Just mediocre all around. I don't know how this place receives great reviews they do. It was great several years ago when I attended, but has declined dramatically.I ordered two pizzas. One Sicilian and one Regular both with two types of pepperoni. The server came up to me and said she rang it in differently to save money. She rang it in as some specialty pizza that had parmesan and all of this other crap on it I did not want. If I wanted that stuff, I would've ordered it. She goes back and comes out all apologetic and fixed it. I'm just glad that I read the menu thoroughly before ordering! Crisis averted.The person I was with wanted beer, and they had no domestic drafts??? He got bottles of Miller Lite instead. It just seemed odd. If they did, the server didn't know.I did order Pepperolis a little bit later. They're an appetizer that I had remembered getting before and forgot about. Asked to add to order. The food comes out and there were SOOO little pepperonis in the pepperolis. Like it tasted like I was just eating bread.The Sicilian was WAY too thick. No, it's not a problem with Sicilian Pizzas. There are many places I have gotten Sicilian Style Pizzas at which did not have this problem. It also lacked the natural crunch that Sicilian style places had. Like I was just biting into a giant dough with tons of air. There was so little cheese on it that it was almost criminal. All of the pepperonis were piled into the middle and I picked them off to enjoy the edge pieces.The regular pizza was pretty good. Not like how I remembered it years ago, but still good. Probably would get it like twice per year if I lived in Bellefontaine for takeout.They did have a great menu. Interesting selection. Lots of crust options. Many different pizzas I'd never order for myself but I thought it was cool regardless.I felt bad for the server and I always tip. She was very nice. I admired her intentions on trying to provide customer service. The total was like $77 or something. I wrote "$100" on the bottom line and they took out $101. It's not that big of deal. $1 is $1. But with everything else? Yeah I won't be returning here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizza Peperoni
Craig Fruchey
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Craig D-son
First time going. The pizza was really good. Had the double barrel on regular Italian crust, and the bianca on Italian crust and garlic knots. All of it was better than most pizza places. The table beside us had a Detroit style crust which I want to go back and try. Service was also good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pizza Peperoni, Ziti with Meatballs
Annette Brothers
Pretty good pizza being sold by the slice on solar eclipse day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Peperoni
Jeff Dodge
Close or out of town, take a trip and have an adventure. The drive to beautiful Logan County gives you Hocking Hills vibes. The pizza (They have three types) or the traditional is a New York style. Brick oven pizza ovens that deliver a delicious char to an outstanding dough. The sauce is on the sweeter side (which we love). Both styles of pepperoni available. The cheese is gooey and melts in your mouth. The Detroit style is in a class of its own, if that is your thing. Sicilian is very good (just not my thing) but I don't order it enough to really speak on it. The beer menu is loaded with options. They even have an event space that is adorable if you are having a large gathering. Saving the best for last: The people. The people who work here are kind, caring, and attentive. We have had multiple servers over the years and they all have a commonality. They care for you and your experience. A magical environment. Cheers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Richards
Busy night and service was great. They make a good pizza here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: American Muscle
Frederick Rudolph
This place has excellent pizza. But the service sucks I sat waiting for someone to serve me for over 15 min No one even looked at me. I don’t think I will be backAnd this is not the first time.Service sucks.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Ashley Schutte
1st timer excellent service hot food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
JJP Mustang
Love the pizza- have had several crusts and topping combos over the years. Stopped in last night and our server ghosted us for 10-15 minutes at a time every instance when we needed him. It took asking 3 different employees to finally get cashed out. I know it was close to closing time when we were done but 4-5 other tables were still eating and getting good service from their server ?♂️
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Les McDonald
Best pizza place we've been to in a long while. The Mad Hatter is out of this
I cannot believe someone was caught in the bathroom pleasuring themselves. And to make it even worse, it was the manager who caught the worker and nothing was done. Very nasty and
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Bryan Olijslagers
Top notch service and really good pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
AundreaB
We are frequent patrons at 600 Downtown and love it so much. Tonight our crust was a little well done, but we didn't say anything. A short time later, our waiter told us that they had made us another pizza since our other pizza was overdone. We were so surprised! Highly recommend!
We have been here many times. The last time we came we said never again because of bad service. We came last night for a friends anniversary. There were 8 of us. They sat us in the back room which we love. Great atmosphere back there. We ordered drinks and ordered appetizers at the same time. It took us 30 min for all of us to get drinks. We had good conversation so didn't mind. Appetizers were good. Had the garlic knots and meatballs. Hardly ever saw our waiter through the whole process. It took about 45 MORE minutes of our 2 hour debacle to get our food. One couples pizza was cold. I asked for no onions on mine. I cannot eat onions they disagree with me. They said they would put another one in oven right away. My husband ordered a small pizza also with light sauce and it was drenched in sauce he spent most of the time trying to scrape it off. After 30 more minutes everyone was done and my food never arrived. I told them to put it in a box to go. They took it off the bill but it was kind of embarrassing sitting there watching everyone eat. While they were preparing the checks I went up front to talk to the manager. She came out a very young women. She was smiling and nice. I told her about our experience and how awful it was for me personally. I told her most likely we would not be back that this wasn't the first time. She just said she was sorry. Did not even try to make it right. No conversation from her just I'm sorry? They should have taken my husband's off the bill also he only ate two pieces. Any way. Sad to say we won't be giving them another chance. Seems to the group that after observing this whole situation this place is very poorly managed. We were even nice to the waiter. We told him we understood that it wasn't his fault. He shrugged is shoulders as if he didn't care. Poor service, poor management.
It was our first time eating there, and I can tell you we'll definitely be back! Our server was fantastic. He guided us through the menu and shared with us popular menu items. I would definitely recommend SIX Hundred Downtown to anyone looking for a place to eat in Bellefontaine.
Just mediocre all around. I don't know how this place receives great reviews they do. It was great several years ago when I attended, but has declined dramatically.I ordered two pizzas. One Sicilian and one Regular both with two types of pepperoni. The server came up to me and said she rang it in differently to save money. She rang it in as some specialty pizza that had parmesan and all of this other crap on it I did not want. If I wanted that stuff, I would've ordered it. She goes back and comes out all apologetic and fixed it. I'm just glad that I read the menu thoroughly before ordering! Crisis averted.The person I was with wanted beer, and they had no domestic drafts??? He got bottles of Miller Lite instead. It just seemed odd. If they did, the server didn't know.I did order Pepperolis a little bit later. They're an appetizer that I had remembered getting before and forgot about. Asked to add to order. The food comes out and there were SOOO little pepperonis in the pepperolis. Like it tasted like I was just eating bread.The Sicilian was WAY too thick. No, it's not a problem with Sicilian Pizzas. There are many places I have gotten Sicilian Style Pizzas at which did not have this problem. It also lacked the natural crunch that Sicilian style places had. Like I was just biting into a giant dough with tons of air. There was so little cheese on it that it was almost criminal. All of the pepperonis were piled into the middle and I picked them off to enjoy the edge pieces.The regular pizza was pretty good. Not like how I remembered it years ago, but still good. Probably would get it like twice per year if I lived in Bellefontaine for takeout.They did have a great menu. Interesting selection. Lots of crust options. Many different pizzas I'd never order for myself but I thought it was cool regardless.I felt bad for the server and I always tip. She was very nice. I admired her intentions on trying to provide customer service. The total was like $77 or something. I wrote "$100" on the bottom line and they took out $101. It's not that big of deal. $1 is $1. But with everything else? Yeah I won't be returning here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizza Peperoni
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time going. The pizza was really good. Had the double barrel on regular Italian crust, and the bianca on Italian crust and garlic knots. All of it was better than most pizza places. The table beside us had a Detroit style crust which I want to go back and try. Service was also good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pizza Peperoni, Ziti with Meatballs
Pretty good pizza being sold by the slice on solar eclipse day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Peperoni
Close or out of town, take a trip and have an adventure. The drive to beautiful Logan County gives you Hocking Hills vibes. The pizza (They have three types) or the traditional is a New York style. Brick oven pizza ovens that deliver a delicious char to an outstanding dough. The sauce is on the sweeter side (which we love). Both styles of pepperoni available. The cheese is gooey and melts in your mouth. The Detroit style is in a class of its own, if that is your thing. Sicilian is very good (just not my thing) but I don't order it enough to really speak on it. The beer menu is loaded with options. They even have an event space that is adorable if you are having a large gathering. Saving the best for last: The people. The people who work here are kind, caring, and attentive. We have had multiple servers over the years and they all have a commonality. They care for you and your experience. A magical environment. Cheers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Busy night and service was great. They make a good pizza here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: American Muscle
This place has excellent pizza. But the service sucks I sat waiting for someone to serve me for over 15 min No one even looked at me. I don’t think I will be backAnd this is not the first time.Service sucks.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
1st timer excellent service hot food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Love the pizza- have had several crusts and topping combos over the years. Stopped in last night and our server ghosted us for 10-15 minutes at a time every instance when we needed him. It took asking 3 different employees to finally get cashed out. I know it was close to closing time when we were done but 4-5 other tables were still eating and getting good service from their server ?♂️
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Best pizza place we've been to in a long while. The Mad Hatter is out of this
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mad Hatter Pizza, Montana Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
I cannot believe someone was caught in the bathroom pleasuring themselves. And to make it even worse, it was the manager who caught the worker and nothing was done. Very nasty and
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Top notch service and really good pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We are frequent patrons at 600 Downtown and love it so much. Tonight our crust was a little well done, but we didn't say anything. A short time later, our waiter told us that they had made us another pizza since our other pizza was overdone. We were so surprised! Highly recommend!
We have been here many times. The last time we came we said never again because of bad service. We came last night for a friends anniversary. There were 8 of us. They sat us in the back room which we love. Great atmosphere back there. We ordered drinks and ordered appetizers at the same time. It took us 30 min for all of us to get drinks. We had good conversation so didn't mind. Appetizers were good. Had the garlic knots and meatballs. Hardly ever saw our waiter through the whole process. It took about 45 MORE minutes of our 2 hour debacle to get our food. One couples pizza was cold. I asked for no onions on mine. I cannot eat onions they disagree with me. They said they would put another one in oven right away. My husband ordered a small pizza also with light sauce and it was drenched in sauce he spent most of the time trying to scrape it off. After 30 more minutes everyone was done and my food never arrived. I told them to put it in a box to go. They took it off the bill but it was kind of embarrassing sitting there watching everyone eat. While they were preparing the checks I went up front to talk to the manager. She came out a very young women. She was smiling and nice. I told her about our experience and how awful it was for me personally. I told her most likely we would not be back that this wasn't the first time. She just said she was sorry. Did not even try to make it right. No conversation from her just I'm sorry? They should have taken my husband's off the bill also he only ate two pieces. Any way. Sad to say we won't be giving them another chance. Seems to the group that after observing this whole situation this place is very poorly managed. We were even nice to the waiter. We told him we understood that it wasn't his fault. He shrugged is shoulders as if he didn't care. Poor service, poor management.
It was our first time eating there, and I can tell you we'll definitely be back! Our server was fantastic. He guided us through the menu and shared with us popular menu items. I would definitely recommend SIX Hundred Downtown to anyone looking for a place to eat in Bellefontaine.