These pies are terrible. The pie shells aren’t even half full.
Christina Littler
These pies are the worst pies ever!!! Never will I purchase these again. Bought them through my daughter’s fundraiser and they’re awful. The coconut cream pie was not even a cream pie it was merengue. Who puts merengue on a coconut cream pie!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
john mcmanus
We bought these pies for my daughter's School fund raider. The pest were TERRIBLE!!! All the pies that were supposed to be crab actually had merengue topping!!!??? Disgusting!! Nobody wants a chocolate merengue or coconut merengue pie!!! I'm also disappointed in our school for not checking the quality before supporting a company like this .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jc Cordray
The chocolate pie was terrible, tasted like jello pudding gone bad. Def not worth the $13 it cost me.
Noah R.
The Pie Peddler helped our small Church, New Beginnings, in Louisa Ky. to raise over 3000.00 in our annual fund raiser. The pies are delicious and the service they give is outstanding. Larry, our delivery guy, takes the time to make sure our order is correct. And Polly is the kindest lady to work with in the world. I Highly Recommend using the Pie Peddler Pies as a fund raiser for any organization. We look forward each year to their delicious pies.
BOOSHman85
Terrible quality control and taste. It's a shame that you can get a better pie from a big box store.
Michael Seflers
First photo is what I received, second photo is what they show on their website. The taste and texture of this Dutch apple pie was ok but nothing special.
Tracy Freeland
I purchased the Dutch apple pie from my granddaughters school fundraiser. It was a lattice apple pie with some crumbly stuff sprinkled in the middle. I am disappointed. I won't order again from them.
Connie Swigart
The Coconut is just like my grandmother made me. Love there pies
Theresa DiPaolo
Ordered the Chocolate pie for a schools fundraiser, instead of where's the beef it was more like where's the chocolate? I can only hope the apple and pecan are better. Only 1/4 of the pie was chocolate the rest was meringue, very disappointing.
Ordered thru a charity and I was VERY DISAPPOINTED. Pie was almost all apple syrup GEL hardly any chunks of apple in the classic APPLE pie. Will never order from here again.
William Myers
It used to be Mahaffey's Pies it was Delicious,It is still great pies.Strawberry is what most people recommend when asked Apparently there is pie businesses there.Anyways Mehaffey's has been there for a long time and highly recommend it.
Cole Hoover
The negative reviewers are a bunch of flapjack trout hootgivers. Eye spy with my little eye a delicious cherry pie!!!
Shannon Sheley
Ordered a pecan pie thru a fundraiser and it taste rancid
Hope curtner
These are the best pies!!! Cant wait for another fund raiser to order more!
These pies are terrible. The pie shells aren’t even half full.
These pies are the worst pies ever!!! Never will I purchase these again. Bought them through my daughter’s fundraiser and they’re awful. The coconut cream pie was not even a cream pie it was merengue. Who puts merengue on a coconut cream pie!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We bought these pies for my daughter's School fund raider. The pest were TERRIBLE!!! All the pies that were supposed to be crab actually had merengue topping!!!??? Disgusting!! Nobody wants a chocolate merengue or coconut merengue pie!!! I'm also disappointed in our school for not checking the quality before supporting a company like this .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The chocolate pie was terrible, tasted like jello pudding gone bad. Def not worth the $13 it cost me.
The Pie Peddler helped our small Church, New Beginnings, in Louisa Ky. to raise over 3000.00 in our annual fund raiser. The pies are delicious and the service they give is outstanding. Larry, our delivery guy, takes the time to make sure our order is correct. And Polly is the kindest lady to work with in the world. I Highly Recommend using the Pie Peddler Pies as a fund raiser for any organization. We look forward each year to their delicious pies.
Terrible quality control and taste. It's a shame that you can get a better pie from a big box store.
First photo is what I received, second photo is what they show on their website. The taste and texture of this Dutch apple pie was ok but nothing special.
I purchased the Dutch apple pie from my granddaughters school fundraiser. It was a lattice apple pie with some crumbly stuff sprinkled in the middle. I am disappointed. I won't order again from them.
The Coconut is just like my grandmother made me. Love there pies
Ordered the Chocolate pie for a schools fundraiser, instead of where's the beef it was more like where's the chocolate? I can only hope the apple and pecan are better. Only 1/4 of the pie was chocolate the rest was meringue, very disappointing.
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered thru a charity and I was VERY DISAPPOINTED. Pie was almost all apple syrup GEL hardly any chunks of apple in the classic APPLE pie. Will never order from here again.
It used to be Mahaffey's Pies it was Delicious,It is still great pies.Strawberry is what most people recommend when asked Apparently there is pie businesses there.Anyways Mehaffey's has been there for a long time and highly recommend it.
The negative reviewers are a bunch of flapjack trout hootgivers. Eye spy with my little eye a delicious cherry pie!!!
Ordered a pecan pie thru a fundraiser and it taste rancid
These are the best pies!!! Cant wait for another fund raiser to order more!