I accidentally scared the hell out of the owners when I got back out of my car in the rain to tell them that they put their foot in my sandwich. They didn’t know what that meant. (Sorry bout that.) I ordered the mushroom meatloaf sandwich and I’m still eating it but I had to come on here and sing their praises. The rye bread was fresh and soft. The meatloaf was perfectly seasoned. I loved the mushrooms and the special sauce and the Swiss cheese had such good pull. Good gravy is this a frickin’ tasty sandwich!This is without a doubt THEE best sandwich I have ever had!! I can taste the love, even down to the way they folded the paper the sandwich was wrapped in. I highly encourage anyone who is looking for an expertly crafted sandwich to stop in and give this place a try. You will not regret it!When I need another one, I will be right back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatloaf Sandwich
Alex Rice
I absolutely love this place. I work right next door to it and it’s always a pleasure to go in on my break and get a sandwich and sometimes some chips and chat with the owners. They are very accommodating and always super kind. I highly recommend this place to anyone if you’re in Bexley and are looking for some place to eat. They are closed Sunday/Monday but be sure to try them out when they are open. Love you Newfangled crew❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hunter S Chicken, High Five, Lucifer's Hammer
Andrew Wyman
Some of the best deli sandwiches I’ve had. Great chicken salad and egg salad.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sharina Hairston
Yummy Yummy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatloaf Sandwich, Hunter S Chicken, High Five
Jane Belhorn
Recovering from hospital visit, a few friends offered to bring lunch today. On a whim I suggested New Fangled Kitchen. Always nervous suggesting a new place. Great response!! Reubens and meatloaf!! We will be frequent flyers from now on. Fresh, tasty and plenty. Thank you. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
STUART FRASER
Im a meatloaf fan and this is the Best meatloaf I've ever eaten. I've asked over and over for the recipe but to no avail. Nice people too. Also enjoy the chicken sandwich, hunter s chicken. Highly
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatloaf Sandwich
Kahn Demko
I can’t believe I’ve overlooked this place for so long. I got the Reuben, fried bologna sandwich, pecan salad, and a side of meatloaf and all items were excellent. Quality super fresh ingredients, very fair pricing and portions, and super fast and friendly service. Even the packaging is outstanding. I love finding privately owned neighborhood gems like this and they are rare. Thank you guys
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eli Fulton
My review of this unique little place is well overdue. I no longer live in Columbus, but when I'm in town I almost always pay a quick visit.I first heard about New Fangled Kitchen when they initially opened (2018 or 19 maybe). I was a college student at Capital University in Bexley and the shop is literally across the street from campus which made things easy.In the past there had been a couple small food businesses leasing this location but either failed or relocated for reasons unknown to me. However, I feel New Fangled is here to stay!ALL of their food is absolutely delicious! Mouth watering just thinking about it. My personal favorite is Lucifer's Hammer. The jalapenos and their famous Diablo sauce really packs-a-punch!But what truly keeps my continued loyalty with these guys are the people who run this joint. I believe it is family owned and I love supporting small local businesses because they typically never disappoint. The quality of service is unmatched. Kind, welcoming, professional people who truly care about their customers and know you by name.If you're in the area and want a quick, fulfilling bite to eat.... this is a given.(Only reason I gave the atmosphere 4-star is because they no longer have inside dining but they do have outdoor tables if the weather permits.)
I order from Newfangled Kitchen on UberEats all the time because it’s so good! I always get the Georgia Reuben and the dill potato salad, it’s a perfect lunch combo and really delicious. I love a turkey Reuben but they can be hard to find, so glad I discovered this place! I look forward to trying other menu items some day, I'm sure they’re also excellent, but every time I think I’ll try a new sandwich I just can’t turn down the Georgia Reuben again ?. My husband has gotten the High Five a few times though, he says it’s very good. Definitely would recommend this place for a great lunch!
A quaint sandwich shop located in Bexley, I've driven past on numerous occasions and finally decided to stop! I am so glad that I did, they are known for their meatloaf sandwiches but I myself am a Reuben fan.I ordered the turkey Reuben and a bag of honey Sriracha kettle chips.My order was fast and fresh and Oh so good!! And the cashier was very friendly and welcoming.I can't wait to go back to try something new . I'm sure I won't be disappointed!Vegetarian options: They have a portobello veggie sandwich.
Our favorite lunch place. Best salads and sandwiches in Columbus. When my wife has a hard day at work, she asks me to pick something up from here to make her night feel better. Beautiful food and wonderful
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zach Shaw
The only thing you can complain about is that their not open 7 days a week to enjoy! Great sandwich shop!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Barnyard Caviar, Meatloaf Sandwich, High Five
Hannah Adams
Everything is so good! My favorites there are the Chatty Cathy, The Fang (meatloaf sandwich), the SwissShroom melt, and the dill pickle salad. My favorite restaurant in Bexley for a quick bite. Definitely worth the stop if you want to try something new and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily Watson
Best meat loaf husband and I have ever had! I'm not even a big meatloaf person but there's is so juicy and full of flavor. The white bbq sauce is my favorite, love the NA drink options, and customer service is always stellar.
Stopped at this place for lunch while passing through Columbus. Definitely one of the best chicken sandwiches I've had. I will be stopping here again next time I'm in town.
I accidentally scared the hell out of the owners when I got back out of my car in the rain to tell them that they put their foot in my sandwich. They didn’t know what that meant. (Sorry bout that.) I ordered the mushroom meatloaf sandwich and I’m still eating it but I had to come on here and sing their praises. The rye bread was fresh and soft. The meatloaf was perfectly seasoned. I loved the mushrooms and the special sauce and the Swiss cheese had such good pull. Good gravy is this a frickin’ tasty sandwich!This is without a doubt THEE best sandwich I have ever had!! I can taste the love, even down to the way they folded the paper the sandwich was wrapped in. I highly encourage anyone who is looking for an expertly crafted sandwich to stop in and give this place a try. You will not regret it!When I need another one, I will be right back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatloaf Sandwich
I absolutely love this place. I work right next door to it and it’s always a pleasure to go in on my break and get a sandwich and sometimes some chips and chat with the owners. They are very accommodating and always super kind. I highly recommend this place to anyone if you’re in Bexley and are looking for some place to eat. They are closed Sunday/Monday but be sure to try them out when they are open. Love you Newfangled crew❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hunter S Chicken, High Five, Lucifer's Hammer
Some of the best deli sandwiches I’ve had. Great chicken salad and egg salad.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yummy Yummy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatloaf Sandwich, Hunter S Chicken, High Five
Recovering from hospital visit, a few friends offered to bring lunch today. On a whim I suggested New Fangled Kitchen. Always nervous suggesting a new place. Great response!! Reubens and meatloaf!! We will be frequent flyers from now on. Fresh, tasty and plenty. Thank you. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Im a meatloaf fan and this is the Best meatloaf I've ever eaten. I've asked over and over for the recipe but to no avail. Nice people too. Also enjoy the chicken sandwich, hunter s chicken. Highly
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatloaf Sandwich
I can’t believe I’ve overlooked this place for so long. I got the Reuben, fried bologna sandwich, pecan salad, and a side of meatloaf and all items were excellent. Quality super fresh ingredients, very fair pricing and portions, and super fast and friendly service. Even the packaging is outstanding. I love finding privately owned neighborhood gems like this and they are rare. Thank you guys
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My review of this unique little place is well overdue. I no longer live in Columbus, but when I'm in town I almost always pay a quick visit.I first heard about New Fangled Kitchen when they initially opened (2018 or 19 maybe). I was a college student at Capital University in Bexley and the shop is literally across the street from campus which made things easy.In the past there had been a couple small food businesses leasing this location but either failed or relocated for reasons unknown to me. However, I feel New Fangled is here to stay!ALL of their food is absolutely delicious! Mouth watering just thinking about it. My personal favorite is Lucifer's Hammer. The jalapenos and their famous Diablo sauce really packs-a-punch!But what truly keeps my continued loyalty with these guys are the people who run this joint. I believe it is family owned and I love supporting small local businesses because they typically never disappoint. The quality of service is unmatched. Kind, welcoming, professional people who truly care about their customers and know you by name.If you're in the area and want a quick, fulfilling bite to eat.... this is a given.(Only reason I gave the atmosphere 4-star is because they no longer have inside dining but they do have outdoor tables if the weather permits.)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Swissshroom Melt, Georgia Turkey Reuben Sandwich, Lucifer's Hammer
I order from Newfangled Kitchen on UberEats all the time because it’s so good! I always get the Georgia Reuben and the dill potato salad, it’s a perfect lunch combo and really delicious. I love a turkey Reuben but they can be hard to find, so glad I discovered this place! I look forward to trying other menu items some day, I'm sure they’re also excellent, but every time I think I’ll try a new sandwich I just can’t turn down the Georgia Reuben again ?. My husband has gotten the High Five a few times though, he says it’s very good. Definitely would recommend this place for a great lunch!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Dill Pickle Potato Salad, Georgia Turkey Reuben Sandwich
A quaint sandwich shop located in Bexley, I've driven past on numerous occasions and finally decided to stop! I am so glad that I did, they are known for their meatloaf sandwiches but I myself am a Reuben fan.I ordered the turkey Reuben and a bag of honey Sriracha kettle chips.My order was fast and fresh and Oh so good!! And the cashier was very friendly and welcoming.I can't wait to go back to try something new . I'm sure I won't be disappointed!Vegetarian options: They have a portobello veggie sandwich.
Restaurantji Recommends
Our favorite lunch place. Best salads and sandwiches in Columbus. When my wife has a hard day at work, she asks me to pick something up from here to make her night feel better. Beautiful food and wonderful
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The only thing you can complain about is that their not open 7 days a week to enjoy! Great sandwich shop!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Barnyard Caviar, Meatloaf Sandwich, High Five
Everything is so good! My favorites there are the Chatty Cathy, The Fang (meatloaf sandwich), the SwissShroom melt, and the dill pickle salad. My favorite restaurant in Bexley for a quick bite. Definitely worth the stop if you want to try something new and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best meat loaf husband and I have ever had! I'm not even a big meatloaf person but there's is so juicy and full of flavor. The white bbq sauce is my favorite, love the NA drink options, and customer service is always stellar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatloaf Reuben, Dill Pickle Potato Salad, Meatloaf Sandwich, Tuna Melt, The Fang, Lucifer
Stopped at this place for lunch while passing through Columbus. Definitely one of the best chicken sandwiches I've had. I will be stopping here again next time I'm in town.