First time having lefty’s pizza was in may! I had just moved here. Very sad to hear they are closing.
Jason Miranda
The absolute best deal and best tasting pizza in Northwest Ohio. 24 inch pizza for 24.50? no one can beat this price. 2.5 times bigger than the 16 inch... the stats speak for themselves = 48 ounces of dough, 3.5 cups of sauce, 1.5 pounds of cheese. THE DOUGH THOUGH. PERFECT FLAVOR, PERFECT CRISP! A fan for life for sure.
Mark Rothman
nowhere to park hardly at all They should have stayed in their old location. Ordered chicken tonight. Skin was so hard I chipped a tooth trying to eat it. Said my order would take 45 minutes. I think my food cooked the whole time. Cooked all the juice out of it. It was inedible. Waste of 20 bucks.
Morvin Dixon
Great local pizza spot. Can't wait to see the full plans for the new space.
Tina Lester
The Best Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza! Even if you don’t like Ranch, I bet you’ll like it. I just wish they had thin & crispy crust. The Broaster chicken meals are very good. The Cheapest delivery fee in town! Make sure you tip your driver well. Hoping to be able to order online some day instead of having to call in.
Andrew Parker
I used to like the place when they were in their old location. I tried to order today and was onhold for close to 5 minutes.... had to order elsewhere
Kyle Phoenix
In-freaking-credible! There used to be only one pizza place that could earn a 5-star rating from me ... until now. Definitely the best pizza in Defiance and possibly in NW Ohio, or at least tied for it. The cinnamon bites are beyond sinful. Pizza sub is really good. Don't much care for the pickle on the side, but that's the only thing I could say negative. Going to enjoy exploring the rest of their menu! Not open on Monday, which blows, but just means you have to plan ahead if you want great food.
Nora Dale
Waited 1 1/2 hours and couldn’t get ahold of anyone to see if they are going to deliver the darn thing
Shannon Bass
Their pizza and Lefty bread are delicious!
Kelly Layne
Terrible experience at this restaurant tonight. Wish I could give it 0 stars. First off I didnt receive the 2 sides that came with my family meal (according to the extremely large lit up hanging menu board), and then was charged 1 dollar more than than that menu specified. Manager Alexis refused to return my dollar or give me the additional side that was supposed to be in my meal stating, "I don't know why that says that, you only get one side. And the price in my computer is the right price. She also refused to put me in contact with her superior saying "Dave was busy at his other job".
Just a heads up to anyone who orders pizza. I ordered one from Lefty's 2 hours ago, and decided I have been patient enough, and call to see what is going on. The girl on the phone gets my info and talks to her boss. She then tells me sorry, but they are closed so they can't do anything. I reply, so what do you mean you can't do anything? What happened? The girl replies she doesn't know, but if I call tomorrow I can get one for free. I reply I work tomorrow, I assume I can get one on my next day off? The girl then has to ask her boss again, and then hesitantly says sure. Anyone else think that waiting for 2 hours just to get told you're SOL, and we don't know what happened, warrants more than a free pizza on my next day off?
Tracy Anton
My family and I stopped on our way to our Hotel after our 12hr drive STARVING and when ordered asked what came with the 3pc tenders, the cashier said she didn't know then asked someone else in which we were told biscuits and wedges, after getting back to our room there were NO sides and small BURNT Chicken pieces. I called management and was told there was nothing they could do, not even offer anything else. I have pictures to show upper management tomorrow as I was told they don't know when management will be in.
Patdino 2820
They have really great pizza!
Deb Sybert
shout out to the very rude person taking phone orders today who offended 2 separate people who tried to place orders for mercy clinic
Kenny-Linz Peterson
We usually love Lefty's but this last time we dined in a brunette maybe late 30's waited on us... dropped the pizza spatula on the floor, stuck in back in our pizza right in front of us. They put the wrong toppings on our pizza. I mentioned it to the waitress, she did not correct it or apologize. It was supper time and they were busy as well as short staffed. I probably wouldn't have said anything if she would have at least said hey sorry let me get you a new spatula. the long blonde haired delivery driver brought us one as he saw what happened. He is a great employee that we always see work hard. We visit a couple times a month as we live out of town. Love the blonde man that usually manages the place! He also does an awesome job and we have never had a problem when he is working.
First time having lefty’s pizza was in may! I had just moved here. Very sad to hear they are closing.
The absolute best deal and best tasting pizza in Northwest Ohio. 24 inch pizza for 24.50? no one can beat this price. 2.5 times bigger than the 16 inch... the stats speak for themselves = 48 ounces of dough, 3.5 cups of sauce, 1.5 pounds of cheese. THE DOUGH THOUGH. PERFECT FLAVOR, PERFECT CRISP! A fan for life for sure.
nowhere to park hardly at all They should have stayed in their old location. Ordered chicken tonight. Skin was so hard I chipped a tooth trying to eat it. Said my order would take 45 minutes. I think my food cooked the whole time. Cooked all the juice out of it. It was inedible. Waste of 20 bucks.
Great local pizza spot. Can't wait to see the full plans for the new space.
The Best Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza! Even if you don’t like Ranch, I bet you’ll like it. I just wish they had thin & crispy crust. The Broaster chicken meals are very good. The Cheapest delivery fee in town! Make sure you tip your driver well. Hoping to be able to order online some day instead of having to call in.
I used to like the place when they were in their old location. I tried to order today and was onhold for close to 5 minutes.... had to order elsewhere
In-freaking-credible! There used to be only one pizza place that could earn a 5-star rating from me ... until now. Definitely the best pizza in Defiance and possibly in NW Ohio, or at least tied for it. The cinnamon bites are beyond sinful. Pizza sub is really good. Don't much care for the pickle on the side, but that's the only thing I could say negative. Going to enjoy exploring the rest of their menu! Not open on Monday, which blows, but just means you have to plan ahead if you want great food.
Waited 1 1/2 hours and couldn’t get ahold of anyone to see if they are going to deliver the darn thing
Their pizza and Lefty bread are delicious!
Terrible experience at this restaurant tonight. Wish I could give it 0 stars. First off I didnt receive the 2 sides that came with my family meal (according to the extremely large lit up hanging menu board), and then was charged 1 dollar more than than that menu specified. Manager Alexis refused to return my dollar or give me the additional side that was supposed to be in my meal stating, "I don't know why that says that, you only get one side. And the price in my computer is the right price. She also refused to put me in contact with her superior saying "Dave was busy at his other job".
Restaurantji Recommends
Just a heads up to anyone who orders pizza. I ordered one from Lefty's 2 hours ago, and decided I have been patient enough, and call to see what is going on. The girl on the phone gets my info and talks to her boss. She then tells me sorry, but they are closed so they can't do anything. I reply, so what do you mean you can't do anything? What happened? The girl replies she doesn't know, but if I call tomorrow I can get one for free. I reply I work tomorrow, I assume I can get one on my next day off? The girl then has to ask her boss again, and then hesitantly says sure. Anyone else think that waiting for 2 hours just to get told you're SOL, and we don't know what happened, warrants more than a free pizza on my next day off?
My family and I stopped on our way to our Hotel after our 12hr drive STARVING and when ordered asked what came with the 3pc tenders, the cashier said she didn't know then asked someone else in which we were told biscuits and wedges, after getting back to our room there were NO sides and small BURNT Chicken pieces. I called management and was told there was nothing they could do, not even offer anything else. I have pictures to show upper management tomorrow as I was told they don't know when management will be in.
They have really great pizza!
shout out to the very rude person taking phone orders today who offended 2 separate people who tried to place orders for mercy clinic
We usually love Lefty's but this last time we dined in a brunette maybe late 30's waited on us... dropped the pizza spatula on the floor, stuck in back in our pizza right in front of us. They put the wrong toppings on our pizza. I mentioned it to the waitress, she did not correct it or apologize. It was supper time and they were busy as well as short staffed. I probably wouldn't have said anything if she would have at least said hey sorry let me get you a new spatula. the long blonde haired delivery driver brought us one as he saw what happened. He is a great employee that we always see work hard. We visit a couple times a month as we live out of town. Love the blonde man that usually manages the place! He also does an awesome job and we have never had a problem when he is working.