Starlight Pizza & Subs

61 Main St, Bloomingburg
(740) 437-7827

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Breadsticks with Cheese

Cheesy Bacon Bread

Ham & Cheese Sub

Pepperoni Pizza

Pizza Toppings

Dessert Pizza

Italian Sub

Taco Pizza

Grand Slam

Steak Sub

Photos

+25 photos

+24 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Doordash

Square

Recent Reviews

Stopped in here while camping at Deer Creek, This place was beyond fantastic the thing I always notice first is service and when you walk in you are met with friendly faces and smiles! The pizza is probably at the top of my list! We got a large pepperoni, medium pepperoni and sausage, cheesey bread all absolutely delicious. This place deserves nothing but ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ stars service and food is top notch! Will be back on our next trip!

July 2025

First I am writing this because I want to and this is what personally correlates with my experiences. I have been going to Starlite/getting food from here for many years, and I honestly cannot recall ever having a bad experience with them. Tonight we got a Taco Pizza for the first time and it did not disappoint! Was awesome and loaded with cheese! Their food is always good! I Like to give credit where credit is due and they absolutely deserve it! Another wonderful experience here!...

June 2025

Hello
Me and my family went to Deer Creek this weekend for a few days and our normal pizza place was closed for the holiday .I looked up a pizza place near us and found a place called Star Light Pizza . Placed an online order and picked it up . People were super nice . Get back to campground and apparently when I scrolled down to pay I must have added mushrooms to the pizzas and all the kids hated mushrooms . Call Starlight and placed another order and explained why...

June 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Bloomingburg, OH

Starlight Pizza & Subs

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Starlight Pizza & Subs