a fun time you need to stop in here. Thanks again to Jeremy and staff!!! 5 star 5 star ?
Clean, Friendly, and DELICIOUS. One of the top restaurants in the area i will never ever stop recommending this place. Worth any drive!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Eggplant Parm
Fair Italian food. The Sicilian Eggplant Parm is good, steamed oysters with butter and lemon good, Fra Diavolo is good although it was sweet, I expected it to be a little spicy and not so sweet. The macaroni and cheese is delicious! They charge gratuity for any "groups" over 4, I suppose. The first time I went , I was with a group of 10. The waitress said she couldn't do 10 separate checks that she could only do one check or, at most, two checks. Ok, NBD, we just put it on one check one person paid the whole bill and then we CashApp-ed the money to that person, there was a 20% automatic gratuity on the check. I went back in a few days later with a group of 5 and got the same response about one check. Five people is not a big group, that's 2 couples and a child. I think they only do that to ensure that they get a tip. Do people not tip anymore that now it is part of the bill? I wonder if I go in there with only my girl if she will still classify us as "large group". At any rate, it's the fanciest place to eat in Whitney Point, but there are places in Vestal and Binghamton that are just as good or better and I use the word "fancy" loosely. The setting is nice here, it's an old hotel so that's nice. They also do take out, you can get a pizza or anything on the menu to eat here. No dress code required.
Great food, service, and atmosphere. Friendly crowd, great bartenders.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My go to food from here is the manboli it's a meat lovers dream food. Chicken, steak, sausage, peppers and cheese. It's amazing.Parking: When busy it's difficult to get a parking spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Bisque, Eggplant Parm, Calamari, Chicken Wings
We were on the way to Ithaca and we did a pit stop at Aiello’s for a quick bite. Such a friendly and lovely place with great food and service. The best on tap Fiddlehead IPA I have ever had. Cheers ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Canoli, Pizzas
Waitress was good, atmosphere is nice. Ordered pasta with shrimp, pasta was ok, shrimp a little too charred but the problem was the Alfredo sauce, I don't think it should be made with a roux, didn't like it , tasted like flour with Carnation milk.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Got the boneless wings and they were absolutely awesome definitely homemade!! The bartender was a sweetheart!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Bisque, Chicken Wings
Very good service and far more than exceptional food! I'll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Chicken Wings
Seriously I am a pizza connoisseur. I've been coming to Aiello's for 30 years and the margarita pizza never disappoints! My husband loves the Sicilian Eggplant and the specials are delicious. No matter your preference Aiello's is a favorite. Thank you to the family for keeping it going!
Worst chicken wings ever, no flavor, taste like eating a lump of charcoal
I had the lobster ravioli with white wine sauce and dry tomatoes - it was to die for! The appetizer was Arancini di riso and it was fantastic. Autentico sapore Italiano. Dopo cena un cigaro col boss! ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Canoli, Dressing, Seafood, Fish, Chicken Marsala, Salad