Recommended dishes: Cristy's Classic, Build Your Own X Large Pizza
Alison Lamp
So if Amanda's Cristys looked at our profile then would see we are probably one of their biggest customers we order at least once a week but usually more than that, Cristys can make a darn good pizza, but having said that we know the taste, and everyone here noticed a huge difference in the taste in these pizzas , it tasted more low quality , I won't mention what other pizza places that are lower in quality it tasted like, but it did. We could tell something was way off . Please do not change your ingredients. I know inflation is a thing, but us regulars will know, and I can tell we had 2 different types a pizza, a new york and a regular, and the sauce and cheese didn't taste the same, we didn't even want to finish it.🫥 sorry to say, but I felt like I needed to something, because that's how different it tasted. Sorry, customer service is always good, dilevery always good, but please do not change your pizza
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Benjamin Redman
Tastes like frozen pizza dough sheets and cheap canned pizza sauce. The garlic sauce is just oleo and garlic powder. Big meat pizza was over cooked.
Food: 1
Dylan Ayers
We tried ordering food 2 separate times and neither time did they deliver food, when we called they claimed to never get our order even though our cards were charged. They stole $20.48 from both me and my friend. P.S. To the owner that responded, I don't accept your apology, I called your location, never got my money back, and was told it was my problem. You stole my cash and refused to even admit it. If I could I'd be giving you negative stars, You're not a business, you're thieves.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Merlene Mccoy
This was the best pizza we have gotten from Christys and we are a regular
Food: 5
Service: 5
Summer Boyer
Love the Lancaster locations, and the Amanda location didn't disappoint. A convenient dinner after a late baseball game. Love the Classic. Their Italian and Veggie subs are also delicious.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cristy's Classic, Veggie Sub
Mark Divelbliss
7 dollars for delivery from Amanda to Belmont and 22 is ridiculous
john neuding
This location likes to put barley any toppings on there pizza don't waste you're time an go to Circleville or lancaster
Ashton Myers
Ol' Jelly Roll says it best, "Never let me down"
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Melissa Taylor
I have always loved Cristy's Pizza since I was a kid growing up in Lancaster. Their pizza is always amazing and quality very consistent and great. I'm super cheap though and sometimes they're just a little out of my range especially without deals or coupons, but I highly recommend for a great pizza!
Vegetarian options: They even offer a cauliflower crust pizza for vegans or gluten free option
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Parmesan Cheese Pack, Cristy's Classic, Cristy's Famous Cheesy Breadstix, Chef Salad, House Salad, Large House Salad, Italian Sub, Build Your Own Small Pizza
I don't want to give a star at all.Management there is rude, nasty mouth, Last time I was there .I swore I'd never go back..it's been months now...I even decided not to buy my pizza or sub that day..Sorry for the bad review..I'd never given anyplace a bad report unless it was truly that bad.
Steve Hill
Everything was luke warm to cold tonight, live 2 blocks away
Stacey Freeman
The last probably 5 times we've ordered the pizza was terrible. Sauce tasted spoiled or something. Barely any toppings. Had a half off coupon and was still charged a ridiculous price. Won't be ordering anymore.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
J Moore
Told 20 minutes for order, got notification pizza was ready for pickup , got there and had to wait an additional 20 minutes after it took them 5 minutes to even figure what my order was. 3 people playing on their phones while I waited my additional 20 minutes. Food was definitely not worth a 40 minute wait. This will be my last trip here
Stephanie Hitsman
Used to be great but the last few times we have ordered have not been. Forgot my Parmesan cheese and extra garlic butter that I paid for. Also asked for pie cut and got pretty uneven squares. Tastes ok but consistently missing items from my order- sometimes a 2 lt of pop, sometimes a salad, this time the extra garlic butter. Never get refunds back for missing items— so make sure you are double and triple checking everything before the delivery driver leaves.
best pizza in town
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cristy's Classic, Build Your Own X Large Pizza
So if Amanda's Cristys looked at our profile then would see we are probably one of their biggest customers we order at least once a week but usually more than that, Cristys can make a darn good pizza, but having said that we know the taste, and everyone here noticed a huge difference in the taste in these pizzas , it tasted more low quality , I won't mention what other pizza places that are lower in quality it tasted like, but it did. We could tell something was way off . Please do not change your ingredients. I know inflation is a thing, but us regulars will know, and I can tell we had 2 different types a pizza, a new york and a regular, and the sauce and cheese didn't taste the same, we didn't even want to finish it.🫥 sorry to say, but I felt like I needed to something, because that's how different it tasted. Sorry, customer service is always good, dilevery always good, but please do not change your pizza
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Tastes like frozen pizza dough sheets and cheap canned pizza sauce. The garlic sauce is just oleo and garlic powder. Big meat pizza was over cooked.
Food: 1
We tried ordering food 2 separate times and neither time did they deliver food, when we called they claimed to never get our order even though our cards were charged. They stole $20.48 from both me and my friend. P.S. To the owner that responded, I don't accept your apology, I called your location, never got my money back, and was told it was my problem. You stole my cash and refused to even admit it. If I could I'd be giving you negative stars, You're not a business, you're thieves.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This was the best pizza we have gotten from Christys and we are a regular
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love the Lancaster locations, and the Amanda location didn't disappoint. A convenient dinner after a late baseball game. Love the Classic. Their Italian and Veggie subs are also delicious.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cristy's Classic, Veggie Sub
7 dollars for delivery from Amanda to Belmont and 22 is ridiculous
This location likes to put barley any toppings on there pizza don't waste you're time an go to Circleville or lancaster
Ol' Jelly Roll says it best, "Never let me down"
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have always loved Cristy's Pizza since I was a kid growing up in Lancaster. Their pizza is always amazing and quality very consistent and great. I'm super cheap though and sometimes they're just a little out of my range especially without deals or coupons, but I highly recommend for a great pizza!
Vegetarian options: They even offer a cauliflower crust pizza for vegans or gluten free option
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Parmesan Cheese Pack, Cristy's Classic, Cristy's Famous Cheesy Breadstix, Chef Salad, House Salad, Large House Salad, Italian Sub, Build Your Own Small Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
I don't want to give a star at all.Management there is rude, nasty mouth, Last time I was there .I swore I'd never go back..it's been months now...I even decided not to buy my pizza or sub that day..Sorry for the bad review..I'd never given anyplace a bad report unless it was truly that bad.
Everything was luke warm to cold tonight, live 2 blocks away
The last probably 5 times we've ordered the pizza was terrible. Sauce tasted spoiled or something. Barely any toppings. Had a half off coupon and was still charged a ridiculous price. Won't be ordering anymore.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Told 20 minutes for order, got notification pizza was ready for pickup , got there and had to wait an additional 20 minutes after it took them 5 minutes to even figure what my order was. 3 people playing on their phones while I waited my additional 20 minutes. Food was definitely not worth a 40 minute wait. This will be my last trip here
Used to be great but the last few times we have ordered have not been. Forgot my Parmesan cheese and extra garlic butter that I paid for. Also asked for pie cut and got pretty uneven squares. Tastes ok but consistently missing items from my order- sometimes a 2 lt of pop, sometimes a salad, this time the extra garlic butter. Never get refunds back for missing items— so make sure you are double and triple checking everything before the delivery driver leaves.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Loading...