Poppy's Elida Depot

430 E Kiracofe Ave, Elida
(419) 677-0505

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Bonnie Little-Rode

Twice in the past 2 visits my order was wrong!! Dude was too busy on his phone and wouldn’t even put it down to fill the order. Dude wouldn’t talk above a whisper, I guess he didn’t want to interrupt the cell convo! Such BS!!! Bye Poppy’s you USE TO BE awesome

Joshua Ricker

Ordered twice before and was blown away at how good the Detroit Style Pizza was. Just went again and unfortunately didnt look at the food until I was home. The "Chef Salad" was just a box of bad lettuce, cut-up Kraft Singles, and like 5 eggs (No Turkey, Ham, Croutons, or Provolone as stated on the menu) Pizza was mid at best... nothing like previous visits. The pizza is expensive but was worth the price.... emphasis on WAS. I feel like I got taken. Huge disappointment.

Micheline Ricker

It has been months since we’ve ordered Poppy’s and then it was good. Ordered tonight and it is absolute garbage. The chef salad was old lettuce, chunks of tomato, 5 hard boiled eggs sliced up and cut up kraft cheese slices. No meat, no other veggies, not worth the $10.29 we were charged. The pizza is subpar to what it used to be as well. Called and asked what is on their chef salad and the guy who answered said he did not know and told hold on and then sat the phone down and after 10 minutes of waiting I finally hung up. So if you like being ripped off order from here but if not, go elsewhere.

Sarah Smith

Have only had their food once when the previous owner had it and it was good. But the service there now is terrible. Couldn't get help from the employee because he was too busy talking and flirting with the carful of women in front of me for a good 10 minutes!!

Bob W

Take your business elsewhere 15.99 for a 6 pack of busch lime is insane

Candy Halt

For my first visit to this establishment it was very memorable. I went last evening at their busiest time but the staff was great.The food was absolutely amazing and delicious!!! I will be returning. The blue Gatorade was awesome

Dustin Jackson

3 and a half hours for a single pizza?
The guys working in the drive through is a joke.
Horrible service. Shitty food

Dannii Miller

Food is always great now and uses quality ingredients, never disappointed! Has items that I want now. my new favorite drive thru closer to home.

Ariel Stiffler

Yeahh... Waited a good hour or more for my food. I ordered, then drove there(10/15 minutes). Arrived was told there was an issue with pricing. Then they had to make it. Waited 40/45 minutes or so on my food. Then while waiting, there's just a lady worker walking back and forth screaming on her phone about someone. All the while I'm just waiting here for my food. Tried to call the store to get someone's attention, no answer. Yeah, I won't be ordering again.

McKenna

Called late and he opened up grill to make my pizzas. Excellent food and service. Will definitely be back.

Riselle Bonner Jr.

Food was so delicious! Best pizza and wings in town. 10/10

Danielle Shrider

This place is under new ownership and you can tell. IT IS HORRIBLE. Do not order from here.

I placed an order at 11 and had to wait a 1.5 hours to get my pizzas. When I got home they got my order wrong too. I had to make my kids chicken nuggets because they put mushrooms on their pepperoni pizza. My slice was doughy and very under cooked.

They won't be getting my money ever again. Horrible!!!!

Larry Siferd

Great pizza, onion rings, and bread sticks. On our first visit, we arrived to pick up our order and were told that the pizza had been overcooked and that a fresh one would be ready in five minutes. It was and they gave us both pizzas! Very ethical. Additionally, both were delicious. Highly recommend !!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sauce, Build Your Own - 16 Poppy's Round Pizza

Faith Vatran

Walked in and bought the 18” Traditional Pepperoni Parmesano and Buffalo Chicken Pizza and the customer service was amazingggg, very lovely and kind people that was the first sign that our pizza was gonna be great. Our pizza was piping hot until we got to our destination but we couldn’t help but to eat it on the way because we were so excited and WE WERE NOT DISAPPOINTED ? ? it was definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a while. First off, the pizzas were HUGE, the crust had the most perfect crunch to it and the flavors were amazing, you could tell the ingredients were fresh and we were getting good cheese pulls with every slice. I’m glad to know that I have such a good quality pizza place near me. Papa John’s, Pizza Hut, etc is out Fresh Local Pizza is IN!!!!!!!!! I would definitely recommend good experience, good pizza, fair pricing, will definitely be going back to try more flavors!! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon

Linda

Ordered food for lunch as a group. I got a sub, it was greasy and flavorless. Other people weren't impressed with their items. Prices seemed high for what we got.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Loading...