Kittie’s Cakes

2424 E Main St, Bexley
(614) 929-5000

Recent Reviews

L

WOW I can’t believe I’ve lived here 6 months and haven’t tried this place out! I’ll DEFINITELY be coming back every weekend!All the employees were SOOO sweet and helpful! The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming. I had the quiche, spouse got a sammie and the strawberry danish— we were so impressed! And the coffee— WOW, it was so smooth! And all the syrups are made in house and it makes a difference— they’re unique in their quality.My new go to for SURE! There’s a Starbucks next door and it’s almost comical how this place blows it out of the water. The employees here really care, and you can tell.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer B

Great coffee and breakfast spot. House made syrups ( no sugar free options, just fyi) Rotating quiche and pastry options and all of it is delicious! Part of the Columbus coffee trail!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Moushumi Mookerjee

Cute little cafe....the bookstore next door is great to browse. Coffee was

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lindsey Wachtel

Great coffee and food, but hands down the rudest barista. We all have off

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

tesla pete

Loved the cheddar jalapeno biscuit with pimento cheese spread and bacon! Also the the cheese and jalapeno twist is like an amazing pretzel shaped pastry that's Devine! ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pastries, Breakfast Sandwich, Quiche

Jesse Badger

Cool space attached to a bookstore. Very good cortado.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Casey McCarty

Cute little spot attached to Gramercy Books. Minimal bake selection and some of the seasonal specials are hit or miss (like the coffee-cola concoction was not a personal fave) but staff are lovely and there's a little covered patio.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Joy Bennett

New favorite place to get coffee <3Dietary restrictions: Love that they have dairy free milk and use in-house syrups

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alexandria Maddox

My partner and I were in the area and stumbled across this beautiful cafe/bakery. And by beautiful I mean delicious. The cinnamon rolls was like a euphoric experience I had never known before. Perfectly warmed, perfectly iced and perfectly served. Paired with the coffee I felt like I had gone to heaven. That first bite - the one where it dawns how you how incredible is it - literally made me feel warm and safe and released all the feel good chemicals. They deserve every single 5 star review and I will defiantly be back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brenda A

The staff was friendly and they were able to make a custom coffee that was not on the menu. The coffee was frothy, creamy made to perfection!Definitely recommend this coffee shop.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Taylor Morris

I decided to just stop by on a whim to this cute little bakery/cafe and I’m so glad I did! The staff was friendly and helpful with suggestions. The coffee was frothy, creamy and delicious! If you’re thinking about getting the jalapeño cream cheese on your sandwich and you’re on the fence about it, just do it! The best part was while waiting for the food, there is a bookstore next door you can browse. Definitely recommend trying this place! ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich

B G

Today was my first time visiting Kittie’s. I wanted to love it! But here are my takeaways.The good: The mocha I ordered was decent!The bad: The barista was not very friendly. I was told as I entered that the coffee shop would be closing soon. She then chased after me as I took my coffee into the bookstore (despite bookstore staff having told me earlier that I could bring my coffee into the bookstore). Did she think I was going to steal the cup? Not sure what the fuss was all about. Strange. No wifi in the coffee shop, either, so don’t come thinking you can work or study while you have your coffee.Overall, I thought the coffee was slightly above average, but I will probably not return due to the chilly reception I received and the fact that you can’t work or study in the coffee shop (as there is no wifi).

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Richard McClincy

This may not be fair, but I was a little disappointed. Visited the Main St location mid-day today with a cinnamon roll on my mind as recommended be the Columbus Navigator. Main St is probably not the right place to do this as this location is really just a small coffee shop supporting Gramercy Books. I had a good cup of coffee, though.

Jacob Greber

Quiet spot- great to get some work done. Espresso and the cinnamon roll were both great!

Kevin Crawmer

Cute little corner coffee shop. I love to try a unique, privately owned shop. This one did NOT disappoint. They offer housemade syrups (which is always a MUST), and was absolutely delicious. This little place checked all the boxes- good vibe, unique, housemade syrup, serious about coffee, super friendly staff. And if books are your thing, it's attached to a book store that looks amazing as well. (Reviewed by Kevin's wife?)

Load More