Our favorite ice cream place! We drive from Erie several times a year.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cone
Linda Kauppila
Quaint old Church turned into a great ice cream creamery. Delicious ice cream!
Christopher Johnston
Neat church converted into a great ice cream shop. Lots of unique flavors and fairly priced. Discovered by accident, but worth a trip back! Service was excellent too.
Jim Rey
Excellent name for an Heavenly treat just wish you had one in Pennsylvania. Staff went above and beyond expectations, my daughter wanted a Not Your Typical Sundae Service T-shirt they were out of her size in store, the staff went out of there way to make sure she had one before we left. Not many places would go out of there way to do something like that. We will definitely be back.
Susan Branz
Love the church building with all the stained glass, and the pews as table benches. The ice cream was wonderful and the owner gave us all the history of the church.
Margie Netzel
Delicious ice cream (and so many toppings!) served up in a repurposed church. They also feature keto friendly ice cream. We love Heavenly Creamery!
Sue Slider
Lots of choices of hard serve ice cream flavors. Pricing is fair, the employees were exceptionally friendly. Would recommend this place to take your family for a treat.
Roger Nolan
Great ice cream and very inventive flavors. The old church provides a heavenly atmosphere. Very friendly service.
Gary H.
Yummy good ice cream with excellent service. Drove an hour to get there and definitely worth the drive.
Katerina Zeppos
We were pleasantly surprised by this location. The service was good and the ice cream was good. Many flavors to choose from
Ice cream was delicious. I had the breakfast flavor. It was French toast flavor and pieces of bacon in it.
julie tomlinson
Unique setting being in a church with pews as part of seating. Lots of varieties of flavors. Friendly staff. Would recommend for a break from the summer heat.
Shawna Mckendrick
Yum the best ice cream and very friendly there
. Denisejohn65 - Nail Ed
Very good ice cream . I had the peanut butter .It’s very pricey for ice cream … wow !Glad I finally did try it . I love the atmosphere .
Carole Klaue
What a charming use for an old small church in Conneaut, ohio. Super clean. Limited on site parking, but close by parking available. They have added a handicap ♿️ ramp, so many can enjoy the place. Not sure on restroom size as did not use. This is close to Conneaut Harbor.
Our favorite ice cream place! We drive from Erie several times a year.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cone
Quaint old Church turned into a great ice cream creamery. Delicious ice cream!
Neat church converted into a great ice cream shop. Lots of unique flavors and fairly priced. Discovered by accident, but worth a trip back! Service was excellent too.
Excellent name for an Heavenly treat just wish you had one in Pennsylvania. Staff went above and beyond expectations, my daughter wanted a Not Your Typical Sundae Service T-shirt they were out of her size in store, the staff went out of there way to make sure she had one before we left. Not many places would go out of there way to do something like that. We will definitely be back.
Love the church building with all the stained glass, and the pews as table benches. The ice cream was wonderful and the owner gave us all the history of the church.
Delicious ice cream (and so many toppings!) served up in a repurposed church. They also feature keto friendly ice cream. We love Heavenly Creamery!
Lots of choices of hard serve ice cream flavors. Pricing is fair, the employees were exceptionally friendly. Would recommend this place to take your family for a treat.
Great ice cream and very inventive flavors. The old church provides a heavenly atmosphere. Very friendly service.
Yummy good ice cream with excellent service. Drove an hour to get there and definitely worth the drive.
We were pleasantly surprised by this location. The service was good and the ice cream was good. Many flavors to choose from
Restaurantji Recommends
Ice cream was delicious. I had the breakfast flavor. It was French toast flavor and pieces of bacon in it.
Unique setting being in a church with pews as part of seating. Lots of varieties of flavors. Friendly staff. Would recommend for a break from the summer heat.
Yum the best ice cream and very friendly there
Very good ice cream . I had the peanut butter .It’s very pricey for ice cream … wow !Glad I finally did try it . I love the atmosphere .
What a charming use for an old small church in Conneaut, ohio. Super clean. Limited on site parking, but close by parking available. They have added a handicap ♿️ ramp, so many can enjoy the place. Not sure on restroom size as did not use. This is close to Conneaut Harbor.