Butter Maid Bakery

Purchased the lemon kolachi online for my daughter- she loved it! I agree, I previously ordered the prune & have been enjoying immensely!

Items shipped quick, and communication was good. The problem I had was there was a pebble in a cookie which caused a crack in my tooth, followed by expensive dentist visits.

It’s a shame because the flavors were spot on like my grandmothers who was from Poland.
I don’t plan on purchasing from here due to the foreign objects that could be in the food. (See pick below)

The kolachi are good but not worth $34 for 16 kolachi...

This place has the absolute best walnut roll I've ever had! Delivery was quick and easy both times I ordered. Definitely worth a try!! I'll be placing my 3rd order very soon. Caution:: you can't stop eating it, once you start❤️

Im so tired of the surveys!

The cookies are sooooooo good and fresh

Butter Maid Bakery makes the best Nut Rolls I've tasted in my 73 years of life. I order from them a few times a year. I always know they'll be fresh and delicious.

get a new company to deliver your product, the one you are now and have been using are idiots, they don't know the difference between a covered protected porch and a garage entrence that is not protected from the elements. the last delivery i got the moron left it in a puddle, well the puddle occured after he /she left because it was left in an unprotected area where it was left again yesterday or today because the moron could have rung the door bell if they climbed the steps, you hire idiots hope it doesn't reflect on your product!

Apricot and Walnut were excellent. Tender, moist and tasty.

I buy the long nut, apricot,& cheese rolls. They are so good. Very convient way of having a delicious dessert for the holidays or whenever the need. Highly recommend Butter Maid Bakery. Can't go wrong. Excellent service.

Kolachi are absolutely terrific. A bit expensive, but worth every penny.

Best poppy seed cake, Ive ever had. Moist, filled with poppy seed filling. Outside, buttery, sweet, soft and just the right texture. Worth every penny, including 2 day shipping. Kolacki's good too
Plenty of filling, good texture.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bakery in Youngstown Ohio. Wonderful European bakery goods. My personal favourite is the Italian Rainbow Cakes. I purchased these for me and the rum balls for my husband. We're also going to cut the blueberry jam Kolachi in half, leaving in the original sealed wrapping and rewrap half for the freezer. We like a slice in the nuker to warm and some extra butter. You can't go wrong with the Poppy seed Kolachi.

Food: 5

Service: 5

We ordered for the first time this Christmas and couldn’t be happier with the baked goods. Even more so, the level of customer service is above and beyond any rating scale. For example , I clicked the wrong item and didn’t notice it until after I placed my order. I contacted them and they quickly fixed the issue. Plus, they went ahead and kept the other item I accidentally ordered in the shipment! What a great unexpected holiday surprise. Special shoutout to Jess on the Care Team!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I have ordered the nut rolls a few times now. Every time they are fresh and absolutely delicious. I would recommend them to all my friends and family!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Original Nut Kolachi Roll