Cibik's Dairy Island

So much variety!

I've passed this place many times but my husband stopped with our daughter since she was wanting ice cream on a hot day. I was surprised when he walked up with a cup of vegan ice cream for me! I did not expect how good that bite was going to be: it's sweet and creamy coconut ice cream with dark chocolate chunks, shredded coconut, and pineapple. Apparently they often have vegan chocolate (they were out today but I would have chosen this coconut flavor over that myself) and dole whip. I'm sure we will go back!

Today, I used my ID showing my 1975 birth year in order to get my free ice cream. The young man taking my order was so congratulatory and joyful to see my birthday. He made me feel very celebrated. What a wonderful place and wonderful staff that make you feel like they are truly happy about giving a free treat, sincere generosity!!

Some of the best ice cream I've ever had! I got the lemon bar hard serve and a peanut butter malt shake, both were so flavorful and delicious

Good Ice Cream

Great place to grab a frozen treat and play some miniature golf… but sometimes you’ll have to wait, it gets busy because it’s good!

Wonder staff and amazing ice cream. Definitely coming back!

Really good ice cream, but prices are just a tiny bit steep

I had trouble deciding on what to order because there's so many options here. You can have ice cream, frozen custard, and more in lots of different formats - shakes, sundaes, etc. They don't have any coffee flavored ice cream regularly, but I wish they did because that would make it easier for me to order. There's a coffee flavored shake, though, so that's confusing. I was overwhelmed with all the choices, but I saw a lot of things I wanted to try. A lot of the flavors weren't clear to me like what a pirate's booty or tin roof sundae would be.

I ended up getting the Mississippi mud pie sundae because I was taking too long and know nothing can go wrong with that. They gave me a large portion of whipped cream - the most I've seen in my life, and there was a good amount of chocolate syrup. I noticed all the sundaes and hurricanes in my group had vanilla, but I wonder if I could have had a different flavor instead of vanilla, which isn't clear on the menu without asking. I also got to taste a peanut butter shake, which was a nice consistency. I'd probably have to get a shake next time because those have the flavors I like the most and are the most simple to figure out straight from the list.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Could add more tables and keep them clean. The ice cream is good but a little expensive for what you get.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

family owned local ice cream, one of my favorites always something interesting, love the old fashion banana split.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Snickers Sundae, Waffle Cone, Hot Fudge Fantasy, Banana Split, Hot Fudge Peanut Parfait, D Ice Cream Sandwich, Cibik's Craft Butter Pecan

Ice cream paradise!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good quality ice cream. A bit pricier than DQ or other smaller ice cream venues. Staff is friendly. They accept both cash and card. It can get quite busy on weekend evening and parking is sometimes and issue.

The treats are delicious. The prices are a little high. The line is long at peak times but moves quickly.

Parking: Plenty of parking around the shop or in the lot next door.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Didn’t get what I asked for but what I got was nice so I can’t complain ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Create Your Own Ice Cream