We were excited to try this new place called Romeo's. They have a full menu. With pizzas, deep dish, calzones, strombolis, wings, bread, and desserts. The staff were very friendly and helpful when we were asking questions about the menu. They even found a coupon to help us! We tried the pepperoni maniac stromboli and the meat Stromboli. Both were delicious. I only wish we could've eaten inside, but its carry out only at this location. Would stop here again!
I ordered a pizza with half pepperoni and the other half deluxe chicken, which should include mushroom and red onion. However, for some reason, the deluxe part wasn't shown on the order, and the final pizza just turned out to be a mix of plain pepperoni and chicken. I didn’t see any mushroom or red onion on it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Bentley Bland Shuller
I ordered double toppings on 2 small pizzas…paid $25 for each pizza & still received with barely one serving of toppings……I wanted a pile of veggies. 😔 Guess I won’t be ordering again. Pick up is ridiculous. The parking is horrific. Wake Forest location.
Gary Carter
Ordered on two different occasions and received bad orders both times. They left off ingredients we paid for and didn't provide the marinara dipping sauce that was advertised to come with the orders. They instead gave us a nasty Capone Sauce. They also didn't identify which calzone was which (ordered two different kinds). We had to cut them open to see the difference.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Lizz Longbrake
I just came across this place today. I have never heard of it before, but I am so glad I stopped in. The lady told me about the lunch special and I wanted to try it. It was ready within 10 minutes and it was the best pizza I've ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Rover T
I have tried this location a few times, and the most recent times they have been on point. On time, excellent quality. The manager Brad is so helpful and offered a great customer experience. I know I am going home with the most delicious and quality pie when I see him. Thank you for being the best pizza in Dayton<3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Will Jay
Wanted to try this pizza coming locally to me very soon so I took a drive to another town to give it a shot. Great service, the guy we dealt with I wish I had remembered his name but I think he was a manager was very welcoming, great energy and even gave us a respectable coupon as 1st time customers.
My pizza was half sausage, half meatball, all pepperoni. I would say it was just about average chain pizza. The sauce & crust were the stars as the sauce has a very good sweetness to it if you enjoy that like we do. Crust was solid to above average. The meatballs were pretty solid as well.
I didn't care for the cheese, it just came across as a very cheap pizza cheese used in many chain joints. The sausage quickly turned me off and I removed it from the pizza, just didn't like the taste and the appearance of it was unappealing a very dark sausage, unusual looking for a pizza. The pepperoni was a bit larger circumference wise than usual and was kinda greasy, it was edible if you could get past the greasiness.
Overall I'd give it about a 6.2, edible & even good in some ways but some real turnoffs as well. If they had different cheese & pork sausage I would easily give it a 7.5, an 8 if they had old world pepperoni instead or just more crispy pepperoni. I would try again and probably will because the sauce is soo good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Rebecca Tipton
The Buffalo Chicken pizza was doused with hot sauce, instead of drizzled. After we removed some of the hot sauce, it was delicious. This location is convenient to our home and the BOGO was wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jason Nagel
So good. I think they are using San Marazano tomatoes in their sauce. Coupled with the Capone and Garlic butter sauce to experience.a true culinary delight
Cassie Rollins
sorry it used to be my favorite but the past couple of times it's been bad. first they didn't make my order until I was in the store (and no mushrooms?) The next time I ordered all the topping were in the center of the pizza. I might try again bc I like the sauce but idk
Online ordering was so easy. Just ordered, so waiting on delivery, but have had their pizzas before & they are wonderful. Expecting the same with this order. Not been in their restaurant.
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Lauren
The first time we got Romeo’s, it was great and you could tell the employees cared. Lately, they couldn’t care less to do their jobs or keep the customers informed of what’s going on with their order. I waited an hour before cancelling my DoorDash order due to them assigning a new dasher and the pizza still not being ready. Save yourself the time and hassle and order pizza from somewhere else.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Mark K
Used an online coupon to try this place out. Placed order over phone and showed up 20 mins later and my pizza eas ready straight from the oven. Tasted great. Looked great. Was great. No marks for atmosphere as there isn't a true dining area. Pick up the pie and go. The Capone Sauce is great as well.
Protip: get your pizza well-done.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Teresa Wright
Loved the sauce on the pizza not spicy and it was just right.
We were excited to try this new place called Romeo's. They have a full menu. With pizzas, deep dish, calzones, strombolis, wings, bread, and desserts. The staff were very friendly and helpful when we were asking questions about the menu. They even found a coupon to help us! We tried the pepperoni maniac stromboli and the meat Stromboli. Both were delicious. I only wish we could've eaten inside, but its carry out only at this location. Would stop here again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Maniac Calzone, Breadsticks
I ordered a pizza with half pepperoni and the other half deluxe chicken, which should include mushroom and red onion. However, for some reason, the deluxe part wasn't shown on the order, and the final pizza just turned out to be a mix of plain pepperoni and chicken. I didn’t see any mushroom or red onion on it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
I ordered double toppings on 2 small pizzas…paid $25 for each pizza & still received with barely one serving of toppings……I wanted a pile of veggies. 😔 Guess I won’t be ordering again. Pick up is ridiculous. The parking is horrific. Wake Forest location.
Ordered on two different occasions and received bad orders both times. They left off ingredients we paid for and didn't provide the marinara dipping sauce that was advertised to come with the orders. They instead gave us a nasty Capone Sauce.
They also didn't identify which calzone was which (ordered two different kinds). We had to cut them open to see the difference.
Food: 1
Service: 1
I just came across this place today. I have never heard of it before, but I am so glad I stopped in. The lady told me about the lunch special and I wanted to try it. It was ready within 10 minutes and it was the best pizza I've ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
I have tried this location a few times, and the most recent times they have been on point. On time, excellent quality. The manager Brad is so helpful and offered a great customer experience. I know I am going home with the most delicious and quality pie when I see him. Thank you for being the best pizza in Dayton<3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wanted to try this pizza coming locally to me very soon so I took a drive to another town to give it a shot. Great service, the guy we dealt with I wish I had remembered his name but I think he was a manager was very welcoming, great energy and even gave us a respectable coupon as 1st time customers.
My pizza was half sausage, half meatball, all pepperoni. I would say it was just about average chain pizza. The sauce & crust were the stars as the sauce has a very good sweetness to it if you enjoy that like we do. Crust was solid to above average. The meatballs were pretty solid as well.
I didn't care for the cheese, it just came across as a very cheap pizza cheese used in many chain joints. The sausage quickly turned me off and I removed it from the pizza, just didn't like the taste and the appearance of it was unappealing a very dark sausage, unusual looking for a pizza. The pepperoni was a bit larger circumference wise than usual and was kinda greasy, it was edible if you could get past the greasiness.
Overall I'd give it about a 6.2, edible & even good in some ways but some real turnoffs as well. If they had different cheese & pork sausage I would easily give it a 7.5, an 8 if they had old world pepperoni instead or just more crispy pepperoni. I would try again and probably will because the sauce is soo good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
The Buffalo Chicken pizza was doused with hot sauce, instead of drizzled.
After we removed some of the hot sauce, it was delicious. This location is convenient to our home and the BOGO was wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
So good. I think they are using San Marazano tomatoes in their sauce. Coupled with the Capone and Garlic butter sauce to experience.a true culinary delight
sorry it used to be my favorite but the past couple of times it's been bad. first they didn't make my order until I was in the store (and no mushrooms?) The next time I ordered all the topping were in the center of the pizza. I might try again bc I like the sauce but idk
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious warm pizza with a very friendly staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Online ordering was so easy. Just ordered, so waiting on delivery, but have had their pizzas before & they are wonderful. Expecting the same with this order. Not been in their restaurant.
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
The first time we got Romeo’s, it was great and you could tell the employees cared. Lately, they couldn’t care less to do their jobs or keep the customers informed of what’s going on with their order. I waited an hour before cancelling my DoorDash order due to them assigning a new dasher and the pizza still not being ready. Save yourself the time and hassle and order pizza from somewhere else.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Used an online coupon to try this place out. Placed order over phone and showed up 20 mins later and my pizza eas ready straight from the oven. Tasted great. Looked great. Was great. No marks for atmosphere as there isn't a true dining area. Pick up the pie and go. The Capone Sauce is great as well.
Protip: get your pizza well-done.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved the sauce on the pizza not spicy and it was just right.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Loading...