Give you exactly what you ask for! Great pizza, cheese rolls, great people!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stacy
They unfortunately stop taking orders and answering the phone at 8, I wish they'd change their hours. Food is delicious though
Food: 5
Service: 2
Davonda Pinkston
Close to closing time they never answer the phone and always hanging up on me when I try to order terrible customer service. It was 8:10pm they close at 9pm
Service: 1
kaitlyn randall
Nicky’s is always a go to for pizza close by !
Lynnette Howell
Family business good pizza and strombolis
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Thomas Harrington
It's my favorite pizza! They remember my wife after her surgery and asked about her. I drive 15 minutes to get to Nicky's, well worth the drive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza and Hot Pepperd
Clarissa Locca
Best pizza in Youngstown
Food: 5
Service: 5
Theresa
Have been going to Nicky's for over 30 years now! Best Pizza, owners, workers, etc.! My sons come to visit from out of state now and when they do we always order Nicky's because it's the BEST!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
H2Maniac
Hours must be wrong. Tried to order sunday at 630 and they were closed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
joel stephens
I visited Niki Pizzeria in Lexington hoping for the same great experience I had at their Five Points location. Unfortunately, this visit was a major disappointment. I ordered an Italian combo with no lettuce or tomato. My son ordered a ham, provolone, and bacon sub, and I also ordered another of the same sub to go.
When the food came out, I bit into my sub and realized it was actually the to-go order, not the one meant for dine-in. I notified our server, and a manager came over, but neither of them could seem to figure out what I had ordered—even though I explained it clearly. During this back-and-forth, I saw the manager standing behind me making a face as if I were crazy—rolling their eyes and giving a look that could only be described as “go to hell.” It was insulting and completely unprofessional.
Eventually, they brought out my corrected order—except it was still wrong. The sandwich had both lettuce and tomato, despite my clear request to leave those off. On top of that, they only brought half of the ham, provolone, and bacon sub. I waited another ten minutes before the correct version finally arrived.
Given the poor service, unprofessional attitude from management, and the small portions for the price, I won’t be returning. This was a frustrating and disappointing experience from start to finish.
Give you exactly what you ask for! Great pizza, cheese rolls, great people!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They unfortunately stop taking orders and answering the phone at 8, I wish they'd change their hours. Food is delicious though
Food: 5
Service: 2
Close to closing time they never answer the phone and always hanging up on me when I try to order terrible customer service. It was 8:10pm they close at 9pm
Service: 1
Nicky’s is always a go to for pizza close by !
Family business good pizza and strombolis
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
It's my favorite pizza! They remember my wife after her surgery and asked about her. I drive 15 minutes to get to Nicky's, well worth the drive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza and Hot Pepperd
Best pizza in Youngstown
Food: 5
Service: 5
Have been going to Nicky's for over 30 years now! Best Pizza, owners, workers, etc.! My sons come to visit from out of state now and when they do we always order Nicky's because it's the BEST!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hours must be wrong. Tried to order sunday at 630 and they were closed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
I visited Niki Pizzeria in Lexington hoping for the same great experience I had at their Five Points location. Unfortunately, this visit was a major disappointment. I ordered an Italian combo with no lettuce or tomato. My son ordered a ham, provolone, and bacon sub, and I also ordered another of the same sub to go.
When the food came out, I bit into my sub and realized it was actually the to-go order, not the one meant for dine-in. I notified our server, and a manager came over, but neither of them could seem to figure out what I had ordered—even though I explained it clearly. During this back-and-forth, I saw the manager standing behind me making a face as if I were crazy—rolling their eyes and giving a look that could only be described as “go to hell.” It was insulting and completely unprofessional.
Eventually, they brought out my corrected order—except it was still wrong. The sandwich had both lettuce and tomato, despite my clear request to leave those off. On top of that, they only brought half of the ham, provolone, and bacon sub. I waited another ten minutes before the correct version finally arrived.
Given the poor service, unprofessional attitude from management, and the small portions for the price, I won’t be returning. This was a frustrating and disappointing experience from start to finish.
Restaurantji Recommends
The best pizza around and the friendliest employee. Always remember you and talk to you like you are their friends.
This is a perfect pizza!! The sauce and dough are amazing with liberal amount of toppings, the staff was so friendly! We will be back for more!
Staff is very friendly and pizza is delicious! Definitely recommend!
Everyone loved the 3 different pizzas!
The best pizza in Youngstown! My go to when family and friends are coming over.
Loading...