Pirates Cove Pizza & Subs
126 E Main St, Cardington
(419) 864-5766
Customers' Favorites
One Topping Pizza
Large Super Salad
Captain Hook Sub
12 Buccaneer Sub
Deluxe Pizza
Bread Sticks
Italian Sub
Steak Sub
BBQ Wings
Menu
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Best pizza in Morrow County. Hands down. This pizza has come a long way over the last year. Crust has a crunchy bottom with a soft middle. Sauce and cheese are outstanding! Thank you Pirates Cove for being in Cardington serving better pizza than everyone else!
Great hometown pizza shop and friendly service! Let’s start with the pizza, crisp crust, loaded toppings and baked perfectly. Now the Italian sub, I can honestly say was the best I have EVER had tons of toppings wrapped in toasty perfection! I was upset it didn’t have the Italian dressing until I realized that was my fault, it was in the bag to avoid the bread getting soggy LOVE IT! Found my new go to spot for pizza and subs!
Wheelchair accessibility: Entrance...
Wheelchair accessibility: Entrance...
In spite of the negative comment on Facebook, we had a great experience and excellent pizza last Saturday.
Shame on the woman and her negativity!
“If you can’t say something nice - don’t say anything at all.”
You May Also Like
Bunker's Mill Winery - 102 E Main St
![]()
Wineries
Cardington Cafe - 103 E Main St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea, Cafe, Pet Friendly
Suz-Eq's - 401 W Main St
![]()
Pizza