An amazing array of interesting flavors you can't find anywhere else!
Dan Jay
I was visiting my sister's family down in PA with my mom and they decided to take us to Heavenly Creamery just across the border into Ohio. First off, it's a very cool renovation of an older church and it still has an altar area and stained glass, as you can see in some of the photos. I'd rather see a building get used and serve a purpose than slowing decaying and becoming a dilapidated eyesore. The interior itself was clean and had a ma and pop feel to it.
The ice cream itself was amazing and the variety of unique flavors and options was quite impressive. I personally tried the lemon-lime and the honey flavors and loved both of them. My mother loves spicy food so he went with mango habanero and also loved it, as it may have been the most unique ice cream flavor she has ever tried. The employees were all very friendly and offered free samples before ordering. The place was quite busy but not too overcrowded as there is a good amount of seating indoors and outdoors. I am not surprised at all that Heavenly Creamery currently has a 4.9 star Google rating as I write this. I would highly recommend checking this place out if you haven't as it strikes me as one of those hidden gems that chain establishments just can't compete with.
Andrea M
Great ice cream and staff!
Mary Dolan
There is a line of locals out the door! Soft serve was Excellent! Yum! They have a lot to choose from banana splits to sundaes and MORE.
Peter Wurst
Great ice cream and service!!
Dave
Best ice cream hands down! Several flavors to choose from. Being in a old church makes it unique. Staff is very friendly! Highly recommend you visit this hidden gem!!!
srv3355
Ice creams pretty darn good and the girls they had waiting on people were very friendly, what else can you ask for?
The Plagued Moose
One I love it here! I would definitely recommend to a lot of people! Due to the ice cream being homemade and having lots of flavors that are changed regularly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Dietrich Sr
Excellent homemade ice cream.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brandy Brooke
They have the best ice cream, hands down. Unique, delicious flavors. Always great service. I’m counting down the days til July so I can get more of their corn & raspberry flavor and my teen is obsessed with cereal milk. So glad to have them!
The ice cream is great. So many choices. However the customer service from Ava and Sydney were TOP NOTCH. it has been awhile since I've witnessed service above and beyond like that (probably pre pandemic) these ladies were helpful and friendly to each customer. They were just genuinely happy people. Making awesome suggestions to people, helping them to choose items, offering other item suggestions. The owner should be very proud.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Color Changing
Matt B
A huge variety of hard ice cream, soft serve, and other treats makes this a place to visit in Conneaut. Lots of options for cones, sundaes, and toppings. Staff behind the counter have always been extra nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katelynn Hribar
The best ice cream around! The stained glass windows are so gorgeous and the staff is super nice! I will continue to bring my family here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nikki Vinyl
The tastiest ice cream and a color changing spoon is what I love the most. Constantly changing ice cream flavors, all homemade, unique flavor combos, the Most atmospheric spot !
I got maple walnut and banana chocolate peanut butter. They were great but choc p.b. Stole the show !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cool Guy
The ice cream stuffed donut is my new go to desert especially with the tiramisu or apple pie flavor. the staff is polite and good at their jobs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cone, Cannoli, Cheesecake, Apple Turnover Sunday
An amazing array of interesting flavors you can't find anywhere else!
I was visiting my sister's family down in PA with my mom and they decided to take us to Heavenly Creamery just across the border into Ohio. First off, it's a very cool renovation of an older church and it still has an altar area and stained glass, as you can see in some of the photos. I'd rather see a building get used and serve a purpose than slowing decaying and becoming a dilapidated eyesore. The interior itself was clean and had a ma and pop feel to it.
The ice cream itself was amazing and the variety of unique flavors and options was quite impressive. I personally tried the lemon-lime and the honey flavors and loved both of them. My mother loves spicy food so he went with mango habanero and also loved it, as it may have been the most unique ice cream flavor she has ever tried. The employees were all very friendly and offered free samples before ordering. The place was quite busy but not too overcrowded as there is a good amount of seating indoors and outdoors. I am not surprised at all that Heavenly Creamery currently has a 4.9 star Google rating as I write this. I would highly recommend checking this place out if you haven't as it strikes me as one of those hidden gems that chain establishments just can't compete with.
Great ice cream and staff!
There is a line of locals out the door! Soft serve was Excellent! Yum! They have a lot to choose from banana splits to sundaes and MORE.
Great ice cream and service!!
Best ice cream hands down! Several flavors to choose from. Being in a old church makes it unique. Staff is very friendly! Highly recommend you visit this hidden gem!!!
Ice creams pretty darn good and the girls they had waiting on people were very friendly, what else can you ask for?
One I love it here! I would definitely recommend to a lot of people! Due to the ice cream being homemade and having lots of flavors that are changed regularly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent homemade ice cream.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They have the best ice cream, hands down. Unique, delicious flavors. Always great service. I’m counting down the days til July so I can get more of their corn & raspberry flavor and my teen is obsessed with cereal milk. So glad to have them!
Restaurantji Recommends
The ice cream is great. So many choices. However the customer service from Ava and Sydney were TOP NOTCH. it has been awhile since I've witnessed service above and beyond like that (probably pre pandemic) these ladies were helpful and friendly to each customer. They were just genuinely happy people. Making awesome suggestions to people, helping them to choose items, offering other item suggestions. The owner should be very proud.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Color Changing
A huge variety of hard ice cream, soft serve, and other treats makes this a place to visit in Conneaut. Lots of options for cones, sundaes, and toppings. Staff behind the counter have always been extra nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best ice cream around! The stained glass windows are so gorgeous and the staff is super nice! I will continue to bring my family here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The tastiest ice cream and a color changing spoon is what I love the most.
Constantly changing ice cream flavors, all homemade, unique flavor combos, the Most atmospheric spot !
I got maple walnut and banana chocolate peanut butter. They were great but choc p.b. Stole the show !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The ice cream stuffed donut is my new go to desert especially with the tiramisu or apple pie flavor. the staff is polite and good at their jobs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cone, Cannoli, Cheesecake, Apple Turnover Sunday
Loading...