Sarah's Pizza

224 Market St, Brookville
(937) 833-6030

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Spicy Chicken Ranch Pizza
Mashed Potato Pizza
Original Submarine
Pizza Spaghetti
Supreme Pizza

Menu

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: nextdoor
Photo credit: nextdoor
+20 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+19 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

Our latest mission in Brookville, OH, has led to a critical discovery: Sarah’s Pizza, a 25-year cornerstone of the local community. To test their mettle, we ordered their XL 18-inch all-meat pizza—a bold choice, but one that paid off spectacularly. This was no ordinary pie. It was a starship of flavor, loaded with toppings in quantities that could sustain a small crew. No rations were spared.

The 18-inch XL is a marvel, easily large enough to feed several...
November 2024
I went to Sarah's Pizza in Brookville a couple of weeks ago. Ordered a mini mashed potato pizza, (no bacon), plain cheese pizza, and potato wedges.I didn't love the red sauce on the cheese pizza. It was really bland. But I added some salt to the top, and that seemed to spruce things up quite a bit. The mashed potato pizza was delicious! They don't use green onions, but rather use white onions, which gives the pizza so much more taste! The potato wedges were also...
May 2024
We got delivery, said 45mins, here in 30.10 gar/Parm wings and 3 subs...(1 steak), Terrific!Everything was hot, fresh, and however it happened, those Subs were Huge!Thank You Sarah's Pizza for a Great 'rest of' our Sunday.Hey folks, don't just post your bad experiences, cuz the good WAY outweigh the bad...Give Credit where credit is due,Sarah's is Brookvilles Best.
October 2023

More Reviews

You May Also Like

What’s The Scoop? - 230 Market St
Ice Cream Shop
Tik Takos - 209 Market St
Mexican, Tacos
Mar-Chele Pretzels Inc - 18 Market St
Pretzel Store

Sarah's Pizza

224 Market St, Brookville, OH 45309
(937) 833-6030