I live just down the road in Jackson, Ohio yet I’ve never heard of this place. Decided to give it a try and wasn’t disappointed. Great food and a great atmosphere. Large variety of menu options. Definitely will eat there again and try their pizza!
Brandt Kingery
Great little dinner with good food!!!!!
Jason Shoemaker
Went here because I like trying "Mom and Pop shops." As a former chef I love finding hidden gems like this one. Got an introduction to the owner, who was an awesome gentleman, with genuine questions about the quality of the food. He wanted to make sure it was up to a standard, and that standard is to be the best around. I'm of the opinion that he has nothing to worry about! We ordered a Double Cheeseburger, a Mushroom Swiss, a pepperoni pizza, fries, and cheese sticks. I can say that nothing disappointed. The burgers weren't eaten as much as they were inhaled. The pizza, the boys said they'd rather drive the 50 minutes to eat here than anything I our town, and I have to agree. the crust was perfect, sauce slightly sweet but not overvearing, 3 cheese blend and the small pepperoni that curl and crisp and hold a little of their grease inside! The fries were well cooked and I'm picky about fries more than most foods. Simple, but easy to mess up, but they didn't! I'm so glad we found this place, and we will for sure be back!
Margitta Seibert-Bailey
This place is an adventure in itself. The food is delicious and the owner is one of the friendliest people I have met on my travels!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Danny Christy
Great parking. Restrooms are clean. Atmosphere is nice and the food is great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Wills
Good food, different flavors of ice cream, old classie in side
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff Miller
I've had the brick oven pizza, grilled chicken sandwich, and several other items, all have been excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mary Mahoney
Super friendly, super clean and super good fresh food! We had the hamburgers that are made from scratch. Photo is of Sully burger with coleslaw and it was super yummy! Bonus points for the toasted bun!! Gold bond malt completed this awesome lunch! We could tell the owner really cares about the food and the appearance of his place. Great stop!!
I've only ordered from Sully's in the Valley twice now! The employees are so nice. Food is ready in no time & worth every penny ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Curds
Jessica Fluty
While working in Beaver , OH, we've eaten here a few times because it's always great service , great food & a wonderful atmosphere. You truly get what you pay for here! Great prices!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lori Mcgath
O.M.G. first time visiting. Fell in love with this place as soon as I walked in the door. 50s music playing, the atmosphere was the 50s, everything here was the 50s. I had to buy a t.shirt to remind me I was here. We were greated with such a warm hello and welcome, they took our order, and we had our choice of seating inside or outside. Very clean and well kept. We sat outside enjoying the music as they brought us our lunches and ask if we needed anything..they ask if the music was to loud if so they will turn it down...but we thought it was perfect...nothing like dancing in your seat as you eat. Lol. I loved it. Already told friends and family out this place they need to visit. The food is fresh, it's hot, French fries was really good I was told by my family members.... I definitely want to go back . I'm from lancaster/ Circleville Ohio and it's well worth the trip there. Thank Sully's best lunch I've had in a very long time.
Parking: The parking lot is on their property..plenty of space ..no problem
Wheelchair accessibility: Easy enough to get a wheelchair through the restaurant or seating outside on the patio.
Best food i've ever had in my entire life. The restaurant is so cozy and the people are so friendly. I recommend the pizza and the cheese burger.???
Jane “MJ” Marcum
Great food, very clean, staff was friendly and helpful. Must recommend the banana split. We got hand dipped Perrys ice cream in our banana split black raspberry, study break, and banana cream pie with Carmel drizzle instead of hot fudge, delicious combo! Pizza was cooked in fire brick over very good crust. Highly recommend the potato skins.
I live just down the road in Jackson, Ohio yet I’ve never heard of this place. Decided to give it a try and wasn’t disappointed. Great food and a great atmosphere. Large variety of menu options. Definitely will eat there again and try their pizza!
Great little dinner with good food!!!!!
Went here because I like trying "Mom and Pop shops." As a former chef I love finding hidden gems like this one. Got an introduction to the owner, who was an awesome gentleman, with genuine questions about the quality of the food. He wanted to make sure it was up to a standard, and that standard is to be the best around. I'm of the opinion that he has nothing to worry about! We ordered a Double Cheeseburger, a Mushroom Swiss, a pepperoni pizza, fries, and cheese sticks. I can say that nothing disappointed. The burgers weren't eaten as much as they were inhaled. The pizza, the boys said they'd rather drive the 50 minutes to eat here than anything I our town, and I have to agree. the crust was perfect, sauce slightly sweet but not overvearing, 3 cheese blend and the small pepperoni that curl and crisp and hold a little of their grease inside! The fries were well cooked and I'm picky about fries more than most foods. Simple, but easy to mess up, but they didn't! I'm so glad we found this place, and we will for sure be back!
This place is an adventure in itself. The food is delicious and the owner is one of the friendliest people I have met on my travels!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great parking. Restrooms are clean. Atmosphere is nice and the food is great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good food, different flavors of ice cream, old classie in side
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've had the brick oven pizza, grilled chicken sandwich, and several other items, all have been excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Super friendly, super clean and super good fresh food! We had the hamburgers that are made from scratch. Photo is of Sully burger with coleslaw and it was super yummy! Bonus points for the toasted bun!! Gold bond malt completed this awesome lunch!
We could tell the owner really cares about the food and the appearance of his place.
Great stop!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had the Alfredo pizza and it’s the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza and ice cream is amazing
Restaurantji Recommends
I've only ordered from Sully's in the Valley twice now! The employees are so nice. Food is ready in no time & worth every penny ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Curds
While working in Beaver , OH, we've eaten here a few times because it's always great service , great food & a wonderful atmosphere.
You truly get what you pay for here! Great prices!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
O.M.G. first time visiting.
Fell in love with this place as soon as I walked in the door.
50s music playing, the atmosphere was the 50s, everything here was the 50s.
I had to buy a t.shirt to remind me I was here.
We were greated with such a warm hello and welcome, they took our order, and we had our choice of seating inside or outside.
Very clean and well kept.
We sat outside enjoying the music as they brought us our lunches and ask if we needed anything..they ask if the music was to loud if so they will turn it down...but we thought it was perfect...nothing like dancing in your seat as you eat. Lol.
I loved it. Already told friends and family out this place they need to visit. The food is fresh, it's hot, French fries was really good I was told by my family members....
I definitely want to go back .
I'm from lancaster/ Circleville Ohio and it's well worth the trip there.
Thank Sully's best lunch I've had in a very long time.
Parking: The parking lot is on their property..plenty of space ..no problem
Wheelchair accessibility: Easy enough to get a wheelchair through the restaurant or seating outside on the patio.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Chicken Strip Sandwich
Best food i've ever had in my entire life. The restaurant is so cozy and the people are so friendly. I recommend the pizza and the cheese burger.???
Great food, very clean, staff was friendly and helpful. Must recommend the banana split. We got hand dipped Perrys ice cream in our banana split black raspberry, study break, and banana cream pie with Carmel drizzle instead of hot fudge, delicious combo! Pizza was cooked in fire brick over very good crust. Highly recommend the potato skins.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Texas Tenderloin Sandwich, Pepperoni Pizza, Undercooked Burger
Loading...