They have wonderful pizza we order one and had it delivered.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Bare
Had a delivery. The young lady took my info and order put the wrong room number on order. I corrected her and she still messed it up. Luckily I just happen to open door delivery guy was just getting ready to knock on the door across the hall
Food: 5
Service: 5
Deana Ore
I’ve dined in and had them deliver. You can always count on a great experience. We have stayed at the KOA and order from them every time we stay! Highly suggest the chicken bacon ranch pizza, and the subs are awesome too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elizabeth Owen
This was my go to place for a decade when I lived in Brookville; I cannot even guess how many meals came from here! I went last week as my cousin was in town and Sarah’s is nostalgic for us as we always had it as kids. Even though I hadn’t ordered in a few years everything was exactly how I remembered! Staff answering the phone was polite and courteous and no items were out of stock! We picked up our order and the owner himself is still in there working hard everyday! Anytime I come to the area to visit family I try to make one of our meals from here and the product they deliver is consistently the same for the last 20 years I’ve ordered! Forever my favorite local place for pizza and I will continue to order from here anytime I come north to visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Frederick S. Cairo II
This is definitely the best pizza in Brookville. The staff is very friendly, and the food is amazing. I highly recommend this restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
dr johnson3253
West Alexandria Sarah’s is much better, doesn’t seem they use the same ingredients, they even asked which one we normally eat at so they can define the differences.
Henry Morgan
Updated menu prices
Zack Shaffner
Our latest mission in Brookville, OH, has led to a critical discovery: Sarah’s Pizza, a 25-year cornerstone of the local community. To test their mettle, we ordered their XL 18-inch all-meat pizza—a bold choice, but one that paid off spectacularly. This was no ordinary pie. It was a starship of flavor, loaded with toppings in quantities that could sustain a small crew. No rations were spared.
The 18-inch XL is a marvel, easily large enough to feed several adults, with leftovers that promise to extend the mission into tomorrow. Each slice was a tactical masterpiece, and their commitment to quality is nothing short of commendable.
Sarah’s Pizza has officially been added to our list of essential local resources, ensuring future expeditions will always be well-fueled. For those stationed in the area, this is a prime recommendation. Resistance is futile.
shaina Quillen
Honestly I've given this place multiple chances and they've always been a let down. I hate to say that but after giving them more than enough chances it was just a loss of money and time .Food is either burnt or not fully cooked. Basically it's either or. If you get delivery don't expect to get all of your order . If you call to explain you didn't receive all of your order don't expect them to send it back out or remember to write it down just in case you do decide to order from there again . By far the worst sarahs pizza out of the chain . Dont waste your hard earned money on this place. Thank God for word of mouth because I would've never ate sarahs again. If you do want to try sarahs I suggest Lewisburg location 10 to 15 mins away and the food quality is 5 stars its better and so is the staff.
Very cool local pizza shop with a retro feel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
They have wonderful pizza we order one and had it delivered.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a delivery. The young lady took my info and order put the wrong room number on order. I corrected her and she still messed it up. Luckily I just happen to open door delivery guy was just getting ready to knock on the door across the hall
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve dined in and had them deliver. You can always count on a great experience. We have stayed at the KOA and order from them every time we stay! Highly suggest the chicken bacon ranch pizza, and the subs are awesome too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was my go to place for a decade when I lived in Brookville; I cannot even guess how many meals came from here! I went last week as my cousin was in town and Sarah’s is nostalgic for us as we always had it as kids. Even though I hadn’t ordered in a few years everything was exactly how I remembered! Staff answering the phone was polite and courteous and no items were out of stock! We picked up our order and the owner himself is still in there working hard everyday! Anytime I come to the area to visit family I try to make one of our meals from here and the product they deliver is consistently the same for the last 20 years I’ve ordered! Forever my favorite local place for pizza and I will continue to order from here anytime I come north to visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is definitely the best pizza in Brookville. The staff is very friendly, and the food is amazing. I highly recommend this restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
West Alexandria Sarah’s is much better, doesn’t seem they use the same ingredients, they even asked which one we normally eat at so they can define the differences.
Updated menu prices
Our latest mission in Brookville, OH, has led to a critical discovery: Sarah’s Pizza, a 25-year cornerstone of the local community. To test their mettle, we ordered their XL 18-inch all-meat pizza—a bold choice, but one that paid off spectacularly. This was no ordinary pie. It was a starship of flavor, loaded with toppings in quantities that could sustain a small crew. No rations were spared.
The 18-inch XL is a marvel, easily large enough to feed several adults, with leftovers that promise to extend the mission into tomorrow. Each slice was a tactical masterpiece, and their commitment to quality is nothing short of commendable.
Sarah’s Pizza has officially been added to our list of essential local resources, ensuring future expeditions will always be well-fueled. For those stationed in the area, this is a prime recommendation. Resistance is futile.
Honestly I've given this place multiple chances and they've always been a let down. I hate to say that but after giving them more than enough chances it was just a loss of money and time .Food is either burnt or not fully cooked. Basically it's either or. If you get delivery don't expect to get all of your order . If you call to explain you didn't receive all of your order don't expect them to send it back out or remember to write it down just in case you do decide to order from there again . By far the worst sarahs pizza out of the chain . Dont waste your hard earned money on this place. Thank God for word of mouth because I would've never ate sarahs again. If you do want to try sarahs I suggest Lewisburg location 10 to 15 mins away and the food quality is 5 stars its better and so is the staff.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was excellent! Will be back
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good Food, Good Prices, Good Location, Good Hours, Good Diner, Good Delivery, No Alcohol.
Good Food, Good Prices, Good Location, Good Hours, Good Diner, Good Delivery, No Alcohol.
Great place in town to vibe and enjoy great food at a great price
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great local pizza ?
Loading...