Okay, so we’re new to the area, and we decided on pizza tonight. Well we have been missing our favorite pizza place in Fl so I was looking and comparing reviews/menu items/price, all that and we chose little sicilys bc of the GREAT reviews commenting on taste, and quality and everything. Well needless to say we were utterly shocked, by how much we truly disliked this simple cheese pizza…… (we always order only cheese pizzas) not only was it not appealing to the eye, it tasted even worse. Not sure if all of the good reviews are employees and friends of the business or if people genuinely think that this is a fantastic pizza place I really hope we don’t order from here again accidentally because we were completely and truly let down and honestly never want to taste of that again. I don’t have much to say on service or the atmosphere since my husband went and Picked up the Pizza.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Clifton Sparrow Jr
Small...but quaint! Food is good. Great customer service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
msgobinna
One of the best hidden gems in the City! Top 10 best pep pizza I have ever. Owner greeted me and was very welcoming. He helped me through the menu and everything is good there. it’s worth it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Works Pizza
Judy Hill-Gehring
Best baked hot Italian sub I've ever had .....miss this so much!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sub
Cameron Troilo
Nostalgic as it gets. I began going there when I was 5. My dad worked there when he was a teenager. I moved to Alabama in 2004, every time I come to Columbus for work or to visit I make Little Sicily’s my must stop. Now I even have my out of town friends and co-workers hooked.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salads, Large Pepperoni Pizza, Sub
Donn Nunn
Been going there for 38+ years always Fabulous food. Best Sausage pizza ever and their subs are phenomenal. I cannot ever recall a bad experience. Here's a good memory. Back in the late 80's. I worked at JCPenney's and they would ask if would like to get overtime on Saturdays. The only reason I volunteered to do it was They ordered Little Sicily's for everybody. Also, it would jack my 50 hr take home pay up to 115.00 bucks. Those were the good ole days ??.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Potato Skins, Salads, Deep Fried Pepperoni, Large Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Tenders, Garlic Bread, Spaghetti Dinner, Thin Crust Pizza, Pizza Shop, Antipasto Salad, Little Sicily's Pizza, Supreme Pizza, The Works Pizza, Antipasto, Sub, Meatball Sub, Pepperoni Large Pizza, Joe's Special Pizza, Large the Works
Heather
Very good every time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ivelisse Cupid
Different cultures work and eat there, they seem to also have several generations working and eating there i just recently started coming here but i can tell they have been around a while and will be around for a long time. Great pizza! Decent prices.
Parking: Theres a lot of in-n-out customers for pick-up or to go orders so the parking lot gets congetested but clears out quickly. Oh! And some of the spots are awkwardly positioned but it works.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Large Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza Shop, Little Sicily's Pizza, Pepperoni Large Pizza
Robert Gravely
I have enjoyed this place for years! I also have family members from another state request eating here on every visit and when they leave to go back home they order pizza just to take back home to share! I appreciate the first name basic and the conversation with employees! Great place to get a wonderful experience!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Potato Skins, Large Pepperoni Pizza, Little Sicily's Pizza, The Works Pizza
Patrick Rockey
Saw your add on FB. Viewed the photos and promised myself we would try it. The pizza, salad and waitress all were excellent.
The supreme pizza was delicious. We’ll definitely return. I highly recommend if you like great pizzas.
9/25/2024 Made a return visit and brought a party of 5 of us. My brothers and SIL ordered two of the Large Supreme pizzas. Everyone of us were again impressed. We had enough for dinner that evening. Well worth the 40 minute drive from Newark
Good columbus style pizza, the boss had huge nuts telling me I'm going to have a hard time ordering if I want my pie cut in slices. Just slice me up buddy. 7.9
Roben Phillips
One of the best pizzas in and around Columbus. Generous toppings, great pepperoni, sausage, cheese and sauce. I live around Grove City and gladly make the drive to Brice for this pizza. Wish they would expand to the old Zamarelli’s Pizza and the west side would have a new favorite.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just Me
One of my fave pizza joints. This place always smells delicious! If you like Reuben sandwiches, try thir Ziggys pizza. Italian sausage with saurkraut. Soooo good!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sandy Altizer
Never disappointed in Little Sicily's! Only 1 location but Joe and crew does it up right!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Potato Skins, Salads, Deep Fried Pepperoni, Large Pepperoni Pizza, Spaghetti Dinner, Thin Crust Pizza, Antipasto Salad, The Works Pizza, Sub, Meatball Sub, Pepperoni Large Pizza, Large the Works
Ricky
Love this little Mom & Pop pizza shop. The staff was great. Friendly, prompt, and on top of everything. The pizza... It's just fantastic. Everything about it. The crust, the sauce, cheese, and toppings. Just spot on. Crispy crust, flavor was delicious. Love everything about it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Pepperoni Pizza, Little Sicily's Pizza
Okay, so we’re new to the area, and we decided on pizza tonight. Well we have been missing our favorite pizza place in Fl so I was looking and comparing reviews/menu items/price, all that and we chose little sicilys bc of the GREAT reviews commenting on taste, and quality and everything. Well needless to say we were utterly shocked, by how much we truly disliked this simple cheese pizza…… (we always order only cheese pizzas) not only was it not appealing to the eye, it tasted even worse. Not sure if all of the good reviews are employees and friends of the business or if people genuinely think that this is a fantastic pizza place I really hope we don’t order from here again accidentally because we were completely and truly let down and honestly never want to taste of that again. I don’t have much to say on service or the atmosphere since my husband went and Picked up the Pizza.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Small...but quaint! Food is good. Great customer service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best hidden gems in the City! Top 10 best pep pizza I have ever. Owner greeted me and was very welcoming. He helped me through the menu and everything is good there. it’s worth it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Works Pizza
Best baked hot Italian sub I've ever had .....miss this so much!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sub
Nostalgic as it gets. I began going there when I was 5. My dad worked there when he was a teenager. I moved to Alabama in 2004, every time I come to Columbus for work or to visit I make Little Sicily’s my must stop. Now I even have my out of town friends and co-workers hooked.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salads, Large Pepperoni Pizza, Sub
Been going there for 38+ years always Fabulous food. Best Sausage pizza ever and their subs are phenomenal. I cannot ever recall a bad experience. Here's a good memory. Back in the late 80's. I worked at JCPenney's and they would ask if would like to get overtime on Saturdays. The only reason I volunteered to do it was They ordered Little Sicily's for everybody. Also, it would jack my 50 hr take home pay up to 115.00 bucks. Those were the good ole days ??.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Potato Skins, Salads, Deep Fried Pepperoni, Large Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Tenders, Garlic Bread, Spaghetti Dinner, Thin Crust Pizza, Pizza Shop, Antipasto Salad, Little Sicily's Pizza, Supreme Pizza, The Works Pizza, Antipasto, Sub, Meatball Sub, Pepperoni Large Pizza, Joe's Special Pizza, Large the Works
Very good every time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Different cultures work and eat there, they seem to also have several generations working and eating there i just recently started coming here but i can tell they have been around a while and will be around for a long time. Great pizza! Decent prices.
Parking: Theres a lot of in-n-out customers for pick-up or to go orders so the parking lot gets congetested but clears out quickly. Oh! And some of the spots are awkwardly positioned but it works.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Large Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza Shop, Little Sicily's Pizza, Pepperoni Large Pizza
I have enjoyed this place for years! I also have family members from another state request eating here on every visit and when they leave to go back home they order pizza just to take back home to share! I appreciate the first name basic and the conversation with employees! Great place to get a wonderful experience!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Potato Skins, Large Pepperoni Pizza, Little Sicily's Pizza, The Works Pizza
Saw your add on FB. Viewed the photos and promised myself we would try it. The pizza, salad and waitress all were excellent.
The supreme pizza was delicious. We’ll definitely return. I highly recommend if you like great pizzas.
9/25/2024
Made a return visit and brought a party of 5 of us. My brothers and SIL ordered two of the Large Supreme pizzas. Everyone of us were again impressed. We had enough for dinner that evening. Well worth the 40 minute drive from Newark
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salads, Supreme Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Good columbus style pizza, the boss had huge nuts telling me I'm going to have a hard time ordering if I want my pie cut in slices. Just slice me up buddy.
7.9
One of the best pizzas in and around Columbus. Generous toppings, great pepperoni, sausage, cheese and sauce. I live around Grove City and gladly make the drive to Brice for this pizza. Wish they would expand to the old Zamarelli’s Pizza and the west side would have a new favorite.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of my fave pizza joints. This place always smells delicious! If you like Reuben sandwiches, try thir Ziggys pizza. Italian sausage with saurkraut. Soooo good!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Never disappointed in Little Sicily's!
Only 1 location but Joe and crew does it up right!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Potato Skins, Salads, Deep Fried Pepperoni, Large Pepperoni Pizza, Spaghetti Dinner, Thin Crust Pizza, Antipasto Salad, The Works Pizza, Sub, Meatball Sub, Pepperoni Large Pizza, Large the Works
Love this little Mom & Pop pizza shop. The staff was great. Friendly, prompt, and on top of everything. The pizza... It's just fantastic. Everything about it. The crust, the sauce, cheese, and toppings. Just spot on. Crispy crust, flavor was delicious. Love everything about it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Pepperoni Pizza, Little Sicily's Pizza
Loading...