The Olde Thyme Pantry

626 E Main St, Elida
(419) 331-2855

Recent Reviews

Maggie Staup

I love this store so much! They have the best chocolate milk get it if you see it there, they also have really good corn salsa. We go there often.

Craig Fruchey

Best meat and cheese in Allen

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

95phoebe ish

Olde thyme pantry is a wonderful little bulk grocery. We so enjoy visiting for their large selection of delicious meats and cheeses. They carry a variety of local, unique items including a candy isle and a large gluten free section. The associates are VERY helpful, pleasant to see and interact with. The sweet, humble, modest atmosphere keeps you coming back to this lovely place. Highly recommend a visit!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alex M (Zombiebytez)

Great place and friendly staff

Ashleigh king

Great, quality selection. And friendly staff.

Debbie B.

I love having a place like this so close to where I live. They have a great selection of candy, sauces, spices, cheese, deli meat, cookies, and so on. Most of the people who work there are some of the nicest people I've met. I usually stop in to grab the cheese pizza pretzels, the cereal marshmallows, and something from the chocolate aisle. My friend who usually goes with me loves their hot cheese cups and the sauces they have to offer. The dip mixes are great too and the baked goods on the rack towards the back are tasty! Sometimes the prices are a little higher on some things but it's a very clean store and just fun to visit.

Rodney W. Horst

Great quality products that are sure to please. Mike stands behind the customer and his product. If you want to shop local and be confident that you are going to get a great experience, shop Olde Thyme Pantry!

Ashley Williams

Beautiful clean store! Very friendly, and awesome service!! My grandma won't shop anywhere else for specific things! We always highly recommend to everyone!

Aaron Erickson

This is my go to for deli. My wife has worked there for years! Fast and friendly service! Some Amish countries good such as Bunker Hill cheese can be found here, same as Heini's Cheese Chalet in Millersburg, Ohio!

Jerry Sites

Shop their quite often good ? service and a lot of different products

Scott Swinehart

Fabulous love this little store great prices and awesome products along with lovely customer service ?

Michael Allen

Great place for bert good lunch meat and cheeses. Huge variety of both meat and cheeses at great prices. Beats any super market in town on variety taste and value. They also carry bbq a variety of other products that I haven't really explored as of yet. The store is Mennonite owned and then staff are very friendly. I highly recommend!!!

Ryan Dicke

This place is awesome. Great selection of meats, cheeses and other items . The ladies working there are so kind and friendly. Highly recommend stopping and checking them out.

Luke Schraffenberger

Wonderful item's at a wonderful price!Thank you!

Penny Kohli

I love this place! It's always kept clean, friendly service, excellent quality deli cheeses and meats. Great variety of herbs and spices. I only wish they were open later in the day

Load More