We paid $25 for a lrg 1 topping pizza that was all crust & tomato paste - no flavor & hardly any pepperoni or cheese. It was another $25 for 8 of the tiniest pieces of chicken I've ever seen & the skinniest jojos and $3 for coleslaw which was cabbage & mayo only
- no taste! So disappointing - Lindsey's used to be so good until Jon sold it - never again.
Food: 2
Michael R
So the pizza is pretty good. Square cut. Little bit of flop. Good toppings. However. I’d like the crust to be done a little more and it’s a little on the pricy side. Large will run you about $25ish.
wally brown
Great hot pizza and the staff is very nice.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Susan Carlisle
Lindsey’s you need to update menu prices. On line says a small Bianca pizza was $7.50. I Picked up and it was $20.50. Are you kidding me, $20.50 for a small pizza. A small pepperoni and mushroom was $17.50. I know prices have increased but that’s ridiculous.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Eric Layne
Accidentally on the website ordered GF egg pizza instead of large my bad. It still tasted great anything we typically order from here is good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Myers
The girl at the counter walked by me 3 times I had to say something to get my order
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Rose Jones
We were looking for a great new place for pizza. We had pizza, pasta and meatballs for the first time on Sunday. The pizza was delicious, and we will most definitely return for more. We live nearly 45 min. from the shop but it's worth the drive. Wish they had a dine in location.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J Gray
Wow! Lindsey's has changed ownership and it certainly shows. I deleted my previous 5 star rating from 7 years ago because it is definitely NOT the same Lindsey's when John owned it up until late in 2024. I suggest you IGNORE all the Google Reviews prior to October of 2024 because things have changed and NOT for the better in my honest opinion.
1) We've had multiple mistakes on our orders several times now. One with the thigh snack pack where they did not include the 3 thighs and were not going to credit us for the shortage because we did not immediately report it. Thankfully one of the employees that knew we were long time customers gave us a credit but not until we had to argue the point. This happened on two separate occasions.
2) They gave us the wrong wings last night as we asked for our traditional barbecue with sauce but instead was given something entirely different as the seasoning was much hotter and spicier and definitely not barbecue. We did not call to report the mistake out of pure frustration knowing that nothing was going to be accomplished. When you arrive at home with your food, you simply want to sit down and enjoy what you supposedly paid for.
3) The window girls now ask you directly if you want to include a TIP. Never before when John owned the place did anyone at the window directly ask for tips. Imagine feeling you have to give a tip on food you don't even know if it is correct yet or tastes good. How about the owner simply pay their employees well enough so they don't feel they have to ask for a tips. I cannot imagine myself asking my customers for tips. Imagine if your package delivery driver asked you for a tip every time he delivered you a package for example.
4) VERY HIGH PRICES compared to all other pizza locations. We paid a total of $67.81 last night for 1 large pizza, an order of barbecue wings which was incorrect, a thigh snack pack (3 thighs, and a breast snack pack - 2 wings) I never minded paying higher prices when John owned it because he was very good to his employees and his employees were very good to us. Truly miss Pat at the window and several others that we had at the window for many many years.
5) The TASTE of the pizza has changed for whatever reason(s). Lindsey's pizza use to be the heaviest most dense flavor filled pizza you could find. Last night, our pizza had less taste and definitely less sauce. More like eating bread with a bit of sauce and cheese than the ratio of the three when John was owner.
6) The addition of the credit card fee is irritating and not charged by all pizza places. Again, when John owned Lindsey's and everything including the employees were top notch, I did not mind paying a credit card fee. Not so much now.
7). Can't forget the precision of the pepperoni placement on the square pizza slices when John owned the shop. Although the same very nice individual still works there sometimes making and cutting the pizza, you would have exactly 4 pepperonis per slice in precision placement on each corner. I often complimented him on that precision and detail. Pepperoni is now scattered about most of the time. A small but noticeable difference that certainly means less pepperoni on each pizza.
Unfortunately, we will not be returning to what was once the best pizza shop around in our opinion and I was around when Pizza Oven first opened on West Tusc back in the 1950's. We have a tradition at our house to have pizza every Saturday night and have a lot of experience with good and bad pizza locations over the years. We wish John the best in his retirement but will certainly miss his ownership and some of his excellent employees that worked there.
Niki Nicholas
By far, the BEST Pizza Place Around !!!
Jessica Croston
Waited 1 1/2 hours for food when told 1 hour. Pizza was fine. First thing was they forgot my sauce for the wings. When I called they said they would give me a credit for the sauce. I’m not eating my wings without sauce so they did end up crediting me for the wings after I had to press. I ordered breaded extra crispy. I received one chicken tender and a couple partially breaded, one not breaded at all. Hopefully I can post pictures bc I have pics of them. The jojos were clearly cooked in old oil. They tasted like burnt smoke. Not edible at all but I’m not calling back at this point. Super disappointed after loving Lindsey’s for many years. The transfer of ownership shows.
Been going here ever since they opened and I still swear they’re the best pizza joint in Canton. Don’t sleep on this place
Sass Williams
Last night was the first time my family and I had Lindsey‘s pizza. I must say it was really good. I appreciate being treated kindly the customer service was really Good we appreciate the free sides as well😉 We will definitely be eating here again .Thank You
Frank Vines
Lindsey's Pizza in Canton, Ohio, is well-loved for its delicious, generously portioned pizzas
We paid $25 for a lrg 1 topping pizza that was all crust & tomato paste - no flavor & hardly any pepperoni or cheese. It was another $25 for 8 of the tiniest pieces of chicken I've ever seen & the skinniest jojos and $3 for coleslaw which was cabbage & mayo only
- no taste! So disappointing - Lindsey's used to be so good until Jon sold it - never again.
Food: 2
So the pizza is pretty good. Square cut. Little bit of flop. Good toppings. However. I’d like the crust to be done a little more and it’s a little on the pricy side. Large will run you about $25ish.
Great hot pizza and the staff is very nice.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Lindsey’s you need to update menu prices. On line says a small Bianca pizza was $7.50. I Picked up and it was $20.50. Are you kidding me, $20.50 for a small pizza. A small pepperoni and mushroom was $17.50. I know prices have increased but that’s ridiculous.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Accidentally on the website ordered GF egg pizza instead of large my bad. It still tasted great anything we typically order from here is good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The girl at the counter walked by me 3 times I had to say something to get my order
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
We were looking for a great new place for pizza. We had pizza, pasta and meatballs for the first time on Sunday. The pizza was delicious, and we will most definitely return for more. We live nearly 45 min. from the shop but it's worth the drive. Wish they had a dine in location.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wow! Lindsey's has changed ownership and it certainly shows. I deleted my previous 5 star rating from 7 years ago because it is definitely NOT the same Lindsey's when John owned it up until late in 2024. I suggest you IGNORE all the Google Reviews prior to October of 2024 because things have changed and NOT for the better in my honest opinion.
1) We've had multiple mistakes on our orders several times now. One with the thigh snack pack where they did not include the 3 thighs and were not going to credit us for the shortage because we did not immediately report it. Thankfully one of the employees that knew we were long time customers gave us a credit but not until we had to argue the point. This happened on two separate occasions.
2) They gave us the wrong wings last night as we asked for our traditional barbecue with sauce but instead was given something entirely different as the seasoning was much hotter and spicier and definitely not barbecue. We did not call to report the mistake out of pure frustration knowing that nothing was going to be accomplished. When you arrive at home with your food, you simply want to sit down and enjoy what you supposedly paid for.
3) The window girls now ask you directly if you want to include a TIP. Never before when John owned the place did anyone at the window directly ask for tips. Imagine feeling you have to give a tip on food you don't even know if it is correct yet or tastes good. How about the owner simply pay their employees well enough so they don't feel they have to ask for a tips. I cannot imagine myself asking my customers for tips. Imagine if your package delivery driver asked you for a tip every time he delivered you a package for example.
4) VERY HIGH PRICES compared to all other pizza locations. We paid a total of $67.81 last night for 1 large pizza, an order of barbecue wings which was incorrect, a thigh snack pack (3 thighs, and a breast snack pack - 2 wings) I never minded paying higher prices when John owned it because he was very good to his employees and his employees were very good to us. Truly miss Pat at the window and several others that we had at the window for many many years.
5) The TASTE of the pizza has changed for whatever reason(s). Lindsey's pizza use to be the heaviest most dense flavor filled pizza you could find. Last night, our pizza had less taste and definitely less sauce. More like eating bread with a bit of sauce and cheese than the ratio of the three when John was owner.
6) The addition of the credit card fee is irritating and not charged by all pizza places. Again, when John owned Lindsey's and everything including the employees were top notch, I did not mind paying a credit card fee. Not so much now.
7). Can't forget the precision of the pepperoni placement on the square pizza slices when John owned the shop. Although the same very nice individual still works there sometimes making and cutting the pizza, you would have exactly 4 pepperonis per slice in precision placement on each corner. I often complimented him on that precision and detail. Pepperoni is now scattered about most of the time. A small but noticeable difference that certainly means less pepperoni on each pizza.
Unfortunately, we will not be returning to what was once the best pizza shop around in our opinion and I was around when Pizza Oven first opened on West Tusc back in the 1950's. We have a tradition at our house to have pizza every Saturday night and have a lot of experience with good and bad pizza locations over the years. We wish John the best in his retirement but will certainly miss his ownership and some of his excellent employees that worked there.
By far, the BEST Pizza Place Around !!!
Waited 1 1/2 hours for food when told 1 hour. Pizza was fine. First thing was they forgot my sauce for the wings. When I called they said they would give me a credit for the sauce. I’m not eating my wings without sauce so they did end up crediting me for the wings after I had to press. I ordered breaded extra crispy. I received one chicken tender and a couple partially breaded, one not breaded at all. Hopefully I can post pictures bc I have pics of them. The jojos were clearly cooked in old oil. They tasted like burnt smoke. Not edible at all but I’m not calling back at this point. Super disappointed after loving Lindsey’s for many years. The transfer of ownership shows.
Restaurantji Recommends
Been going here ever since they opened and I still swear they’re the best pizza joint in Canton. Don’t sleep on this place
Last night was the first time my family and I had Lindsey‘s pizza. I must say it was really good. I appreciate being treated kindly the customer service was really Good we appreciate the free sides as well😉 We will definitely be eating here again .Thank You
Lindsey's Pizza in Canton, Ohio, is well-loved for its delicious, generously portioned pizzas
Pizza was good
Great chicken & jojos.
Loading...