Cole's Public House

209 S Main St, Amherst
(440) 984-7432

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Maddux Montgomery

The service was horrible, my mother ordered pasta and told our waitress it was bland and she took it back. She never brought anything back for my mother and we had to split my burger and fries. We didn’t get any word on her food until the end when we found they just took it off our bill, without offering them to remake it or to offer something else to eat. After sending our food back our waitress disappeared and we didn’t see her again until she took the bill to pay it. I can promise there are a lot better options in the area with a lot better service and hospitality.

K Calin

Amazing food. Drinks and atmosphere. Food is flawless everytime. The blueberry mojitos are made with precision. Absolutely amazing place all times of the year!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

donna moats

We tried the summer special watermelon salad. So many wonderful flavors bursting.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeff Kodman

Sadly, wildly inconsistent. About three weeks ago, a Saturday evening, no tables available so we sat at the small bar. Absolutely fantastic meal as we shared the beet & goat cheese salad along with the elk chops entree. Cooked perfectly. Tuesday evening was however, a complete disaster. Chicken Florentine that could not be cut with a steak knife. Pistachio Lamb Rack that was so incredibly raw. Gave them a chance for a mulligan by having them take back the lamb and ordered the Elk Rack Chop. Everything arrived as if it had been in a fire. Charcoal elk surrounded with a few sweet potatoes that had a quarter inch of ash on their tops. Spoke with the cook since apparently no manager was working. $124 for an experience no one would call a dinner let alone a wedding anniversary dinner.

Daniel Rodriguez

Excellent experience! Cozy spot. Food was excellent. Beers were very good, nice variety. Service was outstanding, we really enjoyed ourselves! Highly recommend the fries although everything we tried was delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jordan Davidson

Went on Saturday and they staffed the place with 2 workers. After over an hour of waiting with an 11 month old we got our soup... Decided to leave early. Would not recommend going if you have kids

Debbie Siss

Food & service was excellent!!

Graham's Dad

Got the Snapper and risotto. The fish was great, but the risotto was almost cold when I got it. The ratatouille was excellent!

Viktoriya Skubyak

We enjoyed our food equally as much as we enjoyed the warmth and uniqueness of this establishment. We are looking forward to coming back for a Taco Tuesday.
Thank you!

Ayyy “king” Bee

Anna L spectacular service my dear, thank you! You made galentines day phenomenal & we are so glad we met you! You can hang anytime, you're cool people!

allen savina

Cold food and slow service

Elisa Boles

Very slow service, fries were cold, and server was not good.

Kathleen Heyman

Food was great. Atmosphere great. Service good. Headbanging music sucked!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Truffle Fries House Burger Classic Onion Soup

John H

Excellent drink selection. Fries were good. Skip the shrimp cocktail, its disappointing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Chili Rubbed Shrimp Cocktail Market

Kevin Squires

Perfectly prepared food, from the side salad to the day special surf and turf. Drinks were great, and our server Heather was equally great. Very good all around.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...