Pagliai’s is a gem in Bowling Green. I stop by whenever I’m in town, sometimes just to relive a fond memory. The food was steaming hot, the drink frosted like a scene from a commercial, and everything tasted amazing. The atmosphere is cozy, the service is warm, and I enjoy every visit. Highly recommend.
Kathleen F
Fresh pizzas, awesome salad bar, and fresh tea. Ordered the buffet and it did not disappoint. Pick a pizza and they'll make it - and give you first dibs when it comes out. Soup and breadsticks are available too. Great music, and a wonderful waitress made it a fantastic dining experience 👌
Kim Steele
Great pizza smorgasbord, with the price and drive from Toledo.
Jonathan Ziebold
Good food, decent prices. The upholstery on their booth seating is falling apart.
Gary Dahmer
Great pizza and great salad bar.. had a local craft soda that was like Dr pepper but better
Anna banana
Buffet just mid if that. Ran out of cinnamon bread which was probably the best thing there.
Rob S.
They have a well-known crust for Bowling Green, which is better than the traditional pizza places. It really is more of a pizzeria than another pizza joint.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dalton Diels
Sat down for 20 minutes and never had anyone come to our table.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Gooeyyy
I went here for the first time over the week and I will definitely be eating here again. The buffet isn't huge, however they always have fresh and different pizzas coming out. Our server even asked us if we'd like a special request and when we did, she brought some out to us before putting it at the pizza bar. Really cool place for family style pizza and awesome service
Recommended dishes: Pizza Buffet, Salad Bar, Pizza Bar
J Angel
Very good!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tyler
Went in to try it for the first time and we decided to get the buffet. I seen the owner doing an interview on the new and he said "I know I don't have the best pizza..." He's either being humble or selling himself short, because every pizza we tried was excellent. Great quality ingredients, nice crust that wasn't hard, and a nice selection. It's one of the best pizza's in the area by far. I'll drive the 30+ minutes again to get it. I personally would put it on par with Pizza Pub, which is a top 5 favorite of mine. I never had a roast beef pizza, and didn't expect much, but the roast beef actually had great flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Buffet, Pizza Bar
Jonathon Legath
This place was amazing. I dined in for the buffet. The staff, specifically the waitress did a fantastic job by keeping up with whatever I needed and also suggesting pizza’s to try since you could order custom ones outside what they had. The buffet, salad bar, soup, and all other items was rotated so everything was fresh. Highly recommended this place!
Pagliai’s is a gem in Bowling Green. I stop by whenever I’m in town, sometimes just to relive a fond memory. The food was steaming hot, the drink frosted like a scene from a commercial, and everything tasted amazing. The atmosphere is cozy, the service is warm, and I enjoy every visit. Highly recommend.
Fresh pizzas, awesome salad bar, and fresh tea. Ordered the buffet and it did not disappoint. Pick a pizza and they'll make it - and give you first dibs when it comes out. Soup and breadsticks are available too. Great music, and a wonderful waitress made it a fantastic dining experience 👌
Great pizza smorgasbord, with the price and drive from Toledo.
Good food, decent prices. The upholstery on their booth seating is falling apart.
Great pizza and great salad bar.. had a local craft soda that was like Dr pepper but better
Buffet just mid if that. Ran out of cinnamon bread which was probably the best thing there.
They have a well-known crust for Bowling Green, which is better than the traditional pizza places. It really is more of a pizzeria than another pizza joint.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sat down for 20 minutes and never had anyone come to our table.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
I went here for the first time over the week and I will definitely be eating here again. The buffet isn't huge, however they always have fresh and different pizzas coming out. Our server even asked us if we'd like a special request and when we did, she brought some out to us before putting it at the pizza bar. Really cool place for family style pizza and awesome service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chipped a tooth, deserved more pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pizza Buffet
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely one of the best Pizza places around!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always a favorite
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Buffet, Salad Bar, Pizza Bar
Very good!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went in to try it for the first time and we decided to get the buffet.
I seen the owner doing an interview on the new and he said "I know I don't have the best pizza..."
He's either being humble or selling himself short, because every pizza we tried was excellent. Great quality ingredients, nice crust that wasn't hard, and a nice selection. It's one of the best pizza's in the area by far. I'll drive the 30+ minutes again to get it.
I personally would put it on par with Pizza Pub, which is a top 5 favorite of mine.
I never had a roast beef pizza, and didn't expect much, but the roast beef actually had great flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Buffet, Pizza Bar
This place was amazing. I dined in for the buffet. The staff, specifically the waitress did a fantastic job by keeping up with whatever I needed and also suggesting pizza’s to try since you could order custom ones outside what they had. The buffet, salad bar, soup, and all other items was rotated so everything was fresh. Highly recommended this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Buffet, Salad Bar
Loading...