Papa Johns Pizza

1369 Ohio Pike, Amelia
(513) 753-1515

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Eddie Hagler

I love the garlic and crust

Chris Wynn

Very poor quality food

Taylor Lilly

I order pizza from here all the time ever on Super Bowl day I ordered pizza from them and it was amazing and today my order was 20.97 I called the store and told them all I had was a 50 so I ordered my food and then the store called me back saying there pizza driver wouldn’t take my 50 they don’t take 50’s?! Like are you kidding me like he was getting a tip and everything like why would you not do your job? I will not be ordering pizza or anything else from this establishment money is money people work hard for it if you don’t wanna take it your loss I’ll take my business to another pizza place 👌

Mark Sestina

3 stars for atmosphere, no dining area. Clerk who handed me the pizza seemed ok, 4 stars for 15 seconds. Called in the order and it appears that pizza shops use a central ordering center where a salesperson tries to sell other products. Whatever. Saves time for the actual location making the pizza. So, very little excuse for pizza that wasn't fully baked. Never worked a pizza shop so I don't know the inner workings. It appears that automation is used to get the pizza right. Well something went wrong. 2 stars for the product

Drew Zimpelman (Brutus)

We live 1.3mil away and it took the driver over 20min to get the food to us. Food was nasty and cold. Boneless wings were nothing but soggy chicken nuggets. The Popadia is nothing but two dry small pizzas on top of eachother. The quality has really gone downhill!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

William Gehbauer

Well there's nothing left of the pizza kids ate it up

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

Whiteboy North

I was happy to see my food last night everything was great and fresh I was happy great job guys girls workers keep it up

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie, Papadilla Chicken Parmigiana

Oxyjenn

Pizza is delicious and the team there is the best! They are quick, efficient and always get me any extras I request!I love this location! ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

MyChelle Whitehill

My ONLY reason for low scoring is that your online/AP ordering sucks! Half the time they do not work. I do NOT want to call. So I'm left to order doordash from somewhere else. I LOVE Papa John's!!! But PLEASE work with your ordering apps and online versions... I need my Papa's weekly!!

Food: 5

Service: 3

Michelle Whitehill

My ONLY reason for low scoring is that your online/AP ordering sucks! Half the time they do not work. I do NOT want to call. So I'm left to order doordash from somewhere else. I LOVE Papa John's!!! But PLEASE work with your ordering apps and online versions... I need my Papa's weekly!!

Eric Stivers

Cashier was rude didn't want to serve me , so ended up just leaving not getting anything.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

addi noe

We ordered online as usual, we spoke to an indian man who was messing up our order while we were on the phone with him we repeatedly corrected him (keep in mind he does NOT speak english) yet he still got it wrong. I am pissed we just wanted some food. We never got a refund or credit and yet never got the food we wanted, beyond pissed. Do better next time Papa John’s.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Cheesesticks, Create Your Own Hand Tossed Pizza

Lorie Scheidt

Order from here often but no more. Got an order today that sat on my front porch because I never received a notification. Asked for well done and it’s not even close. Breadsticks are RAW. Wasn’t even during a busy part of the day.

S C

Why does this store refuse to use the papa tracker! I'd like to know when my food is on the way!
Update still refuses to use the tracked but also not training the employees right. When I order cheese bread that says 14 pieces I expect it to be cut right so all on my guest got some but it was cut short and kids don't wait to I had 3 kids without! Ordered 2 and both were wrong! And why are you sending out emails about the driver only! The driver didn't cut my food wrong so why would I rate my food as my driver!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Shawn Penrod

I order from here monthly. It always great and never disappoints. Great pizza and cannot recommend them enough.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Chicken Wings, The Works with Garlic Parmesan Crust

Loading...