Nothing special about this place. I honestly probably won't eat here again. Nothing bad happened....just not for me. I'd say the best part was the service, but even it was par. 🦈💙
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Will T
The pizza is really good, service was great, good prices. The breadsticks that you get are basically just hot dog buns that are toasted with Parmesan cheese on them, the kids love them though
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Trisha Bowles
Prices are getting out of hand. Subs are messy when you get them or have way too much of something on them. Tabletops are ALWAYS dirty. Molly's the friendliest one in there. Management never comes out to visit paying guests.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Henry Thompson
Fantastic place to eat and enjoy a meal. Service was great waitress was very attentive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jenny Finley
Poppers were delicious! Loved the thin crispy crust on the personal pizza. Philly cheese steak pizza was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nan Lieber
First out waitress was fabulous. Bent over backwards to do her job. Lady friend riend & I ordered a large pep, pineapple ham, sausage , mushroom pizza. Half & half. We ate it all but I found myself sprinkling sugar on mine as the sausage is so dry tasting. Needs serious tweaking. The ham on my side was incredibly salty & I picked off. The pizza crust was so thin and burnt in places, and hard to chew given some dental work I had. Overall we had to dab the pizza with napkins to absorb the grease. Spent $26 total. Personally I won’t be back. Can’t speak for my friend. She’ll eat anything. Oh we about froze to death it was so cold, the cheap speakers were blaring Rediculouslly loud music a genre I generally avoid if I can. Rediculous for a restaurant. Pizza flavor & quality at the Buckeye lake location is much better and enjoyable. Put less sugar on it. Pizza at Newark location enjoyable with a little sugar but doesn’t taste as good as buckeye lake. They said it’s the difference in water they think. I think the circleville local needs to not skimp so much on the crust and fix their sauce. I drive by a lot & don’t see very many cars there. I’ve loved in the area since 2019 from Nerk.
David Crego
Consistently good, fresh salads, above average pizza. Other items look good, too, but it's my go-to for pizza.
Irvin Morgan
My girlfriend stopped and picked up my favorite BLT pizza and drove it to me 3 hours. Wasn't hot but the BLT is the best leftover pizza I ever had. Haven't had it in over 20years, still made and tasted the same. Wish I had a Pizza Cottage near me.
Please save yourself from the despair of trying to order online or via the phone in AI . Second time of ordering for delivery 1) found out it can’t be done :( 2) when the pizza did arrive after a phone call and total of 2 hrs later. The pizza was the original order & just as cold as you can easily imagine. No 3 strike rule, 2 and you’re out Pizza Cottage
Russ Funk
Food was good, place was fine but the server was 100% and really made it a great time!
Melinda Adams
Server was very friendly and made sure to tell us about the special for that day. Ordered onion rings for and appetizer and they was very good. Came out hot and fresh with cheddar cheese sauce. Pizza was a bit spicy for me, but very good. We got a pepperoni with extra cheese pizza. Would definitely recommend.
jeannie & mark
Always good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John
We were ticket 2 for the day, ate right at opening. Food was great and waitress was great. The only negative food comment will be we ordered the cheese bread. I would have thought at a pizza restaurant The cheese bread would be the same bread or dough as pizza but it was a sub bun toasted with cheese. Not the best. The pizza was delicious. The restaurant was clean to look at but the floors were very sticky, shoes would stick at the table and when going to the bathroom which means they don't mop properly at closing. The music was loud and not family friendly. They played a lot of heavy metal with songs that had profanity throughout them. It is a possible return again but hope they have softer playing, more family friendly music.
Great server, loaded baked.potato pizza was 🔥
My #1 pizza place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nothing special about this place. I honestly probably won't eat here again. Nothing bad happened....just not for me. I'd say the best part was the service, but even it was par. 🦈💙
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
The pizza is really good, service was great, good prices. The breadsticks that you get are basically just hot dog buns that are toasted with Parmesan cheese on them, the kids love them though
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Prices are getting out of hand. Subs are messy when you get them or have way too much of something on them. Tabletops are ALWAYS dirty. Molly's the friendliest one in there. Management never comes out to visit paying guests.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Fantastic place to eat and enjoy a meal.
Service was great waitress was very attentive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Poppers were delicious! Loved the thin crispy crust on the personal pizza. Philly cheese steak pizza was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First out waitress was fabulous. Bent over backwards to do her job. Lady friend riend & I ordered a large pep, pineapple ham, sausage , mushroom pizza. Half & half. We ate it all but I found myself sprinkling sugar on mine as the sausage is so dry tasting. Needs serious tweaking. The ham on my side was incredibly salty & I picked off. The pizza crust was so thin and burnt in places, and hard to chew given some dental work I had. Overall we had to dab the pizza with napkins to absorb the grease. Spent $26 total. Personally I won’t be back. Can’t speak for my friend. She’ll eat anything. Oh we about froze to death it was so cold, the cheap speakers were blaring Rediculouslly loud music a genre I generally avoid if I can. Rediculous for a restaurant.
Pizza flavor & quality at the Buckeye lake location is much better and enjoyable. Put less sugar on it. Pizza at Newark location enjoyable with a little sugar but doesn’t taste as good as buckeye lake. They said it’s the difference in water they think. I think the circleville local needs to not skimp so much on the crust and fix their sauce. I drive by a lot & don’t see very many cars there. I’ve loved in the area since 2019 from Nerk.
Consistently good, fresh salads, above average pizza. Other items look good, too, but it's my go-to for pizza.
My girlfriend stopped and picked up my favorite BLT pizza and drove it to me 3 hours. Wasn't hot but the BLT is the best leftover pizza I ever had. Haven't had it in over 20years, still made and tasted the same. Wish I had a Pizza Cottage near me.
Restaurantji Recommends
Please save yourself from the despair of trying to order online or via the phone in AI .
Second time of ordering for delivery 1) found out it can’t be done :(
2) when the pizza did arrive after a phone call and total of 2 hrs later. The pizza was the original order & just as cold as you can easily imagine. No 3 strike rule, 2 and you’re out Pizza Cottage
Food was good, place was fine but the server was 100% and really made it a great time!
Server was very friendly and made sure to tell us about the special for that day. Ordered onion rings for and appetizer and they was very good. Came out hot and fresh with cheddar cheese sauce. Pizza was a bit spicy for me, but very good. We got a pepperoni with extra cheese pizza. Would definitely recommend.
Always good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were ticket 2 for the day, ate right at opening. Food was great and waitress was great. The only negative food comment will be we ordered the cheese bread. I would have thought at a pizza restaurant The cheese bread would be the same bread or dough as pizza but it was a sub bun toasted with cheese. Not the best. The pizza was delicious. The restaurant was clean to look at but the floors were very sticky, shoes would stick at the table and when going to the bathroom which means they don't mop properly at closing. The music was loud and not family friendly. They played a lot of heavy metal with songs that had profanity throughout them. It is a possible return again but hope they have softer playing, more family friendly music.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...