Bakery On The Square

34 Public Sq, Andover
(440) 293-1200

Recent Reviews

Susan Wright

My husband and I stopped by. We got a cinnamon roll and a jelly roll. Everything was fresh and amazing!! I sampled a bite of cake and it was the best tasting cake I ever had!! Everything was a taste of heaven!! Owners are very friendly, wonderful people!! Highly recommend!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Uma Pansari

They are the best !! Once you buy their bread you will be hooked . Love supporting a small family owned business.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eugene Robert Conner

Everything I have bought there was great.Love the pizza shells!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rita Sklenar

Beyond amazing English muffins!! Light fluffy and so delicious,all made from scratch ! I had the delight of having their savory herb flavor. I was so delighted to find such a gem. European bakeries have nothing on these people! Keep up the delicious work you do! It's such a craft.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ellen Kolman

Beautiful baked goods, excellent coffee, and sweet people behind the counter who support their community...definitely worth the drive!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Misty Ison

Ordered 1/4 sheet. Chocolate with chocolate icing. She was unable to do any writing on the cake and that was fine.When I picked the cake up, I was just going to do it myself.Upon arrival, she brought me cake and it was undoubtedly the most beautiful cake I had ever seen! It was iced in layers of beautiful flowers! I had never seen a cake that was so beautiful!It was delicious! Moist and the icing was a delicious chocolate buttercream. Everyone was raving over this cake!!I can't thank you enough!!!It was complete perfection!!

Mariah Carna

I visited this bakery for the first time this past weekend and it will certainly not be my last. The bakery is so cute and has so many options. I bought a loaf of Sourdough Bread and the owner told me all about when the starter was created and about their starters for their other breads dating back to the 1800s. The sourdough loaf is incredible, light, fluffy, and has a great taste.

Kyla Colcombe

Their bread is pretty good but the rest isn't the greatest. Just a small bakery in Andover. They have coffee and make drinks by request but they're pretty average. I would skip if given the choice. Wish them the best of luck

Sue Hall

Ordered for the first time here. Icing was paper thin, very very thinly iced. Nobody finished their cake. So embarrassed. Ordered a cake for my husbands birthday. He and our guests were very disappointed. Expected a better cake from a bakery, will not order again.

Stacie Rhoades

Delightful shop! Upon entering I was greeted by the owner, who gave me a tour of their store - they have items for sale made by local artists and she provided some info about them! The baked goods are unique and tasty! A very welcoming and enjoyable place to visit! I highly recommend :)

Lori Bruckner-Shanks

I really like their homemade baked goods and their coffee. The family that runs the bakery is very nice and welcoming to everyone that enters.

Sarah Gyorki

The outside isn't cute but don't let it fool you! This is a great little spot - really good fresh-baked treats, a nice menu of coffee and tea drinks, good service, friendly people and tons of character. Bonus - well chosen selection of jewelry and gifts. A nice spot to browse, sit and read the paper or take a little picnic out on the square.

Yvonne Buttitta

Love ? this bakery, we have tried everything atleast once, we are only in town periodically and would love to see if you can ship breads and bakery within Ohio ?Their sourdough bread is Fabulous , cinnamon bread melts in your mouth , French toast is perfect and quiches are light and tasteful

Mags

Artisans. Period. Visit, try something new, or try something you know, just enjoy yourself and take home a loaf, a scone, anything they make. You won’t regret it, and you’ll return again and again for a taste of old European excellence nestled in Andover, Ohio. Respecting and believing in artistry, you’ll feel a true investment in this family and business if you believe in excellence and the greatness small business can achieve in rural America. Very lucky to have them here.

Richard Campbell

No care attitude

Load More