Would be best to call Lorissa and have her come back. Place has went to hell in a handbag. Pizza burnt "cheesy bread" was a soggy sub bun with cheese.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Camlin Thompson
I’ve lived in Bainbridge for around 6 months when I first tried fly girl I wasn’t a huge fan of the crust but it wasn’t bad pizza and it’s fairly priced so I continued to eat there. The other night I was expecting same old same old and let me tell you I was shocked! This was by far one of the best pizza experiences I’ve ever had the new crust is more fluffy and tastes great they had to remake my pizza because something happened to the first one but I didn’t have to wait long at all they were very fast, very nice, and it was very very delicious highly recommend!
Patti Sholar
This was the WORST pizza I have ever had!!! I can't believe they are still in business. The pizza is so sweet its disgusting!! I am not exaggerating. I honestly can't believe they call it pizza. How do I even begin to describe it... It's like sweet cheese, sweet pepperoni and sweet tomato sauce on a donut. We took 3 bites too many and threw it in the trash. I never give restaurant reviews but I felt compelled to warn others. It's a real shame that the lovely little town of Bainbridge has the worst pizza on the planet.
Food: 1
Colt Lytle
Excellent food, great sauce and crust. Great service
Ed Nero
I’ve eaten food (pizza,subs and breadsticks) from here 4 times and it just keeps getting worse. Dough was not fresh and is always under cooked. I tried to support local small business but I can’t waste anymore money here. Had to toss the pizza and order from the Paxton.
Nellie Helterbrand
We were in Bainbridge for the circus that was in town and just made an evening of it so we had dinner out. Of course, pizza is at the top of the list for any kid...this place was so good! The food, employees, and atmosphere was all wonderful we'll definitely be going back!
Parking: It wasn't very clear on what was designated for the parking area so I parked on the street and asked if where I parked was ok the owner said it was fine and I was all good ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lüdi Rich
Cheesy bread was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dana Knisley
Pizza Cold Crust extremely hard Couldn’t chew crust Worst I’ve gotten from there in year Before the name change Wasted 25.00 ?
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni & Cheese Pizza
claudia rodriguez
The most delicious pizza and salad that I ever taste!! The service was amazing, and everything was fresh and prepared quickly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anita O'Cull
Not great. My cheese pizza was sweet. Not my bag. Portions are small.
Dessert pizza crust was so thin and rock hard, couldn’t even eat it :( also was not cut Probally due to how hard it was.
Cheese bread was thin and hard also :(
Pizza was okay but the crust was a little doughy. Definitely needed more toppings. Barly any :(
Jake Kohl
Ordered a LG 4 topping pizza and literally counted 10 Pepperonis and couldn't find the bacon. There was two small slivers of onions and the cheese was barely visible against the light colored crust.The sauce was very bland like a cheap knockoff can of no name brand pizza sauce you'd find at the Dollqr Tree.i’ve had this place before and it was very good and I don’t know what’s changed but it is absolutely horrible. New owners?The lady's were friendly but the taste and quality and quantity of toppings were very embarrassing.This place will be in for some trouble once the other pizza place opens down the road.I feel like I paid $20 for a bland tasting loaf of bread.I won't be back!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
Priscilla EspinozaMiller
Friday March 8, 2024Super sweet ladies. But also a super very very sugar-sweet pizza. I have never had a sugary pepperoni and cheese pizza. Got cheesy bread which was less sweet but also came with sweet marinara.I am not looking forward to reading my blood sugar tonight. If you are diabetic this really should come with a sugar warning.The pizza was burnt (I believe now, because of the sugar content) but she told me and I did accept it because we were passing through on a day trip and asked if she'd throw in a literal bag of chips which she gladly did. She told me to call back and tell her if the pizza was okay. I called back but I knew they were busy so I didn't even ask for any money back (because we did eat the cheese off the crust -near starving and short on time?-and the chips.) I asked if the pizza was supposed to be this sweet and she said they were trying out this new crust so I said okay...But, like, if you ever want to swear off of pizza forever, eat here to jumpstart your determination on your new diet! You'll never want pizza again! But, again, responsive service and super sweet, kind ladies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni & Cheese Pizza
Kim Rapp
Pizza is very good. But it needs more sauce and more toppings for what you pay. I love the sauce my belly doesn't hurt when I eat it.
Would be best to call Lorissa and have her come back. Place has went to hell in a handbag. Pizza burnt "cheesy bread" was a soggy sub bun with cheese.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
I’ve lived in Bainbridge for around 6 months when I first tried fly girl I wasn’t a huge fan of the crust but it wasn’t bad pizza and it’s fairly priced so I continued to eat there. The other night I was expecting same old same old and let me tell you I was shocked! This was by far one of the best pizza experiences I’ve ever had the new crust is more fluffy and tastes great they had to remake my pizza because something happened to the first one but I didn’t have to wait long at all they were very fast, very nice, and it was very very delicious highly recommend!
This was the WORST pizza I have ever had!!!
I can't believe they are still in business. The pizza is so sweet its disgusting!! I am not exaggerating. I honestly can't believe they call it pizza. How do I even begin to describe it... It's like sweet cheese, sweet pepperoni and sweet tomato sauce on a donut. We took 3 bites too many and threw it in the trash. I never give restaurant reviews but I felt compelled to warn others. It's a real shame that the lovely little town of Bainbridge has the worst pizza on the planet.
Food: 1
Excellent food, great sauce and crust. Great service
I’ve eaten food (pizza,subs and breadsticks) from here 4 times and it just keeps getting worse. Dough was not fresh and is always under cooked. I tried to support local small business but I can’t waste anymore money here. Had to toss the pizza and order from the Paxton.
We were in Bainbridge for the circus that was in town and just made an evening of it so we had dinner out. Of course, pizza is at the top of the list for any kid...this place was so good! The food, employees, and atmosphere was all wonderful we'll definitely be going back!
Parking: It wasn't very clear on what was designated for the parking area so I parked on the street and asked if where I parked was ok the owner said it was fine and I was all good ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cheesy bread was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza Cold
Crust extremely hard
Couldn’t chew crust
Worst I’ve gotten from there in year
Before the name change
Wasted 25.00 ?
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni & Cheese Pizza
The most delicious pizza and salad that I ever taste!! The service was amazing, and everything was fresh and prepared quickly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not great. My cheese pizza was sweet. Not my bag. Portions are small.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Dessert pizza crust was so thin and rock hard, couldn’t even eat it :( also was not cut Probally due to how hard it was. Cheese bread was thin and hard also :( Pizza was okay but the crust was a little doughy. Definitely needed more toppings. Barly any :(
Ordered a LG 4 topping pizza and literally counted 10 Pepperonis and couldn't find the bacon. There was two small slivers of onions and the cheese was barely visible against the light colored crust.The sauce was very bland like a cheap knockoff can of no name brand pizza sauce you'd find at the Dollqr Tree.i’ve had this place before and it was very good and I don’t know what’s changed but it is absolutely horrible. New owners?The lady's were friendly but the taste and quality and quantity of toppings were very embarrassing.This place will be in for some trouble once the other pizza place opens down the road.I feel like I paid $20 for a bland tasting loaf of bread.I won't be back!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
Friday March 8, 2024Super sweet ladies. But also a super very very sugar-sweet pizza. I have never had a sugary pepperoni and cheese pizza. Got cheesy bread which was less sweet but also came with sweet marinara.I am not looking forward to reading my blood sugar tonight. If you are diabetic this really should come with a sugar warning.The pizza was burnt (I believe now, because of the sugar content) but she told me and I did accept it because we were passing through on a day trip and asked if she'd throw in a literal bag of chips which she gladly did. She told me to call back and tell her if the pizza was okay. I called back but I knew they were busy so I didn't even ask for any money back (because we did eat the cheese off the crust -near starving and short on time?-and the chips.) I asked if the pizza was supposed to be this sweet and she said they were trying out this new crust so I said okay...But, like, if you ever want to swear off of pizza forever, eat here to jumpstart your determination on your new diet! You'll never want pizza again! But, again, responsive service and super sweet, kind ladies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni & Cheese Pizza
Pizza is very good. But it needs more sauce and more toppings for what you pay. I love the sauce my belly doesn't hurt when I eat it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni & Cheese Pizza
Ok for pizza and there menu
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni & Cheese Pizza
Loading...