I called Our Cupcakery because I had lost track of time and I was desperately looking for a gluten-free carrot cake in a very short amount of time. Not only were they kind and understanding they helped me problem solve with assorted gluten-free cupcakes including several carrot cake ones. They were packaged beautifully and were fresh and delicious!! They have a new client! Thank you for saving the day for me!!!
Christopher Bell
A few years ago when Short North Piece of Cake closed, Our CupCakery made us a cake for our wedding on short notice and it was delicious. Great people and cake, couldn’t recommend more! Thank you Laura!
Josie Reinitz
Our CupCakery did a fantastic job with our wedding cake! It looked beautiful and tasted just as good — we got so many compliments from our guests.
They offered a great variety of flavors during the tasting, and the final product was exactly what we envisioned. The team was easy to work with, responsive, and handled delivery and setup without a hitch.
Highly recommend!
Kara R
Strawberry filling was not good. No strawberries. Minimal artwork on cake (I didn’t ask for much but thought, it being professional, that it would look better than a grocery store cake). I did not have high expectations but was shocked as I have ordered cakes for events for years from other bakery’s and received much better results. Very high priced but not high quality. I don’t mind paying for a cake when it’s quality matches. Icing was good. Owner (I think) was not very kind at pick up. I did not complain about anything at pick up. I wish it had gone better, I don’t typically write bad reviews.
Anisha Prakash
We hired Our Cupcakery to make our wedding cake. Laura not only baked us the most delicious cake, she decorated it exactly as we wanted! Definitely coming back for any other cake needs😍
Katie and Nish
We ordered cupcakes and a small wedding cake from Our Cupcakery for our wedding. Laura and the entire team did such a fantastic job of working with us to select flavors and deliver the desserts the day of the wedding. The cupcakes and cake themselves were amazing! We got so many compliments from our guests about how good they were. We can’t recommend Our Cupcakery enough!
Rosemary Davis Carr
Went to a cookie decorating class in 2/2/25. I like the fact they were very into cleanliness and handwashing. I also ordered chocolate cupcakes with caramel and chocolate icing and cake pops with mermaid sprinkles. The class was fun but would not recommend anything other than a class. My cupcakes did not taste very good. In fact the bottoms of some of them were discolored ( lighter brown), meaning they were old or spoiled. Either way they were not edible. By the time we arrived home, the glob of icing had slid off three of the cupcakes. I did not order these with sprinkles and nonpareil balls, but had sprinkles all over them. I should’ve looked at them before we left the shop. I can’t stand sprinkles especially nonpareil balls. Why would you do that? The colors were different from the cake pop colors. So someone thought that I should have sprinkles and nonpareils on my cupcakes? Gross! The cake pops looked fabulous but were only half baked and gooey to wet on the inside. Had to throw those out too! I paid $70 for a dozen cake pops and 6 cupcakes. Definitely not with the money that I paid. I will definitely not be going back there! Don’t waste your time or money!
Mackenzie Hackleman
If there’s one thing guests always talk about after a wedding, it’s the food—especially the dessert! And let us tell you, Our CupCakery delivered perfection. If you’re in Central Ohio and want the best-tasting cakes and cupcakes, look no further.
From the very start, Laura made the process incredibly easy. She took the time to go over every detail of our wedding cake, ensuring it was exactly what we envisioned. Their cake batter? Moist, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. Their frosting? Perfectly balanced—not overly sugary. Instead, they created a stunning cake that was both beautiful and delicious. Their cheesecake rounds were a huge hit as well!
One thing we especially loved was their attention to presentation. They even provided elegant cake and dessert stands, making our treats look like something straight out of a fairy tale ballroom. And if you want fresh flowers on your cake, no problem—they’ll coordinate with your florist to make sure everything comes together flawlessly. And it truly did. Our wedding cake the day of the wedding looked exactly the way we had imagined and more. Just was absolutely breathtaking!
But here’s the best part—our wedding desserts were so good that we actually went back after our wedding just to get more! That’s how irresistible their cakes and cupcakes are. Our favorite being the lemon cake with raspberry buttercream icing.
If you want to ensure your guests leave with full hearts and happy bellies, Our CupCakery is the place to go. We couldn’t recommend them enough!
Libby Bauman
We worked with Laura for our wedding cake and highly recommend OurCupCakery! Laura helped us create the wedding cake of our dreams and went above and beyond to be sure the colors would match our wedding colors. The cake was delicious, and people complimented it all night. The team took great care of our family heirloom cake topper, too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Sara Wolfe
We ordered around 200 cupcakes for our wedding and they KNOCKED IT OUT OF THE PARK. Laura was so sweet and so so easy to work with. She delivered and set up our cupcake display, which was BEAUTIFUL. Our guest are still talking about how delicious the cupcakes were 2 days after! If you are in or around the Columbus area and need cupcakes or cake for your wedding or any other event Our Cupcakery is who you need!
This place has the kindest workers and the best cupcakes I’ve ever had in my life. The chocolate chip cookie dough cupcake is the perfect amount of sweet. The seasonal gingerbread cupcake was absolutely perfect. They’re awesome!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle Sherer
Best cupcakes! You must try the signature buttercream!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Wedding Cake, Custom Cupcake Order
Meg U
Our Cupcakery is an amazing place to get a cupcake or regular cake. The customer service is great and they work hard to make everything look beautiful. We just had our wedding and they did a phenomenal job with the cake and used our wedding flowers to decorate it further. The almond buttercream frosting is five stars. All our guests kept telling us how good the cake was! We’re very pleased with how it turned out and will go back many times in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Janel Oldfield
Our vanilla flavored wedding cake with almond buttercream frosting was so beautiful and delicious! Guests were raving about it. Highly recommend OurCupcakery for your event :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristin Bruce
They made the cake exactly the way I wanted and it was delicious.
I called Our Cupcakery because I had lost track of time and I was desperately looking for a gluten-free carrot cake in a very short amount of time. Not only were they kind and understanding they helped me problem solve with assorted gluten-free cupcakes including several carrot cake ones. They were packaged beautifully and were fresh and delicious!! They have a new client! Thank you for saving the day for me!!!
A few years ago when Short North Piece of Cake closed, Our CupCakery made us a cake for our wedding on short notice and it was delicious. Great people and cake, couldn’t recommend more! Thank you Laura!
Our CupCakery did a fantastic job with our wedding cake! It looked beautiful and tasted just as good — we got so many compliments from our guests.
They offered a great variety of flavors during the tasting, and the final product was exactly what we envisioned. The team was easy to work with, responsive, and handled delivery and setup without a hitch.
Highly recommend!
Strawberry filling was not good. No strawberries. Minimal artwork on cake (I didn’t ask for much but thought, it being professional, that it would look better than a grocery store cake). I did not have high expectations but was shocked as I have ordered cakes for events for years from other bakery’s and received much better results. Very high priced but not high quality. I don’t mind paying for a cake when it’s quality matches. Icing was good. Owner (I think) was not very kind at pick up. I did not complain about anything at pick up. I wish it had gone better, I don’t typically write bad reviews.
We hired Our Cupcakery to make our wedding cake. Laura not only baked us the most delicious cake, she decorated it exactly as we wanted! Definitely coming back for any other cake needs😍
We ordered cupcakes and a small wedding cake from Our Cupcakery for our wedding. Laura and the entire team did such a fantastic job of working with us to select flavors and deliver the desserts the day of the wedding. The cupcakes and cake themselves were amazing! We got so many compliments from our guests about how good they were. We can’t recommend Our Cupcakery enough!
Went to a cookie decorating class in 2/2/25. I like the fact they were very into cleanliness and handwashing. I also ordered chocolate cupcakes with caramel and chocolate icing and cake pops with mermaid sprinkles. The class was fun but would not recommend anything other than a class. My cupcakes did not taste very good. In fact the bottoms of some of them were discolored ( lighter brown), meaning they were old or spoiled. Either way they were not edible. By the time we arrived home, the glob of icing had slid off three of the cupcakes. I did not order these with sprinkles and nonpareil balls, but had sprinkles all over them. I should’ve looked at them before we left the shop. I can’t stand sprinkles especially nonpareil balls. Why would you do that? The colors were different from the cake pop colors. So someone thought that I should have sprinkles and nonpareils on my cupcakes? Gross! The cake pops looked fabulous but were only half baked and gooey to wet on the inside. Had to throw those out too! I paid $70 for a dozen cake pops and 6 cupcakes. Definitely not with the money that I paid. I will definitely not be going back there! Don’t waste your time or money!
If there’s one thing guests always talk about after a wedding, it’s the food—especially the dessert! And let us tell you, Our CupCakery delivered perfection. If you’re in Central Ohio and want the best-tasting cakes and cupcakes, look no further.
From the very start, Laura made the process incredibly easy. She took the time to go over every detail of our wedding cake, ensuring it was exactly what we envisioned. Their cake batter? Moist, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. Their frosting? Perfectly balanced—not overly sugary. Instead, they created a stunning cake that was both beautiful and delicious. Their cheesecake rounds were a huge hit as well!
One thing we especially loved was their attention to presentation. They even provided elegant cake and dessert stands, making our treats look like something straight out of a fairy tale ballroom. And if you want fresh flowers on your cake, no problem—they’ll coordinate with your florist to make sure everything comes together flawlessly. And it truly did. Our wedding cake the day of the wedding looked exactly the way we had imagined and more. Just was absolutely breathtaking!
But here’s the best part—our wedding desserts were so good that we actually went back after our wedding just to get more! That’s how irresistible their cakes and cupcakes are. Our favorite being the lemon cake with raspberry buttercream icing.
If you want to ensure your guests leave with full hearts and happy bellies, Our CupCakery is the place to go. We couldn’t recommend them enough!
We worked with Laura for our wedding cake and highly recommend OurCupCakery! Laura helped us create the wedding cake of our dreams and went above and beyond to be sure the colors would match our wedding colors. The cake was delicious, and people complimented it all night. The team took great care of our family heirloom cake topper, too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
We ordered around 200 cupcakes for our wedding and they KNOCKED IT OUT OF THE PARK. Laura was so sweet and so so easy to work with. She delivered and set up our cupcake display, which was BEAUTIFUL. Our guest are still talking about how delicious the cupcakes were 2 days after!
If you are in or around the Columbus area and need cupcakes or cake for your wedding or any other event Our Cupcakery is who you need!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This place has the kindest workers and the best cupcakes I’ve ever had in my life. The chocolate chip cookie dough cupcake is the perfect amount of sweet. The seasonal gingerbread cupcake was absolutely perfect. They’re awesome!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best cupcakes! You must try the signature buttercream!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Wedding Cake, Custom Cupcake Order
Our Cupcakery is an amazing place to get a cupcake or regular cake. The customer service is great and they work hard to make everything look beautiful. We just had our wedding and they did a phenomenal job with the cake and used our wedding flowers to decorate it further. The almond buttercream frosting is five stars. All our guests kept telling us how good the cake was! We’re very pleased with how it turned out and will go back many times in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Our vanilla flavored wedding cake with almond buttercream frosting was so beautiful and delicious! Guests were raving about it. Highly recommend OurCupcakery for your event :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They made the cake exactly the way I wanted and it was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...