Margaritas Cafe

38 Hillside Ave., Williston Park
(516) 493-9045

Recent Reviews

D M

How it stays in business is beyond me.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Arusyak Tchilingarian

Very good food and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Margaritas Skillet, Guacamole

ALEXANDRA PARRA

HAD A GREAT TIME.. FIRST TIME THERE.. SERVICE WAS AWESOME. THEY HAD MARIACHIS WHICH WAS A NICE SURPRISE. FOOD AND DRINKS WERE GOOD. HAD THE STEAK FAJITAS.. THE CHUNKS OF MEAT WERE HUGE.. PERFECTLY COOKED. LOVED IT!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Fajitas Combo

Dr. Peter Osroff

Excellent traditional Mexican restaurant at moderate prices. Nice menu with multiple choices. Excellent mixed drinks. Compatible with other higher priced local Mexican restaurant, Bessito; but, prices at highly competitive. Highly recommend. There are other locations for this small chain…all are solid.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Everything was great. My husband ordered a club soda and they charged him $2.95 for a club soda. That's ridiculous. He always orders that and is never charged!! That's a sin!! Very disappointing.

EricS

Food, service, ambience all great except (and you know, there's always 1 except) a bit too noisy. But don't worry, the bit of noise issue fades as you enjoy the food and the experience. Fun & delicious. Been a go to for us for several years now and will continue to be.

Stacey L. Tyson-Tracy

This place has it all. Great food, amazing service, and solid menu choices! Look no further if this is what you're craving. Ask for Stephanie behind the bar, and Brian will treat you like family! Go enjoy!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kat

We went an hour and a half before closing and they took forever to bring us our food and they messed up one of our orders. After receiving the food they told us they were closing and they wanted payment right away when we just received our order. It was very unprofessional if they were too busy why take our orders then proceed to not let us eat it. If I wanted take out I would’ve done that and to still be asked for tip is insane. Worst restaurant ever!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Shahram Zarmehr

Restaurant is always packed, you may have to wait to get a table at pick hours and weekends. Quality has been hit or miss for me, I like the Steak and Shrimp, but Chicken quality is very poor. They serve a rubbery taste less chicken breast. I haven’t tried all dishes, I mostly ordered combo Fajitas family style.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Stacey S.

Went last night (12/9/23) around 5:30 to Margarita's Cafe in Williston Park. Lots of empty tables so we were seated immediately. The music was blaring, but thankfully the waiter/Luis mentioned that it would be lowered as we sat down. Thank heavens. Complementary chips and salsa were brought to the table, but of course we started with the beef nachos appetizer. Since the nachos were not hot, Luis brought us a replacement order. It was a nice shareable portion, and loaded with toppings. As for mains, we had chicken quesadillas and mixed fajitas. All dishes were presented well, generous in size and tasted great.

EricS

Food, as always, is excellent. Shared the Parrilla Mexicana and enjoyed every bite. The entrée, an assortment of perfectly seasoned and cooked meats, was fab. The accompaniments did not detract, but added to an overall wonderful meal. Now, the other shoe. Service, while attentive, was sporadic. And please spare me the guitar duo; way to noisy.

Danielle Velez

We were in the area running errands as we normally live in the Bronx. We were a party of 6 and got sat right away. Immediately we noticed we were sat in the same area as a group having a private event. While this didn’t bother us as much we did feel uncomfortable intruding on a private event. We had to ask for our own menus because the waiter hadn’t given us any, as everyone in the restaurant was too busy catering to the event. Once We ordered, the food took an entire hour and when we asked about the timely wait, we were told that events took priority. We said we’d just like to pay for our drinks and be on our way but we were told our food would be right out. Had we been told this before being sat we would completely understand and maybe even went elsewhere as we wouldn’t want to overwhelm the restaurant.The food was alright, but after it took so long we almost lost all our appetites.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

Ashley A.

LOVE this place. My husband and I go very often. The staff is always so friendly and online the best mood. They have live music on the weekends. The drinks are amazing - margaritas especially. The food is so so good. So flavorful. I have not one bad thing to say about this place. Love it!!!

Paulina V.

The host Brian was extremely awesome, despite waiting long for a table he made sure my party was attentive. Def needs a promotion!!

LoveMeSomeSpicyMargaritas

Margaritas never disappoints. Cute Birthday lunch with my daughter. Staff is always so sweet, even made a handwritten birthday message in chocolate on her dessert plate. Beautiful!

Load More