Plus 1 Pizza

26 Olive St, Caldwell
(740) 732-1555

Recent Reviews

Anna Murphy

We had ordered pizzas for delivery lastnight and although they were delicious, we received the wrong order. The store manager call me personally to apologize and gave us a store credit for the inconvenience!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Vernon Yontz

Food is always good for the most part but the waiting time and the delivery are waaaay too

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Stromboli, Old World Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza, Cheesy Bread

Daniel Flores

Best pizza and ranch in Caldwell from an out of towner, I’ve tried them all over the last week. They cut my pizza how I wanted it too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Andrea Wood

I waited 2 hours and 10 minutes for me food. It was ice cold when I got

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Kevin Walters

Best pizza in town

Melissa Kincaid

Awesome pizza and service

Passport50359944111

It was delivered.Im an out of Towner for work details but it was great service and the pizza was some of the best I had.And it turned out the delivery driver was born and raised in Ravenna like myself.I hope to see a plus 1 pizza near me in garretville Ohio some day

Brandi

Always fresh. Taste is amazing ? sometimes forget about ya. LolOverall good food .

Kate Cramblett

Great pizza ?the best around

Jared Schroeder

Pizza was great, but am employee must be smoking? The pizza wreaked of cigarette smoke. The drive home was like I was in the car with a smoker.

Alice Greene

I am from out of state, I usually only have dominos haha but I wanted to try something different. This is what I chose. I got the New Yorker, it was delicious. Definitely fresh. The crust is different from back home which was cool. The boneless wings tasted way better than they look so don’t let that fool you. Seems like good quality and the Buffalo sauce has a nice kick to it. I have no appreciation for weak Buffalo sauce. The brownie was warm fudgy and gooey but still with a little crunch along the edges. I have no complaints. Nobody asked me but it’s easier to enjoy things when you look on the bright side.

Michelle Nicoletti

Out of towners trying the local pizza place and the pizza was fantastic!!!! We were only in town for 4 days but debated on ordering it again it was so good! The cheesy bread was the best I've ever had!

Meg Moore

Was good! Love that they have several different cheeses. Wouldn't get the smoked Gouda on it again but it was well made and tasty

michelle pitsinger

Out of towners trying the local pizza place and the pizza was fantastic!!!! We were only in town for 4 days but debated on ordering it again it was so good! The cheesy bread was the best I've ever had!

Angela Buckey

In my opinion this is the best pizza place in town. The people are always polite, they've never messed up my order (probably the only place in town that hasn't), and I'm never waiting too long for my food.

Load More