This is the best homemade local small business pizza close to this area. Your stupid if you don't give these guys a try. Don't fall for the slick talk an fancy social media advertising. I guarentee you give Pizza Cutter the chance it's worth every penny to support this pizza spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sandee Kirkwood
Great pizza and wings, love the Garlic Sauce!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Boneless Wings, Extra Large Pepperoni Pizza, Extra Large Deluxe Pizza
Laura Trigalet
We get our pizza there pretty much every Friday. Great tasting pizza. Heather is a great person.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Extra Large Pepperoni Sausage and Mushrooms
scott lunn
My family has been ordering from here since we moved to Sheffield Lake. It is a little family owned shop with only a couple of employees. Every pizza that we have tried from there has been good. It can get a bit pricey but when you get great service and handmade ingredients, it is well worth the cost. If you are looking to get away from the chain pizza places, pizza cutter is definitely worth trying.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pizza
Amanda
They need to update hours on their website. I called at 8:45 to place order, only to be told that they are closing up. It says they are open until 10:00. I guess another place will get my $.
Charles Sullivan
I thought it was pretty good especially for the price
Robert Young
Our first time here. Why did we wait so long? The best pizza in town, super nice people, all fresh made ingredients and locally owned small business. Been there forever and now we see why. We can't wait to come back!Parking: Plenty of easy parking. And it's next to a great liquor shop!
Megan L
Looking for pizza in Avon/Avon Lake? Pizza cutter is so good.I have worked a couple different local pizza places in Avon lake, and we still almost always order from pizza cutter.The sauce is perfect, no over powering flavors, just good marinara. The crust is crispy, and somewhere between a thin crust and a pan crust. Not too much, it’s just right.We always order an extra cheese with pepperoni, and it’s always good.They don’t always have a delivery driver, but the pizza is worth the short drive to pick up the pizza.
Recommended dishes: Extra Large Pepperoni Pizza
Estee Arend
Crispy crust, delicious sauce, and reasonably priced. Their garlic bread is a big portion with a nice portion of pizza sauce for dipping. Pizza was yummy and cooked to perfection. It was 21 bucks for a large and garlic bread. I felt that was less expensive than other places. Will definitely order again.
Deborah C.
Love this place! Pizza is fresh! Price is good! I love the Hawaiian style pizza! Not all pizza places know how to make it!!! My husband likes the pepperoni
If I could give higher than 5 stars I would! Hands down the best pizza joint in town! I love their pizza it was a Sunday ritual for our household when we lived in Avon Lake. We moved to North Ridgeville and still make the drive on Sundays to get the pizza because it's our favorite. Highly recommend. We get the Large and it feeds 3-4 people if you want leftovers get XL and pricing is very reasonable
Tracey Stacey
Good pizza a little pricey but good for the money. Better than all the places in Avon lake
Andrew Dlugosz
My wife and I just had your pizza again yesterday. Now that we live out of AL we do not get to indulge as much as I would like. Still amazing pizza. BEST IN LORAIN COUNTY!!
jbomb 113
Good pizza, but they recently jacked up their prices. Unfortunately I won't be coming here anymore.
Kenneth F
To my wife and my liking this was average at best. Good service. Pick up was hot, It is in a strip mall that needs some updating by the owner but not the tenant fault. Place appeared clean
This is the best homemade local small business pizza close to this area. Your stupid if you don't give these guys a try. Don't fall for the slick talk an fancy social media advertising. I guarentee you give Pizza Cutter the chance it's worth every penny to support this pizza spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza and wings, love the Garlic Sauce!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Boneless Wings, Extra Large Pepperoni Pizza, Extra Large Deluxe Pizza
We get our pizza there pretty much every Friday. Great tasting pizza. Heather is a great person.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Extra Large Pepperoni Sausage and Mushrooms
My family has been ordering from here since we moved to Sheffield Lake. It is a little family owned shop with only a couple of employees. Every pizza that we have tried from there has been good. It can get a bit pricey but when you get great service and handmade ingredients, it is well worth the cost. If you are looking to get away from the chain pizza places, pizza cutter is definitely worth trying.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pizza
They need to update hours on their website. I called at 8:45 to place order, only to be told that they are closing up. It says they are open until 10:00. I guess another place will get my $.
I thought it was pretty good especially for the price
Our first time here. Why did we wait so long? The best pizza in town, super nice people, all fresh made ingredients and locally owned small business. Been there forever and now we see why. We can't wait to come back!Parking: Plenty of easy parking. And it's next to a great liquor shop!
Looking for pizza in Avon/Avon Lake? Pizza cutter is so good.I have worked a couple different local pizza places in Avon lake, and we still almost always order from pizza cutter.The sauce is perfect, no over powering flavors, just good marinara. The crust is crispy, and somewhere between a thin crust and a pan crust. Not too much, it’s just right.We always order an extra cheese with pepperoni, and it’s always good.They don’t always have a delivery driver, but the pizza is worth the short drive to pick up the pizza.
Recommended dishes: Extra Large Pepperoni Pizza
Crispy crust, delicious sauce, and reasonably priced. Their garlic bread is a big portion with a nice portion of pizza sauce for dipping. Pizza was yummy and cooked to perfection. It was 21 bucks for a large and garlic bread. I felt that was less expensive than other places. Will definitely order again.
Love this place! Pizza is fresh! Price is good! I love the Hawaiian style pizza! Not all pizza places know how to make it!!! My husband likes the pepperoni
Restaurantji Recommends
If I could give higher than 5 stars I would! Hands down the best pizza joint in town! I love their pizza it was a Sunday ritual for our household when we lived in Avon Lake. We moved to North Ridgeville and still make the drive on Sundays to get the pizza because it's our favorite. Highly recommend. We get the Large and it feeds 3-4 people if you want leftovers get XL and pricing is very reasonable
Good pizza a little pricey but good for the money. Better than all the places in Avon lake
My wife and I just had your pizza again yesterday. Now that we live out of AL we do not get to indulge as much as I would like. Still amazing pizza. BEST IN LORAIN COUNTY!!
Good pizza, but they recently jacked up their prices. Unfortunately I won't be coming here anymore.
To my wife and my liking this was average at best. Good service. Pick up was hot, It is in a strip mall that needs some updating by the owner but not the tenant fault. Place appeared clean