This place is amazing. The staff is great, rhe food is amazing, and the overall mood is good too. We got 2 pizzas and wings. The wings were delicious, and so was the pizza. The sauce is amazing. The only problem we had was there was a peice of plastic in the pizza, and one of my friends bit into the pizza and it got stuck between his teeth. Then the staff tried to blame it on us. Other than that, it was pretty good
Brian Stier
Fun and friendly atmosphere. Was there for a party and had pizza and wings.
Connor Nyahay
Very good service pizza came out fast so did my fried Pepperoni. Going to come back
Griffin Jones
Best pizza ever!
jeffrey van linge
Empty box tells the story!
Angela Madalinski
Great pizza & appetizers were great & not that much. Very friendly staff.
Chuck Hill
Good pie. I travel the lower 48 states for work. This pizza is right up there. Kerry & Terry know what they are doing! Go B.C.!
Brian Rodgers
It was my first visit here at a busy intersection in the small town of Carroll, just northwest of Lancaster off 33. Despite arriving early, upon entering the door to the dining side of the business, I found that there was a wait to be seated.
Now, large crowds do not guarantee quality, but I was cautiously optimistic. If you do find yourself arriving and people are standing in the hall, that means there's a wait for dine-in, as the pick-up area has a separate entrance and waiting area. You'll want to go the head of the line and place a name on the board for your party along with the number of people in your party. Then you wait, and thankfully, the wait wasn't long.
What's better is that the wait was worth it. Service was friendly and fast, the place had an unaffected old-school vibe, and the thin-crust All-the-Way pizza was excellent. I had been looking for a new go-to pizza place near Lancaster, and Shirky's is definitely now in my rotation of spots to visit.
Check it out...I don't think you'll be disappointed at all!
Mike Corrova
Great pizza and salad. The owner and our waitress were very friendly and personable. Will absolutely be back.
First time here, good food… pizza and apps. Service was nice, I’ll be back.
Joseph Fruchey
Some of the best pizza ive ever had.
Carroll Hinton
Just found this place on the internet thought we'd give it a try on way home. Pizza was great we also had the Cuban sub it was ok too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza
Walliam Swiftie
Oh my goodness. This food, the waiters, the decor, is amazing. I come here about 1 time every week and a half its so good and its hometown??
Vegetarian options: Im not vegetarian but they are good with options and telling you if the dishes are vegetarian or not. Lots of options!!
Dietary restrictions: Very friendly gor everything about diets. They listen all the time
Parking: Somewhat small area for parking, especially on busy days like Fridays. You can park on the street, but i have seen better. To be fair it is a small hometown restaurant.
Kid-friendliness: Im 16 and i love to see the adults spending time with their children
Wheelchair accessibility: I see wheelchair spots and I've seen a couple of wheelchair users eat here!! Easy entrance for them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Pickles, Medium Mushroom Pizza, Medium Buffalo Chicken Dip Pizza, Garlic Wings, Large Pepperoni and Onion Pizza, Italian Sub, Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza, Pork Pizza, Steak Sub, blt Pizza, Fried Mushrooms, Wings, Fried Pepperoni, Buffalo Chicken Dip, Hawaiian Pizza, Boneless Wings by the Pound, Pepperoni Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Dip Pizza, All the Way Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Bruce Nelson
First time eating here. Saw the great reviews and had to try it and it didn’t disappoint. Food was great came out hot. Very laid back
Good food will come back thx you
This place is amazing. The staff is great, rhe food is amazing, and the overall mood is good too. We got 2 pizzas and wings. The wings were delicious, and so was the pizza. The sauce is amazing. The only problem we had was there was a peice of plastic in the pizza, and one of my friends bit into the pizza and it got stuck between his teeth. Then the staff tried to blame it on us. Other than that, it was pretty good
Fun and friendly atmosphere. Was there for a party and had pizza and wings.
Very good service pizza came out fast so did my fried Pepperoni. Going to come back
Best pizza ever!
Empty box tells the story!
Great pizza & appetizers were great & not that much. Very friendly staff.
Good pie. I travel the lower 48 states for work. This pizza is right up there. Kerry & Terry know what they are doing! Go B.C.!
It was my first visit here at a busy intersection in the small town of Carroll, just northwest of Lancaster off 33. Despite arriving early, upon entering the door to the dining side of the business, I found that there was a wait to be seated.
Now, large crowds do not guarantee quality, but I was cautiously optimistic. If you do find yourself arriving and people are standing in the hall, that means there's a wait for dine-in, as the pick-up area has a separate entrance and waiting area. You'll want to go the head of the line and place a name on the board for your party along with the number of people in your party. Then you wait, and thankfully, the wait wasn't long.
What's better is that the wait was worth it. Service was friendly and fast, the place had an unaffected old-school vibe, and the thin-crust All-the-Way pizza was excellent. I had been looking for a new go-to pizza place near Lancaster, and Shirky's is definitely now in my rotation of spots to visit.
Check it out...I don't think you'll be disappointed at all!
Great pizza and salad. The owner and our waitress were very friendly and personable. Will absolutely be back.
Restaurantji Recommends
First time here, good food… pizza and apps. Service was nice, I’ll be back.
Some of the best pizza ive ever had.
Just found this place on the internet thought we'd give it a try on way home. Pizza was great we also had the Cuban sub it was ok too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza
Oh my goodness. This food, the waiters, the decor, is amazing. I come here about 1 time every week and a half its so good and its hometown??
Vegetarian options: Im not vegetarian but they are good with options and telling you if the dishes are vegetarian or not. Lots of options!!
Dietary restrictions: Very friendly gor everything about diets. They listen all the time
Parking: Somewhat small area for parking, especially on busy days like Fridays. You can park on the street, but i have seen better. To be fair it is a small hometown restaurant.
Kid-friendliness: Im 16 and i love to see the adults spending time with their children
Wheelchair accessibility: I see wheelchair spots and I've seen a couple of wheelchair users eat here!! Easy entrance for them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Pickles, Medium Mushroom Pizza, Medium Buffalo Chicken Dip Pizza, Garlic Wings, Large Pepperoni and Onion Pizza, Italian Sub, Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza, Pork Pizza, Steak Sub, blt Pizza, Fried Mushrooms, Wings, Fried Pepperoni, Buffalo Chicken Dip, Hawaiian Pizza, Boneless Wings by the Pound, Pepperoni Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Dip Pizza, All the Way Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
First time eating here. Saw the great reviews and had to try it and it didn’t disappoint. Food was great came out hot. Very laid back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: All the Way Pizza
Loading...