Sarah's Pizza
224 Market St, Brookville
(937) 833-6030
Customers' Favorites
Spicy Chicken Ranch Pizza
Mashed Potato Pizza
Original Submarine
Pizza Spaghetti
Supreme Pizza
Menu
Photos
+20 photos
+19 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I’ve dined in and had them deliver. You can always count on a great experience. We have stayed at the KOA and order from them every time we stay! Highly suggest the chicken bacon ranch pizza, and the subs are awesome too.
This was my go to place for a decade when I lived in Brookville; I cannot even guess how many meals came from here! I went last week as my cousin was in town and Sarah’s is nostalgic for us as we always had it as kids. Even though I hadn’t ordered in a few years everything was exactly how I remembered! Staff answering the phone was polite and courteous and no items were out of stock! We picked up our order and the owner himself is still in there working hard everyday! Anytime...
Our latest mission in Brookville, OH, has led to a critical discovery: Sarah’s Pizza, a 25-year cornerstone of the local community. To test their mettle, we ordered their XL 18-inch all-meat pizza—a bold choice, but one that paid off spectacularly. This was no ordinary pie. It was a starship of flavor, loaded with toppings in quantities that could sustain a small crew. No rations were spared.
The 18-inch XL is a marvel, easily large enough to feed several...
The 18-inch XL is a marvel, easily large enough to feed several...
You May Also Like
What’s The Scoop? - 230 Market St
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream
Tik Takos - 209 Market St
![]()
Mexican, Tacos
Mar-Chele Pretzels Inc - 18 Market St
![]()
Pretzel Store