Nicky's Pizzeria
1916 McCartney Rd, Youngstown
(330) 747-0381
Customers' Favorites
Pizza with Pepperoni and Mushrooms Extra Cheese Pizza
Large Sausage and Mushroom Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza and Hot Pepperd
Pizza with Sausage and Peppers
Spicy Ranch Wings
Pizza and Wings
Veggie
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Have been going to Nicky's for over 30 years now! Best Pizza, owners, workers, etc.! My sons come to visit from out of state now and when they do we always order Nicky's because it's the BEST!
Great pizza! Always piping hot on delivery and delicious. I have never had bad service. Last time I called for delivery I was surprised as to how I felt like I was royalty for just placing my order! Nicky’s literally delivers service with a smile! Thank you! ❤️?
Vegetarian options: I am vegetarian so I order any non meat topping. My favorite is extra sauce with extra cheese, banana peppers, black olives and mushrooms! ? ?
Vegetarian options: I am vegetarian so I order any non meat topping. My favorite is extra sauce with extra cheese, banana peppers, black olives and mushrooms! ? ?
The best pizza in Youngstown. Maybe the best in Ohio. This is the real deal, old school Italian-American owned pizzeria that’s been here since the 1970’s in the heart of the East Side of Youngstown. Better than any of that stuff in boardman.
You May Also Like
HeckYA! - 1680 McCartney Rd
![]()
Fast Food, Hot Dogs, Comfort Food
Papa’s Bakery Cafe - 196 McCartney Rd
![]()
Bakery, Cafe, Home Health Care