Creno's Pizza, llc

419 Main St, Caldwell
(740) 305-5292

Recent Reviews

Brussels Penka

Good pizza and fine atmosphere, beer was cold, be we dined in our room‼️Ordered pie to go‼️

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lisa Spears

First time order. I don't know your name, but you know who you are. Told us to get buffalo chips with cheese and bacon. She was right! Excellent! Pizza was a huge hit. Had it delivered. The delivery guy was super friendly. And it was HOT! In town for the weekend. Can't wait until tomorrow night.

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Downs (Jack)

Pretty good pizza. No atmisphere to speak of. Reasonable pruce. Friendly.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ted Davis

Great crew and great food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robert D

Vegetarian options: You can order what you want, they, will accommodateDietary restrictions: You can order what you want, they, will accommodate within reasonWheelchair accessibility: Call and they will bring it out to you

Recommended dishes: Supreme Pizza

Mariah Lynn

good food, great staff

Lacey Boyer

Always amazing pizza! And the customer service is wonderful, very helpful and friendly! And definitely patient with questions being asked!

Brenda Davis

The same young lady waits on me every time. She is always so friendly!!! She’s always busting her butt!!! She goes above and beyond!!!! The pizza is always perfect!!!!

Travis Carpenter

They have pretty good pizza

Joanie Gildow

Gut rot!! For the price it had hardly any cheese or pepperoni. Paid for extra cheese. It was sauce on bread.

Kelly Lawson

Good food employees are always friendly.

Michael Drum

Love this pizza

Denise Fetherolf

Love their Italian subs! Best in town.

Ashley Criner

Best food i have had from a pizza place in awhile ..

Sarah Wilson

Great food. Kind of pricey. But delicious!I'm only giving 4 stars due to the fact I've found something on the menu that in my opinion shouldn't be. They serve Stromboli, I've ordered them multiple times and every single time the dough is raw, uncooked in places. I would not recommend them. Everything else, calzones included has been great.

Load More